Page 1 of 1
Elder Scrolls V: Multiple Characters in a Single Game File?
Posted: Sat Feb 28, 2009 2:05 am
by billydowlingr
Hi guys, I'm Billy.
But getting straight to the point I've often played Oblivion as a roleplay-specific character on each run-through. For example I'd play a sly yet noble thief who'd work his way up the ranks of the thieves guild, stealing from the rich and giving to the poor. This thieve character would never go near the Dark Brotherhood quest-line, and was very stealthy, thus never joining the Fighters Guild. Much like many of you, I'd have various character builds who would only 'play' certain parts of the game. My Nord warrior would never join the Mages Guild. My poor peasant Waterfront scavenger would never buy a house and always sleep rough etc. etc.
I got thinking about the possibilities for Bethesda to try something new with The Elder Scrolls V, and allow you to create several characters (lets cap it at a grand total of five), all of which you could roleplay as in the same game world/save file.
You could have a warrior, a mage, a thief, a murderer and
whatever all in the same game world if you wanted, all getting involved in their own adventures and stories. You could have the five never cross paths, or have their destinies intertwine.
Sounds gimmicky and fairly problematic. I don't envision this in the typical RPG party way, where a party of characters will typically band together. I'm thinking more keep it to the feel of other Elder Scrolls game, where you're all alone in the big bad world for the most part.
Say you play a few days as your Mage character and he advances a major quest along, levels up a fair little amount, but due to him (I dunno) angering a large army of bandits, the next time you decide to play as your cowardly, under-developed stealth character, he is caught in the cross-fire of previously mentioned angry bandit army, who are hunting the wilderness for your dangerous (much higher leveled) mage, who many tell great stories of because of his fabled adventures. How will your weak thief cope in this world? Would your murderer character be part of the bandit guild?
I think this would open up a whole new layer of freedom and storytelling within The Elder Scrolls V. I'd be interested for your thoughts - feel free.
Billy
Posted: Sat Feb 28, 2009 4:31 am
by WolfGang IceEye
I love this idea. Maybe you can bring to a whole new level by adding relationships. Picture this: Dark elf 1is highly attracted to bretons and Mr. serge over there just so happens to be a young rich breton mage. Romance ensues.
Posted: Sat Feb 28, 2009 4:40 am
by Doctor Meaticus
WolfGang IceEye wrote:Picture this: Dark elf 1is highly attracted to bretons and Mr. serge over there just so happens to be a young rich breton mage. Romance ensues.
Uhh... Ew? Dark Elves? Try something that is actually human.
The idea of intertwining characters is brilliant. However, you would only play one character at a time, and any character you weren't playing at the time would either disappear from the game world or just stand in the same place, reducing realism whatever happens. And if the unplayed character went his own way while you played as someone else, you could start playing said unplayed character to find yourself lost somewhere you didn't start off.
Posted: Sat Feb 28, 2009 4:27 pm
by billydowlingr
Yeah it's a tricky one, eh? I think for something along the lines of the 'where do your other characters disappear to when you're not playing as them?' question would best be resolved in the most simplistic manner, even at the sacrifice of realism. For example, if your active character came across one of your inactive characters, inactive character would simply be sleeping on a bedroll where you left them, and any attempt to interact with them would be met with a 'Character is resting' message. But this resolution would bring about its own whole set of problems, especially for players who would like their characters to interact in the game world.
For me personally, the appeal is in having a handful of playable characters who all influence the world in their own massive or subtle ways, all played by you, but they themselves never interact or meet, despite a constant crossing of paths. The appeal for me personally is also in the huge amounts of experimenting this would open up, and new ways to tell a story, without necessarily having to reset the entire game world just to bring in a whole new character, as with other games.
Of course this also brings about the possibility of some sort of multiplayer where any number of people can play in and effect the same world at their leisure (though no more than one person can play at a time), but I am of the opinion The Elder Scrolls is one epic adventure best left unshared lol.
Come to think of it I wonder if there are any mods like this for the Elder Scrolls series. I am a 360 player but am aware of all the benefits of PC gaming, so am thinking of jumping ship.
Billy
Posted: Sat Feb 28, 2009 5:42 pm
by Blue the Thief
I'd like to make my character, then make AI controlled Party members, for example, I could make Blue as my main, then make all the other characters! (Red, Crimson, you-know), And you could also mess with the AI so that:
.They'll cast spells
.fight melee
.bow and arrow.
Or a combantion!, and to stop it from being unfair (Imagne my group, thats a Thief/Assassin, a Dark Wizard, a Tank Fighter, a quick and skillful fighter and a Healer!) For each character you make, the enermys get stronger and what-not!
It would be....magical

Posted: Sat Feb 28, 2009 6:04 pm
by Vargon
I would love that idea; especially how the characters could indirectly affect each others' lives. It would be amazing for roleplaying purposes, and general gaming alike; I'd be surprised if there wasn't already a mod for it.

