Page 1 of 2

Best birthsign for a warrior class

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 2:11 pm
by Moffattz
Hey guys,

I'm making a Nord Warrior.

I have the basic Melee Skills Blade/Blunt Block etc with Restoration and Alteration for the sheild spells. I have always gone with "The Warrior" birthsign in the past but was really weak with the magicka. I was wondering if it would be worth it to go with "The Mage" to boost my magicka pool.

I'm really just wondering if loosing the str/end arrtibute boost can be made up by just putting my experience points into those by just leveling up.

I can still be an efficient warrior without the "the warrior" birthsign, couldn't i?

thanks, guys

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 2:23 pm
by The Raven
If you still want a bonus to Endurance, pick The Lady (+10 to WIL/END).

While you might loose the +50 Magicka bonus, you get a somewhat faster mana regeneration rate.

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 3:48 pm
by Symmachus
have you considered being a battlemage? you seem to have a grasp on the kind of magic you want to use and are obviously thinking to be using magic quite a lot.

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 4:12 pm
by Moffattz
i have though about it.... but the last time in played a warrior it was damn near impossible to play when i got into the late 20-30 levels.... though i can't understand why?? so i thought about battlemage, but i wasn't sure if i would want to sacrifice all my skill in one thing for the split.

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 11:01 pm
by Helikaon
i find that the thief is good for me, although i do tend to sneak quite a bit, +10 speed for my athletics and acrobatics, +10 luck for .......well you know, it's quite handy, and +10 agility for less damage from bows, better marksman, less likely to be staggered and adds a little to fatigue.

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 12:26 am
by Dragour
Personally for a warrior, a mage is a good birthsign, as attributes and skills have caps, magicka doesn't. Also having two weapon classes is sort of pointless (own view) and it kind of removes a perfectly usable skill.

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 4:43 am
by Josjie
If you want to use magic as a Warrior, the Mage is a very good birthsign. A better choice than the Apprentice is you ask me.

If you want a nice balanced character, you can take the Thief, for rounded up attributes. But do this only if you plan on using stealth!

If you want to be a pure warrior, with the highest starting Strength and Endurance as possible, go for the Warrior sign. This is a safe bet, but you won't have much magicka.

Finally, if you've played Oblivion for quite some time, you can pick the Atronach. But do this only when you know how to refill your magicka! I'd say 100 hours of playing time are at least required before you create a character with this sign.
You'll have plenty of magicka, but the main reason to take this birthsign, is for the 50% Spell Absorption. This is great against magic users and a nice back-up for a warrior. But again: only take this sign if you won't be using much magic.

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 1:25 pm
by Moffattz
Dragour wrote:Personally for a warrior, a mage is a good birthsign, as attributes and skills have caps, magicka doesn't. Also having two weapon classes is sort of pointless (own view) and it kind of removes a perfectly usable skill.
I do prefer to use blade over Blunt. So you think i should drop Blunt and pick up something else? that sounds like a good idea to me but i am just concerned about picking up skills that don't have racial etc bonuses applied to them, though that shouldn't really matter though?

i also wonder about the efficiency of splitting up the character like that instead of going "full warrior" i just want to make sure i can hold my own in the later levels.

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 1:29 pm
by Moffattz
josjie wrote:If you want to use magic as a Warrior, the Mage is a very good birthsign. A better choice than the Apprentice is you ask me.

If you want a nice balanced character, you can take the Thief, for rounded up attributes. But do this only if you plan on using stealth!

If you want to be a pure warrior, with the highest starting Strength and Endurance as possible, go for the Warrior sign. This is a safe bet, but you won't have much magicka.

