Page 1 of 2

Favorite Attribute

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 7:06 am
by m@nyt1mes
List what you believe to be the most important attribute, or just your favorite in oblivion, and please supply an argument better than "because you are a dummyhead"

i believe it is strength because there is nothing worse than to get to the best part of a dungeon and get over encumbered and either dropping the worst of your treasure or running all the way back to town to sell it.

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 8:54 am
by urthdigger
Endurance. Because the game heavily encourages you to raise that first above all else.

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 10:30 am
by Calm_Mind
Strength, purely because high strength enables you to carry more loot from dungeons, specifically Rockmilk Cave.

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 10:41 am
by Dragour
Calm_Mind wrote:Strength, purely because high strength enables you to carry more loot from dungeons, specifically Rockmilk Cave.
Ah but a high intelligence enables you to cast strong, long duration feather spells which can carry more than alot of points in strength can! :D

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 11:01 am
by Calm_Mind
Tell that to an Orc Warrior laden with Heavy Armor and a Magicka score so low it might as well be in negative numbers. :P

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 2:23 pm
by Josjie
Nice thread :D

My favorite attribute is... Speed.
Sure, Strength, Willpower and Endurance are nice, but Speed makes you a lot faster and that's great :D. Nothing beats moving from roof to roof pretending you're Altair from Assassin's Creed :D.

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 2:41 pm
by Calm_Mind
josjie wrote:Nice thread :D

My favorite attribute is... Speed.
Sure, Strength, Willpower and Endurance are nice, but Speed makes you a lot faster and that's great :D. Nothing beats moving from roof to roof pretending you're Altair from Assassin's Creed :D.
Except actually playing Assassin's Creed, perhaps... :roll:

I tend to find Speed, Personality and Luck to be the three least necessary attributes, to be honest.

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 4:10 pm
by Josjie
Calm_Mind wrote:
josjie wrote:Nice thread :D

My favorite attribute is... Speed.
Sure, Strength, Willpower and Endurance are nice, but Speed makes you a lot faster and that's great :D. Nothing beats moving from roof to roof pretending you're Altair from Assassin's Creed :D.
Except actually playing Assassin's Creed, perhaps... :roll:

I tend to find Speed, Personality and Luck to be the three least necessary attributes, to be honest.
Oblivion > Assassin's Creed :D

I never said that I think Speed is one of the most useful attributes. It's only my favorite attribute.

The most useful attributes, IMO, would be:
1) Endurance
2) Strength
3) Agility/Willpower

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 4:26 pm
by Big Head
since i am a magician, will power is the most important to me. a quick regeneration rate is essential

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 8:21 pm
by urthdigger
josjie wrote:Nice thread :D

My favorite attribute is... Speed.
Sure, Strength, Willpower and Endurance are nice, but Speed makes you a lot faster and that's great :D. Nothing beats moving from roof to roof pretending you're Altair from Assassin's Creed :D.
Alternatively, fortify acrobatics a whole bunch and jump from roof to roof pretending you're The Tick.

Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2009 4:49 am
by m@nyt1mes
Calm_Mind wrote:Strength, purely because high strength enables you to carry more loot from dungeons, specifically Rockmilk Cave.
as ironic as this is, i got the idea while dropping loot so i could get out of rockmilk cave, just before part two. i am playing an archer and leveling up agility and speed, and strength. but when you rubberband your controller and sneak yourself up to level 88 before you exit the sewers, you tend to be level 6 with 70 speed, 96 agility, and 36 strength.

Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2009 7:55 am
by tyrce111
I would have to say agility because it govens most of the stealth skills but strength is the second useful cuz it lets u hold loads of [&@%!] if ur stealing stuff or if ur getting heavy armour

Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2009 11:57 am
by Mattbott
luck has no value whasoever except to make you feel better about your character, which is why it is my number 1. If you're born under the Thief sign and increase it every level, it still will take you most of your career to max out. A rare quality..

strength is my least favourite stat cos you have to increase it if you want to carry anything (and how much you carry directly affects how much you earn from looting so strength is actually as important as personality/agility if you're a merchant/thief character respectively, which is silly) so it's almost a compulsory attribute which makes it boring imo.
I think encumbrance should be a function of many stats, like fatigue is. The explosive strength to wield a sword is not the same as the tireless strength required to carry gold across the wilderness. Your race could also affect your carrying load - small bosmer carry less than burly orcs.

personality is a very interesting stat, it has little value in the normal cut and thrust of things but is a real role players attribute. I like to make ugly faces for my low personality characters, and make good looking faces for characters who will eventually get good charisma-based stats.

Strong fighters, dextrous thieves, clever mages are all very well but you can play these characters in any game. I like making characters i can only play in Oblivion cos they never existed before

Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2009 12:25 pm
by Calm_Mind
That's an interesting take on things, but luck does have a direct influence on many things. For example, with higher luck, you are more likely to win when betting on the arena, as when your luck exceeds 50, the fighter you bet on begins to accrue additional Health Points. Granted, these won't make up for shortfalls in the quality of his equipment (if he comes out with no weapon, he's going to take a pounding regardless of how much health he has).

