Page 1 of 2

I am thinking about buying morrowind....

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 2:18 am
by shakeandscream
But I don't know if I should buy the GotY edition or the regular. Or if I should get it for PC?
Do you guys have an opinion on which is the best?

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 2:24 am
by apploud
GOTY is best, as for computer or XBOX...Its up to you. I have it for both and found it more fun on xbox, and mods can be fun but most cheapen the game =/.

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 2:33 am
by shakeandscream
Yeah, i was leaning towards xbox, seems more reliable and what not.
Thanks!

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 3:10 am
by urthdigger
I heartily recommend the PC version. The game has more than it's fair share of bugs, and there are a few patches to fix things, as well as mods to improve the graphics in the game. It can also be handy to use the console to fix things when a bug screws stuff up.

Yes, mods can cheapen gameplay (I recall last time I beat the game... kinda zipped through due to a lot of mods that made it easier in one way or another), but there's also a lot of mods that do things the game should have had in the first place.

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 8:29 am
by Đ¢eatime
urthdigger wrote:I heartily recommend the PC version. The game has more than it's fair share of bugs, and there are a few patches to fix things, as well as mods to improve the graphics in the game. It can also be handy to use the console to fix things when a bug screws stuff up.

Yes, mods can cheapen gameplay (I recall last time I beat the game... kinda zipped through due to a lot of mods that made it easier in one way or another), but there's also a lot of mods that do things the game should have had in the first place.
I concur, the PC version is preferable.
And you can't really put any blame on the mods for cheapening the game either, it's up to you which mods you want to use and believe me, there's plenty of good mods out there that just enhance gameplay in marvelous ways. Not to mention the texture replacement packs and Better Bodies for a more eye pleasing game. :D

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 9:05 am
by Dragour
I have to say get it for the PC, there are alot of bugs and little mishaps which can only be solved by the console, which happens to be only PC.
Plus it wasn't entirely designed for the xbox, I too have it for xbox (and pc) and I personally preffer the PC version

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 10:39 am
by alowe
i haven't played the xbox version but some of the mods on pc mw improve the ambiance and feel of the scenery/towns etc. just avoid the mods that cheapen the game for you and be picky about what you install. you can customize mw to how you like it really indepth or just tweak a bit here and there :)

but, the only advantage i can see of the xbox over pc is avoiding all the other little hassles that the pc throw up like ms bloatware, the bill gates virus (called windows), old peeceeitis etc :P xbox is ready to go simple :)

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 11:41 am
by Dragour
To me the xbox version is more difficult, one reason being the inventory, you don't have a cursor to quickly click on what item you want, you have to scroll through them starting at top left going down. It can take ages when you have alot of stuff while the pc you can zoom straight to what ever item your looking for.

One major bonus for the xbox however is that you can toggle sneak mode, it is an utter [female dog] to keep in sneak mode on the pc for me since holding the button down too long makes my character reset out of sneak mode <_<

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 3:35 pm
by trooperdx3117
Definitely get the PC version the inventory and journal system is definitely moreso designed for pc and you can get quite a few mods on the pc that improve the gameplay and graphics of the game.

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 4:57 pm
by Rohugh
Dragour wrote:
One major bonus for the xbox however is that you can toggle sneak mode, it is an utter [female dog] to keep in sneak mode on the pc for me since holding the button down too long makes my character reset out of sneak mode <_<
You can toggle sneak on the pc. If you have sticky keys on your computer, set them before loading the game and as sneak is on the Ctrl button you can just toggle it on and off. On XP you hit shift five times to set them.

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 4:57 pm
by Caz
PC, for reasons already given.
GOTY - more fun :D Plus, if you end up interested in mods, which you may need the expansions for, then you already have them.

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 5:18 pm
by H8Ball
If it comes down to a choice between GOTY for PC or Xbox, I'd go for the PC version every time. Put simply, PC version can be patched (major advantage) but Xbox can't (major disadvantage).

Basically, on PC, you can do anything you like. Beautify the outdated graphics to bring them up-to-date (run at high screen resolution, replace old low-res blurry textures with high-res photorealistic versions, replace old blocky segmented models with high-detail smooth versions), add extra ambient sounds to bring "life" to the world, sort potions/keys in your inventory. You have the new Journal system which allows you to filter Journal entries by Quest Title. You can download/install ANY mods you like to change gameplay, add new quests, landmasses, cities, buildings, people, creatures, etc. You have the Construction Set that allows you to create your own mods. Finally, you can add "patch" mods that fix hundreds of bugs (broken quests, etc).

Personally, I'm running Morrowind at 1360 x 768 screen resolution on a 32" Widescreen 16:9 LCD TV (with PC RGB input so I can use it as a massive monitor). I have high-res textures, Better Bodies, Atmospheric Sound Effects, readable roadsigns, and almost ALL bugs fixed. The game looks and sounds fantastic!

In contrast, on Xbox, you're stuck with the game as-it-was-released, i.e. outdated graphics, few ambient sounds, badly sorted inventory, bad Journal system, no mods, no construction set, and no bugs fixed.

Essential PC patches include:-

Unofficial Morrowind Patch (UMP) - ESP mod that fixes a lot of quest-related bugs

Morrowind Code Patch (MCP) - Modifies Morrowind.exe to fix bugs that UMP can't

There's also a massive mod in-progress for PC, called Tamriel Rebuilt. According to Elder Scrolls Lore, Vvardenfell isn't an island, but is part of the continent of Tamriel. This mod aims to add a massive number of exterior/interior landmass cells representing mainland Tamriel surrounding Vvardenfell, complete with cities and hundreds of quests to take on. Once I'm finished the Main Quest, I plan to download/install it to massively extend the gameplay.