Finally, if you've played Oblivion for quite some time, you can pick the Atronach. But do this only when you know how to refill your magicka! I'd say 100 hours of playing time are at least required before you create a character with this sign.
You'll have plenty of magicka, but the main reason to take this birthsign, is for the 50% Spell Absorption. This is great against magic users and a nice back-up for a warrior. But again: only take this sign if you won't be using much magic.
I have played for 110 hours, though my last character was a warrior and hadn't explored to much in magic. The astronach does really appeal to me but my main concern is how hard it would be to replenish my magicka. Is it a time consuming chore or easier than i think? Also is it worth it to loose the Str/End bonuses from "The Warrior". I'm sure those could be made up for by just leveling?

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 1:40 pm
by Josjie
I'll be honest with you: in my opinion, the Atronach is the best birthsign in the game. And regenerating your magicka isn't very difficult, because you have 50% spell absorption and you can use potions/ingredients/spells and even glitches.
However, you're playing a game. And in a game, I just want to have fun, and I don't want to spend even a little amount of time into something that I don't like. So that's why I never grind my skills. Some people keep casting spells in their house so they raise their skills, but I think that's a bit unfair and most of all: boring.
So the Atronach is a good sign but it means a big chance for your game. You must be well prepared.

As I read your previous posts, I suggest a build like this:

Race: Nord (Male recommended)
Birthsign: The Mage
Attributes: Strength & Endurance
Specialization: Combat
Major skills: Heavy Armor, Armorer, Blade, Blunt, X, X, X

This is a safe bet. You won't die often with this character. I've chosen both Blade and Blunt as major skills. If you like Hand-to-Hand, you can take that as a major skill instead.
But in my opinion, there's nothing wrong with having two major skills. You'll have a high Strength so you can carry lots of items. And it's cool to be using both swords and maces/axes. On my character, I have around 2-3 swords and 2-3 blunt weapons, and I switch between them all the time. My Blade and Blunt skill were constantly somehow equal.
For your three other major skills, I recommend Restoration, Destruction and a third skill of your choice. Like Conjuration, Illusion, Alchemy or Sneak.

Try to maxime your Endurance as soon as possible. This will give you much health and that'll make your game easier.
Also raise your Strength, Intelligence, Endurance and Speed attributes. Agility isn't that important because you won't be using bows.
With 100 Intelligence, you'll have 250 Magicka, and you'll regenerate it quickly (100 Willpower). You can also fortify your Magicka with equipment/spells/potions.
But this character will also have plenty of magicka in the beginning of the game and is able to heal himself and do some damage to his enemies with shock/fire spells.

So it's a safe bet, with no weaknesses, and he's able to use both magic and combat.

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 2:08 pm
by Moffattz
josjie wrote:I'll be honest with you: in my opinion, the Atronach is the best birthsign in the game. And regenerating your magicka isn't very difficult, because you have 50% spell absorption and you can use potions/ingredients/spells and even glitches.
However, you're playing a game. And in a game, I just want to have fun, and I don't want to spend even a little amount of time into something that I don't like. So that's why I never grind my skills. Some people keep casting spells in their house so they raise their skills, but I think that's a bit unfair and most of all: boring.
So the Atronach is a good sign but it means a big chance for your game. You must be well prepared.

As I read your previous posts, I suggest a build like this:

Race: Nord (Male recommended)
Birthsign: The Mage
Attributes: Strength & Endurance
Specialization: Combat
Major skills: Heavy Armor, Armorer, Blade, Blunt, X, X, X

This is a safe bet. You won't die often with this character. I've chosen both Blade and Blunt as major skills. If you like Hand-to-Hand, you can take that as a major skill instead.
But in my opinion, there's nothing wrong with having two major skills. You'll have a high Strength so you can carry lots of items. And it's cool to be using both swords and maces/axes. On my character, I have around 2-3 swords and 2-3 blunt weapons, and I switch between them all the time. My Blade and Blunt skill were constantly somehow equal.
For your three other major skills, I recommend Restoration, Destruction and a third skill of your choice. Like Conjuration, Illusion, Alchemy or Sneak.

