Page 1 of 3

What killed your immersive adventure?

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 11:22 am
by arbmU
Hey there, new member on the forums - I hope it will be a pleasant stay :)

I think Oblivion is a superb RPG because of it's immersive nature, however sometimes random things happen, which are just horribly out of place!

For me it ruined the game when a guard comes rushing in where I'm standing with ocato and martin in the last part of the main quest.. he informs us in a terrified voice that daedra have invaded the Imperial City! Then, after he's done talking to the other guys, he's looking at me with a huge smile and saying 'Greetings citizen!" ... Citizen?!? Am I not part of the main quest?? And what's with that freaking smile??

Argh .. it looked soo stupid! :D

anyways .. Have you guys experienced anything which totally destroyed your immersive adventures in Cyrodiil?

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 2:00 pm
by Symmachus
omniscient guards are a pain. they know where i am always. and how do they move so fast?!

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 2:51 pm
by arbmU
so true!

The other day I was nicely stacking bottles of vintage wine in my winerack in the Rosethorn basement, when this creep of a guard suddenly surprised me! Then he started rambling about some guy (Glarthir?) whom I have apparently met, but doesn't really give **** about!

How dare he enter my hard-earned property without permission? (Like he would ever get one!)

keep them coming people! :D (please don't make this thread a pure guard-rantm, lol)

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 2:59 pm
by The Crusader
I was once attacked by this guard captain who was dressed as a beggar ages after I'd completed the quest on the road up to my castle. thinking him to be a bandit I ran into my castle, cloed the portcullis and watched him run into it. I think this is the last I'll see of him but a day later (roughly) He leaps at me in a street in Skingrad! WTF! How did he get from Chorrol to Skingrad in 24 hours?

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 3:14 pm
by Valus
I usually discreetly kill the guards that call me "citizen".
Once I was in Kvatch and I went to the chapel and this Legion Soldier just has this weird greeting like, "I've seen your kind, you've got blood on your hands. Keep your blade sheathed you murdering [&@%!], or I'll put you down myself." and the only people I've killed are the beggars and the Thieves Guild. Yeah, Like Legion Soldier could put me down.

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 3:50 pm
by RestlessChicken
it seems the guard AI is a really immersion-killer. we should kill them all before they kill our fun.

'fraid i don't have much to add here otherwise, as it's been a long time since i played oblivion (don't have the game anymore), and i can't remember any WTF moments i've had.

then again, the bright shinyness (bloom?) of bloody near everything put a big dampener on the realism scene.

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 8:00 pm
by Fiar
Entering combat is a general immersion killer. Your walking along, gentle background music, the trees, shrubs, and grass sway in the winds. Then you hear the combat music play, and have to focus on taking out the enemy before you can get on with your adventure.

Only countered when I am looking for epic fights to wage, and loot caves and such. Then it only gives to my adventure.

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 8:12 pm
by Josjie
When you think you're exploring a dungeon with marauders or bandits, and suddenly a zombie pops up.

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 8:33 pm
by Kestral
josjie wrote:When you think you're exploring a dungeon with marauders or bandits, and suddenly a zombie pops up.
If you thinking it, the zombie popping up would be a surprise, that should be intriguing you.

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 8:39 pm
by Josjie
FireAcolyte wrote:Entering combat is a general immersion killer. Your walking along, gentle background music, the trees, shrubs, and grass sway in the winds. Then you hear the combat music play, and have to focus on taking out the enemy before you can get on with your adventure.

Only countered when I am looking for epic fights to wage, and loot caves and such. Then it only gives to my adventure.
100% agree with that. Sometimes I'm looking at my character in 3rd person, while I'm standing on a big rock and looking at the beautiful landscape, and then suddenly the music changes and I'm attacked by a stupid Imp.

