Page 1 of 1

Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 12:31 pm
by Cloud_Nine
This is a thought ive had for a long time, the thought that the Magicka increase should work the same as health increases

Health increases by 10% of your endurance level every time you gain a level, my thought is that your magicka should increase by 10% of you intelligence level at the same time, it just seems unfair to me that health continues to increase while your magicka is stuck at the same it was when you were just level 20.

After all, you've earned the level, shouldnt you earn the right to higher magicka?

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 1:24 pm
by Symmachus
Totally! But that would just make the already superior mage class completely invincible...

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 1:26 pm
by Kaelan Corvinus
Agreed.

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 1:28 pm
by Cloud_Nine
Symmachus wrote:Totally! But that would just make the already superior mage class completely invincible...
I was under the impression it already was :D

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 1:34 pm
by Dogmantra
If anything, health should work the same as magicka, because with magicka it doesn't matter whether you increased your intelligence to 100 asap, or if you waited until level 40 or so, you'll always have 200 (I think it's 2 x INT...), but with health, if you don't max endurance, you're missing out on health.

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 1:35 pm
by Kaelan Corvinus
Cloud_Nine wrote:
Symmachus wrote:Totally! But that would just make the already superior mage class completely invincible...
I was under the impression it already was :D
Not really, because my Witchhunter, who has killed hundreds of Conjurers and Necromancers, can testify to the fact that Mages are NOT invincible. :Twisted Evil:

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 1:47 pm
by Cloud_Nine
Kaelan Corvinus wrote:
Cloud_Nine wrote:
Symmachus wrote:Totally! But that would just make the already superior mage class completely invincible...
I was under the impression it already was :D
Not really, because my Witchhunter, who has killed hundreds of Conjurers and Necromancers, can testify to the fact that Mages are NOT invincible. :Twisted Evil:
Of course NPC mages aren't invincible, simply put: they're stupid. But whether or not mages are invincible really is beside the point
Dogmantra wrote:If anything, health should work the same as magicka, because with magicka it doesn't matter whether you increased your intelligence to 100 asap, or if you waited until level 40 or so, you'll always have 200 (I think it's 2 x INT...), but with health, if you don't max endurance, you're missing out on health.
I disagree, if health worked the same as magicka did we'd all be stuck at whatever the max health would be but the creatures we fight would still be gaining more health as we grow stronger and into higher levels, of course this wouldnt make a difference past level 20, but before that

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 1:52 pm
by Kaelan Corvinus
Okay, ease up, buddy. It was a joke.

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 1:56 pm
by Cloud_Nine
Kaelan Corvinus wrote:Okay, ease up, buddy. It was a joke.
did i sound too serious? :?

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 2:02 pm
by Kaelan Corvinus
Cloud_Nine wrote:
Kaelan Corvinus wrote:Okay, ease up, buddy. It was a joke.
did i sound too serious? :?
:D Nah, its cool.

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 2:16 pm
by m@nyt1mes
This is actually an amazing idea, because then even the most mundane, stupid barbarian can be adaped relatively quickly to be a decent mage. raise magicka costs for spells, and you would be set!

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 2:33 pm
by Loserbumo
Well, Im not overly interested in mages but this does seem like a valid point. I've never even really been content with the health increase either. I'd rather it be like warcraft where you have tons of health but, you can hit for like 1600 damage in one swing.Instead of just the 10% of my 32 endurance..... Back to the point: This would be a great thing for mages but not for me. Good idea it just wont have any effect on me.

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 2:35 pm
by m@nyt1mes
Loserbumo wrote:Well, Im not overly interested in mages but this does seem like a valid point. I've never even really been content with the health increase either. I'd rather it be like warcraft where you have tons of health but, you can hit for like 1600 damage in one swing.Instead of just the 10% of my 32 endurance..... Back to the point: This would be a great thing for mages but not for me. Good idea it just wont have any effect on me.
health is 2X endurance, + 10% of your endurance every time you level up.

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 3:26 pm
by shadow_of_sithis
Yeah this is totally true! i agee completely

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 3:28 pm
by Dogmantra
Cloud_Nine wrote:I disagree, if health worked the same as magicka did we'd all be stuck at whatever the max health would be but the creatures we fight would still be gaining more health as we grow stronger and into higher levels, of course this wouldnt make a difference past level 20, but before that
If health worked like magicka, the creatures would be tweaked too...