Try to maxime your Endurance as soon as possible. This will give you much health and that'll make your game easier.
Also raise your Strength, Intelligence, Endurance and Speed attributes. Agility isn't that important because you won't be using bows.
With 100 Intelligence, you'll have 250 Magicka, and you'll regenerate it quickly (100 Willpower). You can also fortify your Magicka with equipment/spells/potions.
But this character will also have plenty of magicka in the beginning of the game and is able to heal himself and do some damage to his enemies with shock/fire spells.

So it's a safe bet, with no weaknesses, and he's able to use both magic and combat.
I am all about having fun as well, not too into the grinding. If i went with Atronach i wouldn't have to worry about raising my Willpower... something i've been thinking about. The mage sounds good as well.

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 2:10 pm
by Moffattz
Moffattz wrote:
josjie wrote:I'll be honest with you: in my opinion, the Atronach is the best birthsign in the game. And regenerating your magicka isn't very difficult, because you have 50% spell absorption and you can use potions/ingredients/spells and even glitches.
However, you're playing a game. And in a game, I just want to have fun, and I don't want to spend even a little amount of time into something that I don't like. So that's why I never grind my skills. Some people keep casting spells in their house so they raise their skills, but I think that's a bit unfair and most of all: boring.
So the Atronach is a good sign but it means a big chance for your game. You must be well prepared.

As I read your previous posts, I suggest a build like this:

Race: Nord (Male recommended)
Birthsign: The Mage
Attributes: Strength & Endurance
Specialization: Combat
Major skills: Heavy Armor, Armorer, Blade, Blunt, X, X, X

This is a safe bet. You won't die often with this character. I've chosen both Blade and Blunt as major skills. If you like Hand-to-Hand, you can take that as a major skill instead.
But in my opinion, there's nothing wrong with having two major skills. You'll have a high Strength so you can carry lots of items. And it's cool to be using both swords and maces/axes. On my character, I have around 2-3 swords and 2-3 blunt weapons, and I switch between them all the time. My Blade and Blunt skill were constantly somehow equal.
For your three other major skills, I recommend Restoration, Destruction and a third skill of your choice. Like Conjuration, Illusion, Alchemy or Sneak.

Try to maxime your Endurance as soon as possible. This will give you much health and that'll make your game easier.
Also raise your Strength, Intelligence, Endurance and Speed attributes. Agility isn't that important because you won't be using bows.
With 100 Intelligence, you'll have 250 Magicka, and you'll regenerate it quickly (100 Willpower). You can also fortify your Magicka with equipment/spells/potions.
But this character will also have plenty of magicka in the beginning of the game and is able to heal himself and do some damage to his enemies with shock/fire spells.

So it's a safe bet, with no weaknesses, and he's able to use both magic and combat.
I am all about having fun as well, not too into the grinding. If i went with Atronach i wouldn't have to worry about raising my Willpower... something i've been thinking about. The mage sounds good as well.
Should i worry too much about loosing the Str/End bonus from the warrior?

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 3:03 pm
by Generalno1
You can click on edit on the top right to extend your post

and,if you'r planning on using magic,i say go for the mage

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 3:13 pm
by Josjie
Should i worry too much about loosing the Str/End bonus from the warrior?
No. As long as you level up one of these skills every time you level up:
Heavy Armor
Armorer
Block

If you don't want to grind, wear full Heavy Armor every time you're in combat, use a shield and repair your armor when it's broken, and you'll get a +2, +3 or even a +5 bonus to Endurance every time you level up.

So just keep putting points in Endurance.

For your second attribute, I recommend Strength, so you'll do more damage with your weapons.

For your third attribute, it's completely your own choice and it doesn't really matter. I recommend Speed or Intelligence.

So get your Endurance, Strength and Intelligence/Speed to 100 as soon as possible.

If you do this, the +10 bonus you would otherwise get from the Warrior birthsign doesn't really make much of a difference and you can just have fun without worying about whether your character is strong enough or not (because it is strong enough :D).