I know which version I'd choose!

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 11:36 pm
by shakeandscream
I have to say i am convinced of buying the PC GotY edition.
Thanks for all the input!

Posted: Fri May 08, 2009 2:09 am
by H8Ball
HUGE THUMBS UP! :D

I bought Morrowind in 2002 (when it was originally released), Tribunal in 2003 (for the new Journal system) and finally, GOTY in Jan this year (for Bloodmoon because I couldn't find it separately).

I'm on my 4th or 5th play-through (can't remember which) and have enjoyed every one as a different character. It's just one of those games I keep coming back to and, every time I start a new game, I'm in for months of gameplay.

My current play-through has lasted over 3 months, is up to somewhere around 750+ hours of gameplay (estimated) and I'm STILL only a third of the way through the Main Quest (saving it for last). There's enough possibilities to keep me going for life!

And even when I've exhausted all it has to offer, there's still mods to add new places to explore and hundreds of new quests. Looks like I'll be leaving this game to someone in my will!

Here's to many, many years of enjoyment...

Posted: Fri May 08, 2009 9:42 am
by alowe
i've played through twice.

1st time i only had mw and didn't know you could join almost every faction. played the main quest mainly (as hlaalu). was a bit surprised when it ended so quickly.

2nd time i had bloodmoon and tribunal. went out of my way to join everyone and do all quests. went redoran this time. the game lasted three times longer. even added some mod quests like the island of menya. lasted three times longer.

3rd time - if i do play mw again it may not be for a few years since i know the quests well. will then hunt around for all the good mods i can find. maybe the tamriel rebuilt project will be done by then. then start on 100 difficulty and aim to use enchanting more. as telvanni, that'll make it a newer experience.

by then budget laptops will be starting to be powerful enough to play oblivion (with a gfx card) and i'll probably move to that. after hearing how easy it is will probably do it max difficulty (if there is difficulty)

Posted: Fri May 08, 2009 10:24 am
by Dragour
Rohugh wrote:
Dragour wrote:
One major bonus for the xbox however is that you can toggle sneak mode, it is an utter [female dog] to keep in sneak mode on the pc for me since holding the button down too long makes my character reset out of sneak mode <_<
You can toggle sneak on the pc. If you have sticky keys on your computer, set them before loading the game and as sneak is on the Ctrl button you can just toggle it on and off. On XP you hit shift five times to set them.
... You win this round... sadly my laptop is, not working (don't ask, I'm still puzzled) so I can't try this but if you can toggle sneak mode on PC then... damn

Posted: Fri May 08, 2009 10:32 pm
by shakeandscream
So, my understanding is Bloodmoon is only available on GotY edition?

Posted: Fri May 08, 2009 10:53 pm
by Rohugh
With XBox it is only available as the GOTY edition.

For pc it is (or was) possible to buy the Bloodmoon disc as an add-on expansion if you already had Morrowind. However, the individual expansion disc has become rarer and price wise it is probably just as cheap to buy the complete GOTY edition (which also includes the Tribunal expansion). You may find the BM disc somewhere like ebay.

The pc GOTY version is available either as a three disc cd set (4 if you include the extra Construction Set cd (not needed if you are not going to mod)) or as a single disc DVD edition (again 2 with the cs disc).

Posted: Sat May 09, 2009 3:15 am
by Dragour
The Morrowind GOTY for PC that I bought came with one cd, all three games (morrowind, bloodmoon and tribunal) and also the construction set.
It was only $20 at dicksmith and it was the first time one had been there, and the last :cry: they only stocked the one game (they told me) and they were never going to restock as they don't make the game anymore, so really fate brought me and the game together ^^

Posted: Mon Jun 01, 2009 9:44 pm
by Stormscape
The single reason to get PC version imo: http://planetelderscrolls.gamespy.com/V ... ail&id=422

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 2:49 am
by Ryce
I'm trying to find GOTY for Xbox but I check every store in my area and they don't have it. I also try Ebay and the one I order was defective and also cost alot. $30 total for game and shipping. Since it was defective, shipping back to the seller cost me another $15.

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 4:39 pm
by gdsmack267
Ryce wrote:I'm trying to find GOTY for Xbox but I check every store in my area and they don't have it. I also try Ebay and the one I order was defective and also cost alot. $30 total for game and shipping. Since it was defective, shipping back to the seller cost me another $15.
I bound GOTY for the pc off of amazon last summer brand new for only like 20 bucks. Dont trust eBay

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 4:41 pm
by gdsmack267
Ryce wrote:I'm trying to find GOTY for Xbox but I check every store in my area and they don't have it. I also try Ebay and the one I order was defective and also cost alot. $30 total for game and shipping. Since it was defective, shipping back to the seller cost me another $15.
Here check this link out, scroll down a little bit to skip the featured ones and choose from one of the new ones. The price is as low as 13-15 bucks now.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/offer-listing/ ... dition=new

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 8:20 pm
by Ryce
tats pc version though, i need xbox

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 9:14 pm
by gdsmack267
Ryce wrote:tats pc version though, i need xbox
why xbox? I have both and pc version is 100 times better. The load times on xbox are so annoying not to mention pc looks so much better.