Page 1 of 3
Repair hammer observation
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 12:22 am
by Silkysmooth
I've noticed when I am repairing my stuff that if I hit the A button slower (360) I break hammers less than if I hit A as fast as I can. When I do the latter I sometimes break 2 or 3 in a row but that has never happened when I tap the A button slower. Has anyone else seen this in their own game or is it just me?
Re: Repair hammer observation
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 4:41 am
by Kestral
Silkysmooth wrote:I've noticed when I am repairing my stuff that if I hit the A button slower (360) I break hammers less than if I hit A as fast as I can. When I do the latter I sometimes break 2 or 3 in a row but that has never happened when I tap the A button slower. Has anyone else seen this in their own game or is it just me?
It just seems like it because you're using more hammers faster than usually.
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 9:22 am
by Mattbott
i agree, hammers do seem to break less if you repair 'more carefully' ie slower.
i never tested if this was actually true, but it did make me change the speed of repairing when i was running out of hammers
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 10:28 am
by Leilah
It also seems this way to me, but I think Kestral is right. After all, if you click rapidly, your perception of the speed at which you use up the hammers will change.
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 1:37 pm
by Kaelan Corvinus
I noticed this a while back, as well.
And contrary to what Kestral says, Ive actually done a count on slow vs. fast and you do actually break hammers more when you keep hitting the A button over and over again.
If you take your time, it decreases the breakage by almost half.

Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 4:24 pm
by Kestral
Kaelan Corvinus wrote:I noticed this a while back, as well.
And contrary to what Kestral says, Ive actually done a count on slow vs. fast and you do actually break hammers more when you keep hitting the A button over and over again.
If you take your time, it decreases the breakage by almost half.
:D
And how do you know if you counted right?
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 5:35 pm
by Kaelan Corvinus
Kestral wrote:Kaelan Corvinus wrote:I noticed this a while back, as well.
And contrary to what Kestral says, Ive actually done a count on slow vs. fast and you do actually break hammers more when you keep hitting the A button over and over again.
If you take your time, it decreases the breakage by almost half.

And how do you know if you counted right?
Because I graduated elementary school and can count accurately like most other productive members of society.

Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 5:55 pm
by JoeDan
Funny, I actually did notice this just a week or so ago as I was impatiently hitting the Repair button as fast as I possibly could. But it was never a big problem for me since repair hammers are dirt cheap. (Not to mention you can get most of your stock by digging through crates and boxes). It's a good motivation to hit 100 in Armorer.
Even though my file is pretty much done and has very few quests left, I still desperately want to get my Armorer to 100. I hear you can then repair weapons to 125%... damn I wish there was another expansion pack coming out to make use of all these newly upgraded stats I have

I want to play Fallout 3 but I hate that game for not giving Bethesda the resources to make a second Oblivion expansion lol
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 6:08 pm
by Kaelan Corvinus
JoeDan wrote:Funny, I actually did notice this just a week or so ago as I was impatiently hitting the Repair button as fast as I possibly could. But it was never a big problem for me since repair hammers are dirt cheap. (Not to mention you can get most of your stock by digging through crates and boxes). It's a good motivation to hit 100 in Armorer.
Even though my file is pretty much done and has very few quests left, I still desperately want to get my Armorer to 100. I hear you can then repair weapons to 125%... damn I wish there was another expansion pack coming out to make use of all these newly upgraded stats I have

I want to play Fallout 3 but I hate that game for not giving Bethesda the resources to make a second Oblivion expansion lol
Actually you repair items up to 125% at level 75 Armorer. When you hit 100, you can use only hammer and it will never break.
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 6:33 pm
by JoeDan
Kaelan Corvinus wrote:JoeDan wrote:Funny, I actually did notice this just a week or so ago as I was impatiently hitting the Repair button as fast as I possibly could. But it was never a big problem for me since repair hammers are dirt cheap. (Not to mention you can get most of your stock by digging through crates and boxes). It's a good motivation to hit 100 in Armorer.
Even though my file is pretty much done and has very few quests left, I still desperately want to get my Armorer to 100. I hear you can then repair weapons to 125%... damn I wish there was another expansion pack coming out to make use of all these newly upgraded stats I have

I want to play Fallout 3 but I hate that game for not giving Bethesda the resources to make a second Oblivion expansion lol
Actually you repair items up to 125% at level 75 Armorer. When you hit 100, you can use only hammer and it will never break.
Ah, that's what it was, thanks... By the time I hit 75 Armorer, I will probably have nothing to do left in the game I might as well not even bother lol
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 6:48 pm
by Kaelan Corvinus
JoeDan wrote:Kaelan Corvinus wrote:JoeDan wrote:Funny, I actually did notice this just a week or so ago as I was impatiently hitting the Repair button as fast as I possibly could. But it was never a big problem for me since repair hammers are dirt cheap. (Not to mention you can get most of your stock by digging through crates and boxes). It's a good motivation to hit 100 in Armorer.
Even though my file is pretty much done and has very few quests left, I still desperately want to get my Armorer to 100. I hear you can then repair weapons to 125%... damn I wish there was another expansion pack coming out to make use of all these newly upgraded stats I have

I want to play Fallout 3 but I hate that game for not giving Bethesda the resources to make a second Oblivion expansion lol
Actually you repair items up to 125% at level 75 Armorer. When you hit 100, you can use only hammer and it will never break.
Ah, that's what it was, thanks... By the time I hit 75 Armorer, I will probably have nothing to do left in the game I might as well not even bother lol
You can always continue to "dungeon crawl" afterwards. In fact, nowadays, since Ive beaten every questline in the game, thats what I do the most anyway.
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 7:47 pm
by Kestral
Kaelan Corvinus wrote:Because I graduated elementary school and can count accurately like most other productive members of society. :lol:
That didn't even answer the question.
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 8:07 pm
by Kaelan Corvinus
Kestral wrote:Kaelan Corvinus wrote:Because I graduated elementary school and can count accurately like most other productive members of society.

