Page 1 of 1

The Atronach and Willpower Question

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 3:21 pm
by Moffattz
I have a question/concern about the Atronach Birthsign:

Since the Atronach will not regenerate magicka, I am assuming that it would be a waste if I put experience points into Willpower? (since willpower speeds up magicka regeneration). BUT, I am using Restoration and Alteration (whose governing attribute is Willpower).

Will this affect my restoration/alteration abilities if I don’t put experience points into Willpower?

Sorry I haven’t really delved into the magic aspect of the game before.

Thanks!


I am a Nord Warrior with The Atronach Birthsign.

Strength & Endurance are my 2 favored Attributes.

My Major skills are:

Armorer
Heavy Armor
Blade
Block
Alchemy
Alteration
Restoration

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 3:31 pm
by Sanguine
It says here that with stunted magicka willpower will only affect your fatigue.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 3:33 pm
by Redguard_Master
willpower will still affect willpower derived skills normally in terms of skill perks, casting cost etc.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 3:35 pm
by Sanguine
Redguard_Master wrote:willpower will still affect willpower derived skills normally in terms of skill perks, casting cost etc.
No, I'm pretty sure willpower doesn't affect those things. Doesn't mention it anywhere on the wiki page.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 3:40 pm
by Redguard_Master
I was refering to atronach birthsign. It affects magic regen, not the nature of using willpower based skills. Using atronach will affect magic regen but other than that restoration and other willpower based skills operate normally.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 3:41 pm
by Sanguine
Redguard_Master wrote:Maybe it does affect it.It says it affects magic regen, without confirmation I've never heard anything to suggest atronach birthsign would affect using willpower based skills and the xp gained per casting and skill level affecting casting cost and that kinda stuff.
But is there any comfirmation that atributes affect that stuff?

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 3:45 pm
by Redguard_Master
That's not the question he asked. he asked if atronach would affect the use of restoration and other willpower based skills. No, it won't. It reduces the importance having a high willpower attribute. But it doesn't affect the fact that a 100 is needed to cast master level restoration spells, the formula used to calculate the cost of restoration based spells etc.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 3:51 pm
by Moffattz
Redguard_Master wrote:That's not the question he asked. he asked if atronach would affect the use of restoration and other willpower based skills. No, it won't. It reduces the importance having a high willpower attribute. But it doesn't affect the fact that a 100 is needed to cast master level restoration spells, the formula used to calculate the cost of restoration based spells etc.
Basically i want to know if my Resto/Alter skills would lack in some way by not investing in willpower, as it wouldn't make sense to raise that attribute.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 3:53 pm
by Sanguine
They will only be lacking in the way that there skill ups contribute to a stat you don't use.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 3:58 pm
by Moffattz
Sanguine wrote:They will only be lacking in the way that there skill ups contribute to a stat you don't use.
Ok, i get yah now.. thanks!

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 3:58 pm
by Redguard_Master
No. You can just put points into other attributes at level up time.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 3:59 pm
by Moffattz
Redguard_Master wrote:No. You can just put points into other attributes at level up time.
true

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 4:40 pm
by FilthyNord
Redguard_Master wrote:That's not the question he asked. he asked if atronach would affect the use of restoration and other willpower based skills. No, it won't. It reduces the importance having a high willpower attribute. But it doesn't affect the fact that a 100 is needed to cast master level restoration spells, the formula used to calculate the cost of restoration based spells etc.
That is not the question he asked either. What he wants to know is, since his character is born under the sign of the Atronach, and thereby does not regenerate Magicka, should he bother putting experience points into Willpower, since Magicka regeneration is governed by Willpower.

The answer is yes. Fatigue regeneration is also governed by Willpower - so if you are a melee character, you will get tired faster and do less damage with a lower willpower. And of course the cost of casting Restoration, Alteration, and Destruction spells is governed by Willpower. The higher your Willpower, the less it costs to cast spells which are governed by this attribute.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 4:43 pm
by Sanguine
FilthyNord wrote:
Redguard_Master wrote:That's not the question he asked. he asked if atronach would affect the use of restoration and other willpower based skills. No, it won't. It reduces the importance having a high willpower attribute. But it doesn't affect the fact that a 100 is needed to cast master level restoration spells, the formula used to calculate the cost of restoration based spells etc.
That is not the question he asked either. What he wants to know is, since his character is born under the sign of the Atronach, and thereby does not regenerate Magicka, should he bother putting experience points into Willpower, since Magicka regeneration is governed by Willpower.