Oddly enough, despite always choosing strength as one of my attributes to raise when I'm raising 5/5/5, I've never really considered it an essential attribute. I usually focus on Strength, Intelligence and Willpower to make for a good mixed fighter.

Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2009 12:29 pm
by Leilah
Mattbott wrote:luck has no value whasoever except to make you feel better about your character, which is why it is my number 1. If you're born under the Thief sign and increase it every level, it still will take you most of your career to max out. A rare quality..
I completely agree. I maxed out my luck last week, when I reached level 36. It's always one of my favoured attributes, since it makes me feel all warm and fuzzy knowing that I have a lucky character.

Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2009 1:58 pm
by Mattbott
in Fallout 3 there are random encounters, ie set pieces which occur 'at random' when you're walking through the wilderness. They add a lot to the whole experience and i suspect bethesda could be planning this sort of feature in the next TES game.
This could be tied into your luck stat, maybe high luck means you meet 'nicer' people in the road, for example. Maybe you would engineer a low luck character to attract more bad-assed encounters. The idea that luck affects everything a little bit is ok, but it could be used to add unpredictability to the game, like the joker card in the pack.
I also like the idea that high luck increases your 'exposure' to luck, ie high luck score means you have chance of something horrible happening to you as well as the good things, a double edged blade

Perhaps they could take out some of those random yarn-and-other-junk-filled containers, and put in some good luck/bad luck events instead
:wink:

Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2009 2:37 pm
by Kaelan Corvinus
Endurance is by far the most useful and my favorite attribute, because no matter what class you are, it is always useful.

High hit points are always welcome. :D

Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2009 4:13 pm
by Mattbott
this is undeniable

Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2009 4:47 pm
by Josjie
Mattbott wrote:in Fallout 3 there are random encounters, ie set pieces which occur 'at random' when you're walking through the wilderness. They add a lot to the whole experience and i suspect bethesda could be planning this sort of feature in the next TES game.
This could be tied into your luck stat, maybe high luck means you meet 'nicer' people in the road, for example. Maybe you would engineer a low luck character to attract more bad-assed encounters. The idea that luck affects everything a little bit is ok, but it could be used to add unpredictability to the game, like the joker card in the pack.
I also like the idea that high luck increases your 'exposure' to luck, ie high luck score means you have chance of something horrible happening to you as well as the good things, a double edged blade

Perhaps they could take out some of those random yarn-and-other-junk-filled containers, and put in some good luck/bad luck events instead
:wink:
If Luck would affect loot, that'd be nice. But if it would make the game easier by making you encounter less enemies, that would seriously suck. The more enemies, the better, because in Fallout 3 (and perhaps in The Elder Scrolls V!!) they mean experience and they always carry gold (caps) and/or loot. I would never put a point in Luck if they would do that.
Kaelan Corvinus wrote:Endurance is by far the most useful and my favorite attribute, because no matter what class you are, it is always useful.

High hit points are always welcome. Very Happy
Endurance rules :D I agree with that. However, it is not my favorite attribute. Favorite like "the effect it has on the game". More health is nice, but it's not something I really notice all the time. So that's why I go for Speed, which makes you faster. Imagine that you're a level 50 wizard with only 20 Speed but with 100 Endurance and Strength. Then I prefer 100 Speed over 100 Strength.

Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2009 11:25 pm
by PinballWizard
Personality all the way.

When you walk into somewhere, and not even the rat attacks you, you feel like a god. Talking with bandits? Now that's fun. You can just waltz in, grab what you want, and waltz back out.

Posted: Thu Jun 04, 2009 1:26 pm
by Calm_Mind
Oddly enough, despite the number of mages that people create and the number of characters using magic a fair amount, nobody has specified intelligence as their favourite. Surely if you're a mage, high intelligence (therefore high maximum magicka) is a neccessity given the cost of some of the spells to cast, like Legendary Soul Trap etc?

Posted: Thu Jun 04, 2009 2:22 pm
by Josjie
100 Intelligence only gives you 200 Magicka.

With my High Elf mage with the Atronach birthsign, I already have 250 base Magicka, and 500+ more with enchanted items. So that 200 Magicka isn't much of a difference.

And I start with 50 Intelligence so actually it's only 100 more Magicka.

Posted: Thu Jun 04, 2009 7:41 pm
by The Raven
Favorite Attribute? Either Personality or Endurance.

Probably Personality. I love Illusion, Speechcraft and Mercantile

So yeah, Personality.

PERSONALITY ISN'T BAD!
PERSONALITY IS AWESOME!

Posted: Mon Jun 29, 2009 1:34 am
by rosenrot
Luck. Just feels better having high luck.

Posted: Mon Jun 29, 2009 2:01 am
by Kestral
Strength or Intelligence.

Strength; I can carry more. Face it, being an awesome Mage will run into conflicts when you can't haul loot.

Intelligence; I need to cast magic.