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 11:27 pm
by austinpwnz
My biggest peeve in this area is when NPCs don't recognize you for who you are. I mean, I finished SI and I should be addressed by my proper title (you know who) by everyone in Bliss and Crucible! Also, Fighters Guild members should realize that I am the guild head, same for Mages Guild. They seem to notice this in the ambient conversation when they walk nearby, but not in the actual conversation menu.

I also kind of wish there were more quests but they were harder to start and less simplistic...but when that starts to really bother me I'll get more mods.

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 12:30 am
by Dragour
This isn't as much to do with the immerseness of the game but it did ruin it for me, they took out too many skills and items, such as medium armour, spears and halbergs, crossbows! throwing knives, all the good stuff from Morrowind never made it into Oblivion

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 1:55 am
by The Ninja
I shot a guard in some tiny village while atop a place that wouldn't be possible for him to climb. Then he seemingly "teleports" right into my face :shock: and says, "You have broken the law..." yada yada yada. I was like "WTHeck?!!?" and I ran off into the nearby woods.

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 2:00 am
by Kestral
My immersive adventure died when I died.


"Dark dungeon... ph4t l00t... OMGOGOMGOMGOMGOMGOMG 2 Spider Daedra and 6 Clannfear OMGOMGOMGOMGOMGOMGOMG- *dies*"

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 2:32 am
by KaiJin
Kestral wrote:
josjie wrote:When you think you're exploring a dungeon with marauders or bandits, and suddenly a zombie pops up.
If you thinking it, the zombie popping up would be a surprise, that should be intriguing you.
... and it's a Dread Zombie that gives you Astral Vapors ?

- KJ

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 5:39 am
by yomanj
My biggest peeve in this area is when NPCs don't recognize you for who you are. I mean, I finished SI and I should be addressed by my proper title (you know who) by everyone in Bliss and Crucible!
Ya right... Or when you return to Cyrodil with all this exotic weaponry, clothing, slighty insane... People should give mad props right.

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 5:43 am
by yomanj
... and it's a Dread Zombie that gives you Astral Vapors ?
Nah, it was the chili at The Bloated Float.

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 6:13 am
by Grade Zero
I was walking and I saw a Bandit hunting a deer. I killed the deer and the Bandit started walking back to wherever. I expected a fight, but he ignored me. I talked to him and got his Disposition to 89. :D

My reaction was: WTF??!?!? I'm friends with a Bandit?

So I walked with him for a while and as we were walking, we came across a courier whom the Bandit then started to attack. The horse was frozen in place (but it's still doing the 'running' animation). I couldn't talk the courier because she was trying to flee even though her horse isn't going anywhere and my Bandit friend was whacking her silly.

After a few seconds, a guard passed by and attacked the Bandit. I cast a demoralize spell on the Bandit and pretended I 'told' him to run.

We all ran east, with me casting Demoralize all the way. In a twist of fate, we ran into more Bandits (damn Bandit camp).

The guard easily killed my Bandit because I couldn't cast Demoralize (I was defending myself from the new Bandits). I watched as my newfound friend dies.

By the time the guard finishes the rest of them off, his horse was dead. But he still did the 'ride horse' animation as though there was a horse there! He was floating in mid-air as if he was on it. But the glitch made him appear closer to the ground and scrunched up like an accordian.

In the end, I ended up talking to this guy who killed my friend and traveled with him, killing bears, boars, and more bandits.

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 8:20 am
by Josjie
Grade Zero wrote:I was walking and I saw a Bandit hunting a deer. I killed the deer and the Bandit started walking back to wherever. I expected a fight, but he ignored me. I talked to him and got his Disposition to 89. :D

My reaction was: WTF??!?!? I'm friends with a Bandit?

So I walked with him for a while and as we were walking, we came across a courier whom the Bandit then started to attack. The horse was frozen in place (but it's still doing the 'running' animation). I couldn't talk the courier because she was trying to flee even though her horse isn't going anywhere and my Bandit friend was whacking her silly.

After a few seconds, a guard passed by and attacked the Bandit. I cast a demoralize spell on the Bandit and pretended I 'told' him to run.

