Page 1 of 2
Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 12:32 am
by Ryce
Is hand to hand combat good in oblivion? Cause in elder scrolls 3, hand to hand was horrible. Good as in capable to killing enemies.
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 12:35 am
by Kestral
I don't like hand to hand. The range is too short, and it's hard to pack much of a punch when compared to other combat styles.
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 12:44 am
by ace62394
Kestral wrote:it's hard to pack much of a punch
Pun intended?
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 12:49 am
by Kestral
ace62394 wrote:Kestral wrote:it's hard to pack much of a punch
Pun intended?
No.
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 12:51 am
by A-BIack_Man
hand to hand damages their fatigue whenver you hit them, so if youre going against a guy with a huge, heavy hammer, it might be helpful, as you could just punch him to the ground and keep him there
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 12:53 am
by Kestral
A-BIack_Man wrote:hand to hand damages their fatigue whenver you hit them, so if youre going against a guy with a huge, heavy hammer, it might be helpful, as you could just punch him to the ground and keep him there
Fatigue doesn't seem to have much of an effect in Oblivion as it did in Morrowind, so, lowering your enemie's fatigue won't help. It probably won't go down fast enough, too.
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 1:04 am
by A-BIack_Man
its good as a second method, say like your fighting a person, and they take a huge swing at you, back up, take out your fists, and punch him. he falls, you bring out your weapon, and swing away
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 4:36 am
by Leilah
I love hand to hand. Punch punch punch. I practise against rats and mudcrabs until I can take on stronger enemies. It may not do very much damage, but I get a great kick out of it.
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 5:04 am
by leroybrown
I use it. I doubt its more effective than sword or something. Its really fun though makes me feel like steven segaul.
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 9:10 am
by shadow_of_sithis
i like H2H specially with khajiits! i just jumpoed around them and punch and run around them while punching! im like the super hero! (who works undercover as a DB assassin!)
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 11:04 am
by ectoplasm
good, im a apprentice at it and i went to do the shivering isles (felldew quest) and i owned the creatures in 2 blows
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 11:48 am
by Lorkmir
I LOVE HAND TO HAND!
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 1:23 pm
by Kaelan Corvinus
Hand to Hand can be a very useful skill if done correctly.
First of all, you can't really compare it to the other melee skills in the game because if you do, it will look like a waste of time.
-Hand to Hand is the quickest mode of attack in the game, so for the player looking to be the quick, agile combatant, Hand to Hand is the way to go.
-Hand to Hand is a little more practical than the other ways of fighting. You never have to repair your hands.
-Because of the quickness of your attacks, your character is able to hit and then maneuver a little easier than you would if you were swinging a 2-handed weapon or a longsowrd.
There are some drawbacks to Hand to Hand, but there are drawbacks to every fighting style in the game, so Hand to Hand is no different.
-The first and most obvious would be the low damage when compared to the other styles.
-The second is the fact that you can't enchant your hands, therefore using Hand to Hand will never allow you to have in magical effects.
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 2:15 pm
by Mattbott
i agree
i really like the sneak attack jab with h2h
Problems with punching: you also suffer damage if you block with hand to hand - perhaps greaves could sort this out a bit in the next game (i kind of hoped those fortify 30 h2h greaves you can steal from the chest belonging to the sparring fighters in the arena outside area might have done this)
and can't poison your hands, but as we see in the Sarkoy assassins of Jack Vances Demon Princes books (books 1 and 3 esp), a way could be done to do this - for instance, you have 100 in alchemy (Poisons) and 75+ in hand 2 hand. This could involve introducing 'cross over' perks from reaching certain skill levels. A bit like in 3rd edition d&d where you get synergy between skills. They sort of have it in oblivion already with the roll away perk which you get that's a bit acrobatic and a bit block. I hope they expand on it to give us lots of nice little abilities in the next game. If you had poisonous hands, though, it would screw up your ability to have friendly physical contact with people, so maybe it's not a great example. But there's no reason why these perks can't have bad points to them so long as things don't get too complicated.
I think hand to hand damage could definitely be improved for races with claws and if they expand the combat system we could see for fancier h2h moves. Someone with 75+ hand 2 hand might crit a lot more and if you have 100 you do damage more in line with martial weapons. I'm imagining Bruce Lee or Mike Tyson-like character potential here, not your casual alchemist who gets into the occasional pub fight.
Perhaps a high speed could improve your fatigue damage and high strength could improve the damaging damage part, depending on your characters style.
this skill, combined with a good spellcasting ability, is ace with the infiltrate the mythic dawn base quest. It's almost worth making up a kung fu mage just to do that mission imo
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 5:48 pm
by Bode
I like hand to hand because it's fun, but it's not very practical compared to blunt or blade. Mods can balance it out a little, especially those that make fatigue more important. I remember taking a good ten or fifteen minutes punching down two minotaur lords for strength training once, good times.
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 11:43 pm
by Ryce
If Im hand to hand, how should I deal with undead/ghost? Spells or is there such thing as enchanting fist with elements ?
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 11:47 pm
by Teinaava
Ryce wrote:If Im hand to hand, how should I deal with undead/ghost? Spells or is there such thing as enchanting fist with elements ?
Once you become a Journeyman (50) in Hand to Hand, you'll be able to damage anything that's immune to normal weapons, such as ghosts.
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 11:56 pm
by Olarim
Well, since I just had to uninstall and reinstall my pc version of Oblivion. Ill give Hand to Hand a go and see if I like it.
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2009 4:18 am
by Leilah
Ryce wrote:If Im hand to hand, how should I deal with undead/ghost? Spells or is there such thing as enchanting fist with elements ?
No, you can't enchant your fists. I'd suggest having a backup silver weapon or a few spells until you become a journeyman - that's what I do.
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2009 11:24 pm
by King Acunasti
It isn't that fun or funny unless you have a Chuck Norris character.
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2009 11:57 pm
by Xaeryx
I might try Hand to Hand as a major skill at some point, the stationary shoryuken power attack is worth it with the ragdoll physics.
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Wed Aug 26, 2009 4:37 am
by leroybrown
Xaeryx wrote:I might try Hand to Hand as a major skill at some point, the stationary shoryuken power attack is worth it with the ragdoll physics.
I now like you more than most on this forum. Mainly on account of you knowing what a "shoryuken" is. Its safe to assume that you also know what a "haduken" is.
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Wed Aug 26, 2009 4:51 am
by Reaper67

There is no need to publicly state favorites. I take no offence but I can't say that for everyone. Anywho, I had some fun with h2h when I was fighting Baurus in the sewers. Some of you may have seen the thread I made about training in the beginning sewers. I broke his katana with my face and took it then fought him h2h and it was like a boxing ring. It does take a while but I learned that eventually their fatigue will get low enough to where they will go down with every punch. The best part was that we both got to that point at the same time.
Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Wed Aug 26, 2009 3:07 pm
by Xaeryx
leroybrown wrote:Xaeryx wrote:I might try Hand to Hand as a major skill at some point, the stationary shoryuken power attack is worth it with the ragdoll physics.
I now like you more than most on this forum. Mainly on account of you knowing what a "shoryuken" is. Its safe to assume that you also know what a "haduken" is.
lmao, yes, I wonder if there's a hadouken mod to hurl blue fireballs...
Oh well, it turns out the stationary power attack changes at higher H2H skill levels.

Re: Hand to Hand Good/Bad?
Posted: Wed Aug 26, 2009 9:18 pm
by skooma
Kestral wrote:The range is too short,
Yep. The main reason I don't use H2H as a primary combat skill is the short range.