Posted: Sat Feb 28, 2009 7:42 pm
by Boulderheart
Yeah thus would be a great idea tbh even to intereact with you other characters belongings, to break into their house and steal an artifact of greatness.
Posted: Sat Feb 28, 2009 7:53 pm
by Arzock
Maybe when your characters are inactiive they could be controlled by AI, and you could decide their personality?
Posted: Sat Feb 28, 2009 8:02 pm
by Boulderheart
yes i agree with azrockand decide where they go - like the countess of leyawiin, she always travels etc, perhaps your character could be found hanging around caves, or swimming in the lake or hacking down innocents.
Posted: Sat Feb 28, 2009 8:45 pm
by WolfGang IceEye
There is probably a mod out there that adds AI controlled followers that you create. (Check TES nexus .com) Maybe when you are not playing as a character said character would continue on with there regular schedule. For example: (SPOLIER)
If one of your characters is the listener for the DB he would take the trip to Bravil to see the night mother's statue.
But what would happen if one of you characters is walking in the forest and is attacked by a wolf pack? Should your inactive characters be unable to die? Maybe only the character you are playing as can kill your inactive characters.
Posted: Sat Feb 28, 2009 9:30 pm
by billydowlingr
Perhaps they could just fall unconscious like essential characters in Oblivion do. I still say for the sake of keeping it simple and bug/issue free, sacrifice the realism and just have your inactive characters 'rest.'
If you're playing as a vampire you can bite their necks!
Billy
Posted: Sat Feb 28, 2009 9:51 pm
by WolfGang IceEye
Maybe when you don't want to play as the character any more you would have to bring it to it's house or rent it a room at inn or sleep at a camp etc. But if you don't you might come back to that character to find him with no gold left on his person.

Posted: Sun Mar 01, 2009 2:25 am
by The King
As long as there is no romance, I don't want elves have little elves in my games.
Posted: Sun Mar 01, 2009 3:38 am
by Coulsonji
Maybe when you make the characters you set a place for them to go back to? And if you try to talk to them, they will tell you to go away or something?
Or, maybe to save and exit your game, you HAVE to go to a certain spot? I'm not sure, brainstorming will sort this one out

.
Posted: Sun Mar 01, 2009 9:17 am
by billydowlingr
I wonder if Bethesda would consider such an idea, and how best to make them aware of it? Of course they've probably thought over such an idea (or similar) many times.
I don't know a whole lot about modding at all, but seeing how easy it was to get rid of the borders in Oblivion, I assume it can't be all that hard to go into the console and start creating multiple playable characters? Of course I don't have a PC version of Oblivion so can't try it for myself yet.
Thanks to the link for that mod site, WolfGang.
Billy
Posted: Thu Mar 12, 2009 5:46 pm
by kjdanext
Maybe you have to go to a bed you own or rent one or sleep on the ground(wait) and then autosave and char change.
Posted: Thu Mar 12, 2009 6:45 pm
by randomfrog
The King wrote:As long as there is no romance, I don't want elves have little elves in my games.
I cannot say how much I agree with you. Keep romace out of TES V! That's the reason I don't have Fable 2!
Posted: Thu Mar 12, 2009 7:27 pm
by Kestral
randomfrog wrote:The King wrote:As long as there is no romance, I don't want elves have little elves in my games.
I cannot say how much I agree with you. Keep romace out of TES V! That's the reason I don't have Fable 2!
The "romance" (you could barely call it that) in Fable 2 has nothing to do with the main game. Where's the romance in pumping your arm in front of a lady for 12 minutes at the tavern, getting married, and have kids and leave off to the great yonder never to arrive again except to adjust the family funds?
Posted: Fri Mar 13, 2009 11:02 am
by Mattbott
Great idea
For this to really work the ai would have to be good enough to play your dormant characters. Unless the game deals with what happens when you meet your own character, it's missing the point IMO. You'd also have to limit the number of potential characters, otherwise you'd get people filling the world with an army of mattbott clones, for example. 3 or 4 might be a good number of characters to work with. I can see this getting hideously complicated and crashing often.
So, When you start each character the game asks you to customise his/her behavior and this behavior can itself be modified during the game by your actions when you're playing that character. Whilst dormant, the character still moves around and does their 'normal' routine, but can't undertake quests.
It would be allowing you, the player, to ceate really interesting npcs (after all, you will only play one at a time). The logical conclusion to this is you end up fighting your own characters, perhaps with the help of other characters you have built.
My first thought is that I would use this to create a super villain for my hero to fight (or vice versa). I suppose eventually all the guild masters would be my own characters and so for a new character to get anywhere, they would have to depose one of my high level characters.. Similarly, as the guildmaster, I might decide every now and then to go out into the world and seek out all potential threats and have a 'purge' which might mean hunting down and killing (or locking up?) my own low level character (who might then have to escape from the guild cell?) who has been moving up the ranks too quickly.
It's the ability to mod the characters, rather than just the world, which could be amazing. The world would have to be bigger, though, 'this town aint big enough for the two of us' springs to mind, unless you limit a character to only doing one or two questlines (or close some quest paths down as choices are made).
It is steering Oblivion down the fable road a bit, i wonder if bethesda have that much ambition/ability in the AI engineering department? Bethesda workers probably scan most of these forums so if they can do it and want to do it, they will do it. It would definitely take the current TES series to the next level.