That didn't even answer the question.
Im sure it didn't for you.

Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 8:20 pm
by Kestral
Kaelan Corvinus wrote:Kestral wrote:Kaelan Corvinus wrote:Because I graduated elementary school and can count accurately like most other productive members of society. :lol:
That didn't even answer the question.
Im sure it didn't for you. :D
HOW did you count.
Of course you went "1... 2... 3..." but you didn't say how you counted as in:
Say 1... 2... 3... for each and every certain action.
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 8:26 pm
by Kaelan Corvinus
Ok, here it goes.
I created two saves of the same character, back to back.
I used the first save to repair items using the slow click method.
I used the second save to repair items using the fast clicking method.
At the end of repairing exactly the same items, The first save had more Hammers left by 3, I believe.
But don't hold me to that, it could have been 4.
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 8:34 pm
by Dragour
Well perhaps if this is true, then it could be that Bethesda is trying to prevent controller damage or they simply don't want chaotic and impatient gamers ...
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 8:57 pm
by Kaelan Corvinus
Dragour wrote:Well perhaps if this is true, then it could be that Bethesda is trying to prevent controller damage or they simply don't want chaotic and impatient gamers ...
My thoughts exactly, my friend.
Also I think anyone who has played Oblivion will tell you that Oblivion and impatience do NOT mix well.

Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 9:05 pm
by Dragour
Kaelan Corvinus wrote:Also I think anyone who has played Oblivion will tell you that Oblivion and impatience do NOT mix well.

Yeah, nor does over confidence

you tend to die more than when you were less confident, same fights, one is less cautious because they know (expect) victory is innedible while the other always tries to stay safe (safer) and attempts to take the enemy down by using their weakness, regardless of the enemy.
(off topic but still in subject to how things were done... maybe)
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 9:12 pm
by Kestral
Kaelan Corvinus wrote:Ok, here it goes.
I created two saves of the same character, back to back.
I used the first save to repair items using the slow click method.
I used the second save to repair items using the fast clicking method.
At the end of repairing exactly the same items, The first save had more Hammers left by 3, I believe.
But don't hold me to that, it could have been 4.
How do you know if you used the same amount of hammers for each save?
You could have used 5 on the first but 8 on the second because you can't keep track how much you use.
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 9:22 pm
by Silkysmooth
I could be wrong but what I think he is trying to say is that if he had started with the same amount of hammers on both saves, and repaired the same equipment both ways then he could tell which used less hammers by the amount of hammers he had left.
If he started with 10 and one method he was left with 4 that means he broke 6
While using the other method lets say he was left with 7 that means he only broke 3.
That still doesn't prove my theory as he only tried it once and it could have just been luck, but as others were saying button mashing doesn't seem to be rewarded very often in Oblivion.
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 9:24 pm
by Kaelan Corvinus
Kestral wrote:Kaelan Corvinus wrote:Ok, here it goes.
I created two saves of the same character, back to back.
I used the first save to repair items using the slow click method.
I used the second save to repair items using the fast clicking method.
At the end of repairing exactly the same items, The first save had more Hammers left by 3, I believe.
But don't hold me to that, it could have been 4.
How do you know if you used the same amount of hammers for each save?
You could have used 5 on the first but 8 on the second because you can't keep track how much you use.
I saved the same character twice, back to back. They had the exact same inventory.
In laymans terms, I duplicated the same character twice, back to back!
Do you get it, now?
Good God. Why is this so much of an issue?!
If you won't to believe the facts of which I stated, that's fine with me.
Im just telling everyone how I came to realization that Hammers work better if you take your time in using them.
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 9:29 pm
by Dragour
Well what I see here is that someone trustworthy (on the internet...) must perform the same test Kaelan Corvinus did (not saying you were wrong!) and record every hammer broken per 10 hammers on completely broken armour. After about ten goes if the faster button smashing has always had more hammers broken, then although the test is very minor and could very much be nothing but coincedince, we would have atleast a very strong theory in which one is better

Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 9:34 pm
by Kestral
Kaelan Corvinus wrote:{Text}
You're not answering the question right. I was saying, that, how do you know you used the same amount of hammers? Yes, you had the same amount of hammers in your inventory when you started, but how many hammers did you use in the test. And how would you know for sure? They could be different amounts of hammers. In fact, this whole test was wrong.
You would have count how many successful strikes and not hammers used.
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 9:45 pm
by Silkysmooth
Kestral wrote:Kaelan Corvinus wrote:{Text}
You're not answering the question right. I was saying, that, how do you know you used the same amount of hammers? Yes, you had the same amount of hammers in your inventory when you started, but how many hammers did you use in the test. And how would you know for sure? They could be different amounts of hammers. In fact, this whole test was wrong.
You would have count how many successful strikes and not hammers used.
Repairing the same gear with the same damage done to it with the same armorer level would require the same number of strikes if he broke 3 hammers one way and 6 hammers the other way, then the second way would yield more broken hammers per strike.
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 9:47 pm
by Kestral
He never said until what extent stopped.
There's also not the same amount of hammer strikes per hammer.