Page 1 of 1

Next of Kin (Possible spoilers)

Posted: Thu May 21, 2009 4:36 pm
by Kroogur
In the DB questline there is the Next of Kin quest. Why does the entire Draconis family have to die? what did they do?

Up to this point with the exception of Whodunit? There was at least some kind of reason behind the contracts.

Posted: Thu May 21, 2009 5:58 pm
by Dark Spark
One of the family is a mercenary type who, in the words of his mother, got in with the wrong sort of people before. Someone may have carried a grudge.

Another member is a participant in the persecution and torture of Argonians in Leyawiin. Someone definitely is carrying a grudge.

Posted: Thu May 21, 2009 6:41 pm
by Brass Petals
i always wondered that as i didnt like killing people without knowing why. just shows even in games innocent people die because of one person who ruins it all....i hated killing the mother so too much of a girl for my own good.

makes me wanna know the right reason though!

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 8:00 am
by Generalno1
Or maybe somebody hated someone in the Draconis family so much he/she wanted the entire bloodline to end

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 9:41 am
by Calm_Mind
I've never really read much into the reasoning behind why the client of the Dark Brotherhood wants a mark exterminating, I guess I'm just bloodthirsty that way. :/

The only time during the Dark Brotherhood questline where I'm fairly sure you meet the person who comissioned the contract is where you have to sneak through the secret hatch and drop a minotaur's head onto an elf of some kind to kill him. A relative of his moves into the house after his death, and reacts with a kind of cold indifference to the whole scenario.

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 10:54 am
by Generalno1
Well ,there has to be someone who commisioned the contract for a reason,revenge,hate,personal benefit......the dark Brotherhood is'nt a group of psychotic lunatics

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 11:13 am
by Kroogur
All in all I think the DB quests were very well crafted, that is why I had a problem with Next of Kin and to a lesser extent Whodunit? They just seemed "slapped" together.

The mother seems like a truly good person and Dark Spark made a good point that a couple of her kids were rotten and therefore may have brought the wrong kind of attention to the family.But her innkeeper son seems decent enough and even her "cavegirl" daughter seems innocent.

Whodunit? felt cheap because the motive was clear..greed(except for the rich kid) but what did any of them do to deserve their fate? The only possible thing I got out of that quest was maybe the Redguard was directly or indirectly responsible for the Nord's daughters death.

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 1:56 pm
by Calm_Mind
Unless I'm wrong, one of the people in Whodunnit? is in love with the female Dunmer, and I can only assume that his devotion turns to hatred, because at a certain disposition, he can be persuaded to attack and kill her for you.

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 5:42 pm
by Dark Spark
In the Agatha Christie story that inspired "Whodunit?", each of the victims committed a crime that the letter of the law could not touch, and the killer sought to exact "justice" for the deeds they got away with.

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 5:44 pm
by Sanguine
Calm_Mind wrote:Unless I'm wrong, one of the people in Whodunnit? is in love with the female Dunmer, and I can only assume that his devotion turns to hatred, because at a certain disposition, he can be persuaded to attack and kill her for you.
You are wrong, he doesn't love her she reminds him of his dead daughter.

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 5:55 pm
by Dark Spark
My theory on the Whodunit client: a hungry cannibal who wanted to stock up his larder for the coming months. It all stems from that silly little "don't let them know you're the killer!" limitation on the quest.

Why is that there? Does it really matter whether or not they know the identity of the Dark Brotherhood assassin sent to kill them? It's not like they're going to be chewing that one over for any goodly amount of time!

No, the only reason for the secrecy is so that the victims do not fight or exert themselves at the instant of death. Because a creature relaxed at the moment of death provides more tender meat than one that is agitated when it is killed. Your client wants the victims to remain unaware, which only points to the conclusion that you were hired by someone who wants to eat the victims.