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 3:52 pm
by Moffattz
josjie wrote:
Should i worry too much about loosing the Str/End bonus from the warrior?
No. As long as you level up one of these skills every time you level up:
Heavy Armor
Armorer
Block

If you don't want to grind, wear full Heavy Armor every time you're in combat, use a shield and repair your armor when it's broken, and you'll get a +2, +3 or even a +5 bonus to Endurance every time you level up.

So just keep putting points in Endurance.

For your second attribute, I recommend Strength, so you'll do more damage with your weapons.

For your third attribute, it's completely your own choice and it doesn't really matter. I recommend Speed or Intelligence.

So get your Endurance, Strength and Intelligence/Speed to 100 as soon as possible.

If you do this, the +10 bonus you would otherwise get from the Warrior birthsign doesn't really make much of a difference and you can just have fun without worying about whether your character is strong enough or not (because it is strong enough :D).
right on thanks...!

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 12:42 am
by Moffattz
bump

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 4:02 am
by Mad Prophet Helmholtz
I voted Atronach, but only for experienced Warriors who tend to use as little magic as possible in the game. Mage is a nice conservative choice (and my personal fave), but it's better for Mages/Battlemages/Theives. I would never choose Warrior (or any bonus which supplies +10) because you can max out your attributes just fine without these types of birthsigns. And Birthsigns with Powers are just...worthless.

Atronach is better for warriors than mages. If you minimize your use of magic and rely on brawn, the stunted magicka isn't much of a factor and you get a great 50% spell absorption for defense. The extra 100 isn't really needed, but it helps. Also, Atronach is better for a playstyle where you just play freely, as opposed to spending time doing training for specific skills and efficient leveling, since you go through magicka quite rapidly.

The Mage is only 50 extra magicka. Not really that important if you are going to minimize magic.

I would also recommend the Apprentice, but not for a warrior. Donald Trump, great architect of HOTELS and CASINOS, a constructor of generators of ziggurwatt power which ennobles all Supermen to make way for the landing of SPACESHIP JESUS and in opposition to the nefarious illusion world created by GHOST SHARK, for the APPRENTICE = DONALD TRUMP TV SHOW. Watch the Apprentice. I was thrilled to see Joan Rivers win last night. Brilliant mistress of witchcraft Joan Rivers creates FAUX AIDS CHARITY which she sends meals implanted with dangerous poisons to send to AIDS PATIENTS thus hastening quick deaths all in the name of SPACESHIP JESUS.

The Apprentice makes you 100% weak to magic so it is best to have someone, say a Breton with 50% magic resistance and get that high level Mundane Ring, thereby making you 100% resistant to magic, nullifying your weakness and most importantly PROMOTING TRUMP TV INTO OBLIVION, great game of HOTEL USAGE and living a superreality of apocalyptic proportions!

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 4:05 am
by AzNmamba
dude, are you frikin punking me?????