The answer is yes. Fatigue regeneration is also governed by Willpower - so if you are a melee character, you will get tired faster and do less damage with a lower willpower. And of course the cost of casting Restoration, Alteration, and Destruction spells is governed by Willpower. The higher your Willpower, the less it costs to cast spells which are governed by this attribute.
I don't think that is true as the wiki page I linked to said the only benefit for an Atronach character from willpower is fatigue.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 4:45 pm
by Arzock
I don't think that is true as the wiki page I linked to said the only benefit for an Atronach character from willpower is fatigue.
No, the wiki is incorrect.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 4:47 pm
by Sanguine
Arzock wrote:
I don't think that is true as the wiki page I linked to said the only benefit for an Atronach character from willpower is fatigue.
No, the wiki is incorrect.
Well then someone should edit it.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 4:49 pm
by FilthyNord
Sanguine wrote:
FilthyNord wrote:
Redguard_Master wrote:That's not the question he asked. he asked if atronach would affect the use of restoration and other willpower based skills. No, it won't. It reduces the importance having a high willpower attribute. But it doesn't affect the fact that a 100 is needed to cast master level restoration spells, the formula used to calculate the cost of restoration based spells etc.
That is not the question he asked either. What he wants to know is, since his character is born under the sign of the Atronach, and thereby does not regenerate Magicka, should he bother putting experience points into Willpower, since Magicka regeneration is governed by Willpower.

The answer is yes. Fatigue regeneration is also governed by Willpower - so if you are a melee character, you will get tired faster and do less damage with a lower willpower. And of course the cost of casting Restoration, Alteration, and Destruction spells is governed by Willpower. The higher your Willpower, the less it costs to cast spells which are governed by this attribute.
I don't think that is true as the wiki page I linked to said the only benefit for an Atronach character from willpower is fatigue.
Hmm ... well, being that he's a Nord/Atronach (same as my usualy character, BTW), raising his willpower will help out with his melee combat.

BTW, I think Nord/Atronach is just about the most powerful combination in the game ... makes things rather easy, IMHO.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 5:45 pm
by Moffattz
FilthyNord wrote:
Redguard_Master wrote:That's not the question he asked. he asked if atronach would affect the use of restoration and other willpower based skills. No, it won't. It reduces the importance having a high willpower attribute. But it doesn't affect the fact that a 100 is needed to cast master level restoration spells, the formula used to calculate the cost of restoration based spells etc.
That is not the question he asked either. What he wants to know is, since his character is born under the sign of the Atronach, and thereby does not regenerate Magicka, should he bother putting experience points into Willpower, since Magicka regeneration is governed by Willpower.

The answer is yes. Fatigue regeneration is also governed by Willpower - so if you are a melee character, you will get tired faster and do less damage with a lower willpower. And of course the cost of casting Restoration, Alteration, and Destruction spells is governed by Willpower. The higher your Willpower, the less it costs to cast spells which are governed by this attribute.
This is exactly the type of answer that i was looking for..... thanks everybody for your opinions! chime in if you want pls

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 8:19 pm
by Dark Spark
Sanguine wrote:
Arzock wrote:
I don't think that is true as the wiki page I linked to said the only benefit for an Atronach character from willpower is fatigue.
No, the wiki is incorrect.
Well then someone should edit it.
Here's you chance, people. Let's see if it stands up to review.

Notice that the only Attribute factored into the Magicka cost of a spell is Luck, and it only does so through calculating is affect on the relevant Skill (in thos case, the school of magic).

Posted: Sun May 17, 2009 10:31 pm
by sweetalmonds
And of course the cost of casting Restoration, Alteration, and Destruction spells is governed by Willpower. The higher your Willpower, the less it costs to cast spells which are governed by this attribute.
no difference seen in game. i had 80 willpower then hax it 180 but still same cost to cast a destruction spell.