We all ran east, with me casting Demoralize all the way. In a twist of fate, we ran into more Bandits (damn Bandit camp).

The guard easily killed my Bandit because I couldn't cast Demoralize (I was defending myself from the new Bandits). I watched as my newfound friend dies.

By the time the guard finishes the rest of them off, his horse was dead. But he still did the 'ride horse' animation as though there was a horse there! He was floating in mid-air as if he was on it. But the glitch made him appear closer to the ground and scrunched up like an accordian.

In the end, I ended up talking to this guy who killed my friend and traveled with him, killing bears, boars, and more bandits.
Lol, amazing story. Wish that happened to me.

A few months ago, I achieved 100% completion with one character (over 100 hours playing time). I just finished the Shivering Isles expansion and I was thinking: "what's next?" Could there still be something to do?
So I just walked through the Imperial City, sold a few items at the Market District, entered the Arena district and there I found... the Adoring Fan. I've killed him a dozen times at Dive Rock, but he simply respawned. And he ran up to me and was about to speak when I thought: wth, pressed exit and created a new character. Never played with that other character again ;).

Posted: Mon May 11, 2009 9:42 pm
by Valus
This may seem a bit off-topic, but has anyone else ever noticed that the island on which the Imperial City is on kind of resembles North America?

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 4:16 am
by Mad Prophet Helmholtz
For some reason, I've started a permanent Mages Guild vs Battlemage war on one of my characters. I forget what I did, but I was probably messing around with some Frenzy spells or something one day. Thing is, everytime I go to Arcane University, there is an all out battle between a helpless battlemage getting jumped by 3-4 naked Mage Scholars.

This has been going on forever. I will leve AU, travel around Cyrodiil for an in-game month or two then come back, and the damn war is still going on.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 7:04 am
by yomanj
I was walking and I saw a Bandit hunting a deer. I killed the deer and the Bandit started walking back to wherever. I expected a fight, but he ignored me. I talked to him and got his Disposition to 89. Very Happy

My reaction was: WTF??!?!? I'm friends with a Bandit?
Kinda reminds of the time I was, heck, somewhere I don't quite remember... There was a gang of marauders (though I think they were called something different, Miners maybe...) anyways, they wear inside a town or village attacking when I exited a building.... They/we killed the guards, kinda hung out for a while.... was weird.

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 11:10 am
by arbmU
Very nice stories y'all have! :D

I really laugh hard each time I hear a story about stupid guards .. talk about low AI!

I have one for myself, and this time it is not something caused by a glitch or anything like that ..

Have you tried going to a cave or dungeon at a high level, expecting to find all kinds of bad-ass glass or daedric-compound weapons lying on the floor - cause in the lower levels all you could find lying around were items of iron or fur?

BUT NO! I'm opening my 36th Oblivion gate with my uberhard level 17 battlemage.. I find some corpses right inside the portal, and just now have glass and daedric weaponry and apparel appeared in random loot. But why the hell are the corpses still wearing crude iron weapons and tattered fur armor? - it must be on the part of Bethesda .. apparantly, everything that's not nailed down in the game (scripted corpses or other items) will never change, even though everything else levels up with me?

Oh the disbelief!

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 12:13 pm
by Blue the Thief
Valus wrote:This may seem a bit off-topic, but has anyone else ever noticed that the island on which the Imperial City is on kind of resembles North America?
Maybe, but I think the whole of Cyrodiil looks alot like Australia, have a look-see:

Cyrodiil - Australia

And Cyrodiil even has a place called the gold coast! We must take action!

....Or maybe I'm going insane again :lol:

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 12:49 pm
by Brass Petals
i managed to turn a situation of two guards chasing when i broke into a house when i went down into the basement of a house in the imperial city and three vampires attacked me. they helped out and then totally forgot i were chasing me lol i think it was a quest in the thieves guild that took me to tht house.
in the main quest i just kept accidently hitting them and killed them. they were always in the way which was more of a hassle really.