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 6:29 am
by Josjie
Mad Prophet Helmholtz wrote:I voted Atronach, but only for experienced Warriors who tend to use as little magic as possible in the game. Mage is a nice conservative choice (and my personal fave), but it's better for Mages/Battlemages/Theives. I would never choose Warrior (or any bonus which supplies +10) because you can max out your attributes just fine without these types of birthsigns. And Birthsigns with Powers are just...worthless.
True, but if you go for maximum health, you'll want to start with an Endurance of 65 instead of 55. And for people who want to maximize Luck, the Thief is a good choice.
So we've Mage, Apprentice, Atronach, Warrior and Thief. All other birthsigns are pretty useless (well only for role-playing or really unusual character concepts, like the Lady).
Mad Prophet Helmholtz wrote:Atronach is better for warriors than mages. If you minimize your use of magic and rely on brawn, the stunted magicka isn't much of a factor and you get a great 50% spell absorption for defense. The extra 100 isn't really needed, but it helps. Also, Atronach is better for a playstyle where you just play freely, as opposed to spending time doing training for specific skills and efficient leveling, since you go through magicka quite rapidly.
I don't fully agree with that. I've got an Altmer with the Atronach birthsign and he uses magic 90% of the time. And he rocks :D. And I know that there are many others who also enjoy the Altmer + Atronach combination. With 100% Spell Absorption and 100 Alchemy level, you can quite easily regenerate your magicka.
For everyone who has played, let's say, less than 300-400 hours, the Atronach might work better with a warrior, I agree with that.[/quote]
Mad Prophet Helmholtz wrote:The Mage is only 50 extra magicka. Not really that important if you are going to minimize magic.
I think the Mage is a really safe bet for anyone who plans on using magic in the end-game or perhaps the entire game. It gives the Warrior just a bit more Magicka so he can enjoy creating nice spells too. And Moffatz said he was going to use magic.
Mad Prophet Helmholtz wrote:I would also recommend the Apprentice, but not for a warrior. Donald Trump, great architect of HOTELS and CASINOS, a constructor of generators of ziggurwatt power which ennobles all Supermen to make way for the landing of SPACESHIP JESUS and in opposition to the nefarious illusion world created by GHOST SHARK, for the APPRENTICE = DONALD TRUMP TV SHOW. Watch the Apprentice. I was thrilled to see Joan Rivers win last night. Brilliant mistress of witchcraft Joan Rivers creates FAUX AIDS CHARITY which she sends meals implanted with dangerous poisons to send to AIDS PATIENTS thus hastening quick deaths all in the name of SPACESHIP JESUS.
:shock:
Mad Prophet Helmholtz wrote:The Apprentice makes you 100% weak to magic so it is best to have someone, say a Breton with 50% magic resistance and get that high level Mundane Ring, thereby making you 100% resistant to magic, nullifying your weakness and most importantly PROMOTING TRUMP TV INTO OBLIVION, great game of HOTEL USAGE and living a superreality of apocalyptic proportions!
:shock: :shock:

Anyway, if you want purely combat, take the Warrior.
If you want to use magic with your character (all the time, after X hours of playing, it doesn't matter), take the Mage.
If you're a really experienced player, won't use much magic (only healing, perhaps some weak Destruction spells) and know what you're doing, take the Atronach.

So for your character concept, Moffatz, I recommend The Mage.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 1:06 pm
by Moffattz
Hmmm thanks!

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 1:51 pm
by Blue the Thief
The Atronach! Choose the Atronach! THE ATRONCH!

Ahem.

I think the Atronach would be a good pick, think about it, you start with 50% chance (Read: a coin filp) to absorb all magic thrown your way, and if you make it 100%....

All you'll have to worry about are arrows (No way to deal with them, just dodge 'em) and those big scary orcs wielding a small imperial guard (And thats what shield enchantments are for!)

The Thief is also a good choice, if you want a quick fighter, as are the Warrior and the Lady (Though the Lady is more for Battlemages, methinks)

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 8:41 pm
by Dragour
If you are familiar, very familiar with the Cyrodiil such as locations of spesific enemies, ingredients and bottom line, gameplay, then and only then would I recomend the Atronach, it is a good sign but it is definitely not for beginners or people getting used to the game.

For someone new or fairly new, go for the mage, personally the bonus magicka helps since as I stated magicka only gets capped when you have nothing else to keep improving it. all stats and skills can reach 100 then that birthsign becomes... well it doesn't do anything beyond that.


edit: @ Blue, getting to max resist/reflect magic is actually suprisingly easy without the birthsign. I do have a list :wink: well two actually

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 9:44 pm
by Mad Prophet Helmholtz
josjie wrote:
True, but if you go for maximum health, you'll want to start with an Endurance of 65 instead of 55. And for people who want to maximize Luck, the Thief is a good choice.
So we've Mage, Apprentice, Atronach, Warrior and Thief. All other birthsigns are pretty useless (well only for role-playing or really unusual character concepts, like the Lady).
True, if you want Maximum possible health, then yes you have to start with the 65 so the Warrior would be needed. However, starting at 55 and still +5ing your Endurance every level till you hit 100 would give you a great deal of health, and to me 50% spell absorption > The extra health the Warrior sign would bring.