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 3:45 pm
by m@nyt1mes
that would make perfect sense in a way, because at higher levels, magic is essentially the health of most pure mages, saying that when it runs out, they are pretty much dead, and i know how much even the slightest difference in endurance can mean:
I had a custom built warrior(replaced h2h and blade with acrobatics and restoration)
and a dark knight(same as above, but conjuration, no restoration)
the dark knight had the apprentice sign, the warrior had the lady sign, same race, same class attributes, so the DK had 55 endurance, the W had 65, and at level 30 , there was about 75 or so in health difference (530 as opposed to 450, or at least in that ballpark) which is a considerable amount considering they took a +5 to endurance each level till it was at 100

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 4:06 pm
by Cloud_Nine
Loserbumo wrote:This would be a great thing for mages but not for me. Good idea it just wont have any effect on me.
That's just it, it would have an effect on you, on everybody, melee-based characters have to cast spells too, mainly restoration spells, and stealth based characters cast illusion spells when their sneak cant get the job done, increasing magicka allows you to cast them more without having to wait as long for your magicka to regenerate, and you're probably not that skilled in the spells you're casting so they're weak so you have to cast them over and over to get the effect you want which consumes the majority if not all of your magicka making it more difficult to cast them again when you need them most

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 4:10 pm
by m@nyt1mes
i actually think it would be the opposite, along with the magicka change, it should make spells more expensive to cast, making it HARDER for the mundane characters to cast spells.

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 6:57 pm
by Dark Spark
If you wanted Health treated just like Magicka, then it'd fully regenerate within seconds, just like Magicka does...

...bottom line, they're two very different things. The fact that Magicka regenerates in real-time more than balances what petty limitations you see imposed on its maximum quantity.

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 7:00 pm
by scribbane
Dark Spark wrote:If you wanted Health treated just like Magicka, then it'd fully regenerate within seconds, just like Magicka does...

...bottom line, they're two very different things. The fact that Magicka regenerates in realtime more than balances what petty limitations you see imposed on its upper limits.

This is a good point. I still think that it would be cool if it increased like health, but maybe not as much? Maybe instead of 10% of your Intel, it could be like 5% or something like that. However Dark Spark does have a very valid point in the sense that with a high enough willpower, and a smartly made character, total amount of magicka would not be too much of an issue.

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 8:07 pm
by Yaije
if anything the birthsigns should be like they were in morrowind. apprentice, mage, and atronach increasedhow much magicka per intellect you got rather than just a straight fortify magicka that was constant :Twisted Evil:

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 9:24 pm
by adibobo
I think that Yaije is right, because , even at level 30, a barbarian or other melee class or just a character who uses magic rarely having a high amount of mana is unrealistic. Hovewer intellect is raised if you use magic ofthen, and the situation becomes more realistic since even a character who didn't use magic originaly, but who started using it frequenteley midway whould become more inteligent and have more magica.

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Thu Jul 30, 2009 7:30 am
by Symmachus
Some comments mentioned that the maximum amount of magicka is not so important becuase with enough Willpower magicka returns quickly anyway.

However, your maximum amount of magicka does place a cap on the magnitude of your spells. Powerful custom spells could be made because whether or not you can cast a spell depends on the amount of magicka you have and your skill level, not how fast your magicka returns.

With more magicka and a slower regeneration rate a mage could cast a few truly powerful spells and be made to wait longer or use more potions. It would open up a lot of possibilities like longer Conjuration times, more powerful direct-damage spells or spells with longer durations... It would also create different styles of play. Cast a few really strong spells and run out of magicka, or lots of little ones that because of quick regeneration will never leave the mage running on empty?

Also, by making magicka increase every level with respect to intelligence would not give barbarians oodles of magicka because just as a mage who never puts points into endurance will end up with low health so the same will happen to warriors.

This mechanism would also reinforce that there are different kinds of mages, like the high Intelligence Altmer Apprentice, who can cast wide range and very strong spells and would try to kill the enemy quickly, and the Breton Mage who would perhaps need a bit more health and not so much magicka for fighting alongside their Conjured creature with their Bound armour and weapons.

It would let mages pick a strategy that suits them best, and allows the ambitous casters to cast the super-spells they dream of.

Re: Do you think Magicka increase should work the same as Health

Posted: Thu Jul 30, 2009 7:46 am
by Cloud_Nine
Very well said Symmachus