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 6:40 pm
by Kroogur
Dark Spark wrote:My theory on the Whodunit client: a hungry cannibal who wanted to stock up his larder for the coming months. It all stems from that silly little "don't let them know you're the killer!" limitation on the quest.

Why is that there? Does it really matter whether or not they know the identity of the Dark Brotherhood assassin sent to kill them? It's not like they're going to be chewing that one over for any goodly amount of time!

No, the only reason for the secrecy is so that the victims do not fight or exert themselves at the instant of death. Because a creature relaxed at the moment of death provides more tender meat than one that is agitated when it is killed. Your client wants the victims to remain unaware, which only points to the conclusion that you were hired by someone who wants to eat the victims.
It was Glarthir and that creepy creep that owns the alchemy shoppe! they are in cahoots! He is really a cannibal and well we know what the shop owner does.... :shock:

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 6:50 pm
by Sanguine
Kroogur wrote:
Dark Spark wrote:My theory on the Whodunit client: a hungry cannibal who wanted to stock up his larder for the coming months. It all stems from that silly little "don't let them know you're the killer!" limitation on the quest.

Why is that there? Does it really matter whether or not they know the identity of the Dark Brotherhood assassin sent to kill them? It's not like they're going to be chewing that one over for any goodly amount of time!

No, the only reason for the secrecy is so that the victims do not fight or exert themselves at the instant of death. Because a creature relaxed at the moment of death provides more tender meat than one that is agitated when it is killed. Your client wants the victims to remain unaware, which only points to the conclusion that you were hired by someone who wants to eat the victims.
It was Glarthir and that creepy creep that owns the alchemy shoppe! they are in cahoots! He is really a cannibal and well we know what the shop owner does.... :shock:
Problem with that theory is that it is possible to kill Glarhir well before the Whodunit? quest.

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 7:03 pm
by Kroogur
Sanguine wrote:
Kroogur wrote:
It was Glarthir and that creepy creep that owns the alchemy shoppe! they are in cahoots! He is really a cannibal and well we know what the shop owner does.... :shock:
Problem with that theory is that it is possible to kill Glarhir well before the Whodunit? quest.
I know, it was just my pitiful attempt at humor :wink: :D

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 7:19 pm
by Sanguine
Kroogur wrote:
Sanguine wrote:
Kroogur wrote:
It was Glarthir and that creepy creep that owns the alchemy shoppe! they are in cahoots! He is really a cannibal and well we know what the shop owner does.... :shock:
Problem with that theory is that it is possible to kill Glarthir well before the Whodunit? quest.
I know, it was just my pitiful attempt at humor :wink: :D
Yes, very pitiful. Any who, doesn't someone say that all of the guests have wronged the employer in someway

Posted: Sat May 23, 2009 7:30 am
by Dark Spark
Sanguine wrote:
Kroogur wrote:
Dark Spark wrote:My theory on the Whodunit client: a hungry cannibal who wanted to stock up his larder for the coming months. It all stems from that silly little "don't let them know you're the killer!" limitation on the quest.

Why is that there? Does it really matter whether or not they know the identity of the Dark Brotherhood assassin sent to kill them? It's not like they're going to be chewing that one over for any goodly amount of time!

No, the only reason for the secrecy is so that the victims do not fight or exert themselves at the instant of death. Because a creature relaxed at the moment of death provides more tender meat than one that is agitated when it is killed. Your client wants the victims to remain unaware, which only points to the conclusion that you were hired by someone who wants to eat the victims.
It was Glarthir and that creepy creep that owns the alchemy shoppe! they are in cahoots! He is really a cannibal and well we know what the shop owner does.... :shock:
Problem with that theory is that it is possible to kill Glarhir well before the Whodunit? quest.
Problem with the Dark Brotherhood is that, once the gold is paid and the contract is made with the Speaker, you don't know exactly how long it takes before the contract is executed. While Glarthir is waiting for the party to assemble, his impatience (and desire for food) could cost him his life.