But perhaps I should explain my playstyle philosophy: I don't believe in Extremes. I do believe in strong specialties, but I don't believe getting the 100% possible health/magicka/etc. is necessary. If you start out at 55, and +5 your End, you'll have more than enough health than needed. My Breton battlemage-type character only started with 30 End, but I +5ed my End asap and I'm at level 26 with it with tremendous amount of health.

josjie wrote:I don't fully agree with that. I've got an Altmer with the Atronach birthsign and he uses magic 90% of the time. And he rocks :D. And I know that there are many others who also enjoy the Altmer + Atronach combination. With 100% Spell Absorption and 100 Alchemy level, you can quite easily regenerate your magicka.
For everyone who has played, let's say, less than 300-400 hours, the Atronach might work better with a warrior, I agree with that.
I knew I was going to get a response to THAT. ;) But, I should clarify my point and I did misrepresent my position on it. Okay, Atronach IS a good sign for a mage, particularily the Altmer, of course, but I do have certain issues with it...
1) Pain in the ass starting out and working up. Potions are few and far between. And there's not too many enemies that hurl spells at you to make your spell absorption that worthwhile.
2) More micromanagement needed (making/using potions, finding ayleid wells, etc.) Even if you have the means to easily recharge your magicka whenever, I think it's a bit annoying to always have to recharge manually. But, that's just my personal opinion.
3) +150 Magicka bonus (vs 100 Apprentice and 50 Mage). I think it's a bit overrated, since you can get transcendent sigil stones and make clothes/armor with Fortify Magicka enchantments. I forget the actual number but I know a maxed out Atronach is 1000+ Magicka. A maxed out App or Mage would just be 50-100 below that, and when you have Magicka pools that large, it's really a minor difference. But, if your goal would be to have the maximum possible amount of magicka...then obviously go for it, but like I said, I don't believe Extremes are necessary.

I do like Altmer (3rd fav race for me) but when it comes to spellcasting types I prefer Breton Apprentice/Mage. They start off with 50% Magic Resistance, which IMHO, is more or less just as useful as the 50% Spell Absorption. Either way, 50% of spells won't work on you! The SA isn't really necessary because you don't have stunted magicka, and a high willpower lets you recharge quickly. And once you get the top level mundane ring you are 100% immune to Magic, and it's a lot easier to attain that than the 100 spell absorption. It also means you only need one slot to get your 100% resist magic, freeing up the rest for other enchantments like Fortify Magic and Reflect Damage.

The downside is a smaller magicka pool, obviously, and it's clear that Altmer are better offensively and Bretons defensively. It really comes down to playstyle and what you are willing to do for your character. I've had a much better experience playing my Breton Mage than my Altmer Atronach. Then again, my character is not a pure mage but skilled in Blade/Block/Heavy Armor so I can hold my own as a warrior as well.

By the way....DONALD TRUMP... No, it's the "Best birthsign for a warrior class" thread, not the "Donald Trump Jesus Spaceship whatever" thread. ~Codex

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 10:29 pm
by AzNmamba
WTF is spaceship jesus?????there is no christianity in oblivion!

Posted: Wed May 13, 2009 2:56 am
by Blue the Thief
Dragour wrote:edit: @ Blue, getting to max resist/reflect magic is actually suprisingly easy without the birthsign. I do have a list :wink: well two actually
It's alot easier when your half way there at the start :P

Also, this is for a Warrior, so the Stunted Magicka means nothing, as does the extra magicka.... but the absorb.... that changes everything....

Just think, you walk into the Necromancer cave, they throw spells at you, and they do nothing... :Twisted Evil: