Page 1 of 4

How about that Dark Brotherhood, eh?

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 5:45 pm
by jelpower
What would be your thoughts about this subject?
Are they evil?
Do you like them?
Is this a nice addition to Oblivion?
And what are some interesting points?

I'm listening, fire away!

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 6:01 pm
by J'Ghasta
The Dark Brotherhood is not pure evil,but they are not the kindess people either.They kill for gold and magical stuff.I do really like 'em (with tail=better)They are the "gold" in oblivion.All history and dialougs makes 'em the best :wink:

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 6:05 pm
by Josjie
Are they evil?

Nope, they're "grey", just like almost everyone in Oblivion. Even the Daedra are not evil. Even heroes like Martin Septim and Jauffre make mistakes. The members of the Dark Brotherhood serve Sithis and they think that what they're doing is good. Otherwise they won't be doing it.

Do you like them?

In my opinion the Dark Brotherhood questline is the best questline vanilla Oblivion has to offer. I say "vanilla", because I am a great fan of the Lost Spires mod which adds an Archeology Guild.

Is this a nice addition to Oblivion?

Sure! The Dark Brotherhood is perfect for all rogues and assassins out here! And for role-playing purposes it's also great!

And what are some interesting points?

The choices you must make, the multiple ways to complete a quest. The difficulty of the quests. Ehm... and of course the (bonus) rewards you'll get. The Dark Brotherhood armorset is one of the best looking pieces of armor in my opinion and the Black Hand Hood & Robe are also great.

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 6:19 pm
by jelpower
The lost spires? i'll check that mod out then! seems very interesting.

I like the brotherhood especially for the dark atmosphere. For me darkness means power, and power means control :Twisted Evil: i like control :Twisted Evil:

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 8:34 pm
by Kelt
i wouldn't exactly say the DB is evil, they do what they do because they get paid for it. I see them as sort of a mecenary type, where as they do whatever the contractor wants as long as they got the money. I also think its neat how they can receive contracts from different people in different lands like morrowind through the use of praying to the Night Mother

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 8:42 pm
by Mattbott
i like the brotherhood cos the quests are by and large quite straight forward. You also get involved with the welbeing of the group straight away, whereas the heirarchies in the mages and fighters guilds mean you are doing chores for middle management for a long time before things get interesting.

The members support each other and if youre part of the group, they are 'good' to you, but the idea of killing for money is pretty much as near to evil as you can get. I know you could say that about soldiers, but the difference is the law supports the army whereas the Dark Bro operate outside the law and have no interest in any moral considerations, literally they cherry pick jobs from people who pay money for a death.

In Oblivion, there are more evil people out there and definitely people you would have less respect for than the dark bro as an organisation.
But..
Spoiler: when the time came for me to purge the Cheydinhall gang, i did a lot of wandering around trying to find an alternative to killing them all like i was instructed.
If someone told me to slaughter the fighters or mages guilds, i'd have got stuck in without a pause. So that says something for the Dark Brotherhood.

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 8:43 pm
by The_Argonian
I, really love the DB! It has the best quests in the game! (Followed by the Mages Guild of course) But I hate the Purification! :( I dont like killing my best friend Teinaava over, and over again! :cry:

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 8:50 pm
by jelpower
The_Argonian wrote:I, really love the DB! It has the best quests in the game! (Followed by the Mages Guild of course) But I hate the Purification! :( I dont like killing my best friend Teinaava over, and over again! :cry:
I enjoy it every time over and over again! :Twisted Evil: :Twisted Evil:

But the at the purification quest where you get the info why you have to purify, there were other DB buildings mentioned if i'm not wrong.

I'd like to see those too!

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 8:54 pm
by The_Argonian
Sadly, you wont see any of the others ingame. Why doesnt someone make a "DB sanctuary in every major city" mod?

Re: How about that Dark Brotherhood, eh?

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 9:10 pm
by Alchemy Addict
jelpower wrote:What would be your thoughts about this subject?
Are they evil?
Do you like them?
Is this a nice addition to Oblivion?
And what are some interesting points?

I'm listening, fire away!
They are sort of evil.. I mean they worship the Night Mother....

I do like them! I mean what is better than an organization of killers!

It is a very fitting and well thought-out addition to Oblivion. It wouldn't be the same without it.

Oh BTW, your quote is cool :Twisted Evil:

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 9:29 pm
by Dark Spark
Incompetent, gullible fools unworthy of the fear they somehow convey upon the rest of the population. I've seen more menace permeating a Venice Beach candle shop.

My regret is that I couldn't get rid of Arquen. Talk about failing upwards, that one.

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 12:56 am
by WolfGang IceEye
I was hoping to see a war between the dark brother hood and the morag tong.(with drowning pool-bodies playing)

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 1:53 am
by Alchemy Addict
WolfGang IceEye wrote:I was hoping to see a war between the dark brother hood and the morag tong.(with drowning pool-bodies playing)
That would be an interesting addition to the game. But I don't know about it :?

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 2:16 am
by The King
WolfGang IceEye wrote:I was hoping to see a war between the dark brother hood and the morag tong.(with drowning pool-bodies playing)
You could always mod the morang tong in, and play Drowning Pool.



Dark Brotherhood is my favorite addition to The Elder Scrolls Series. This is probably my all time favorite guild, even beating Telvanni.

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 4:21 am
by Aendra
I love the dark brotherhood , Not so much the person who looks like a bad breed of a dog, arquen I think she's called. I remember when I got sufferthorn xD it was pretty awesome :D lol
Would be cool if some other assassin guilds were open. however, roleplaying the Crimson scars is fun :)

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 9:16 am
by jelpower
WolfGang IceEye wrote:I was hoping to see a war between the dark brother hood and the morag tong.(with drowning pool-bodies playing)
Yeah, i read about this yesterday. Would be kinda kewl if the morag tong would show itself a bit more. And the Night mothers history is clearly explained in the book written by Enric Milres. If the book is correct, the night mother would actually be a thief, who found it easier to kill the victim, which brought her to the thought of killing them for money.
A quite interesting part of lore.

I do have to say i agree greatly with the night mother. Why not raid someones possesions if they're dead? Right?
Means double income :Twisted Evil:

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 9:21 am
by jelpower
The_Argonian wrote:Sadly, you wont see any of the others ingame. Why doesnt someone make a "DB sanctuary in every major city" mod?
Exactly!!

I'm learning to mod, if ill learn it good enough, i might just try and make my first mod, this kind of mod.

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 9:40 am
by Shanks
The Dark Brotherhood is the best!. One thing that would have been cool is if they had a rival agency kind of like the Fighter Guild and the Blackwood company. You Could be a Double agent!

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 9:44 am
by Aendra
Sir Shankalot wrote:The Dark Brotherhood is the best!. One thing that would have been cool is if they had a rival agency kind of like the Fighter Guild and the Blackwood company. You Could be a Double agent!

Yeah, The crimson scars would be good for that xD

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 10:22 am
by Mattbott
or the Morag Tong?

Maybe the Blackwood company could have taken over the fighters guild's position in Cyrodiil if it had help from Shadowscales - the one you kill for Teiinaava could have been a scout for them and there could have been a joint Fighter/Brotherhood plotline.

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 2:06 pm
by Dark Spark
Or the employees of a Venice Beach candle shop?

Posted: Fri Jan 16, 2009 12:58 am
by Teinaava
jelpower wrote:And the Night mothers history is clearly explained in the book written by Enric Milres. If the book is correct, the night mother would actually be a thief, who found it easier to kill the victim, which brought her to the thought of killing them for money.
A quite interesting part of lore.
I think that that's only the description of one Night Mother. I don't think the Night Mother is a person, but a title given to various individuals (similar to The Underking who has been identified as King Wulfharth and Zurin Arctus among others). The reason I think this, is that Night Mother has been identified as several different people. In Fire and Darkness: The Brotherhoods of Death, the Night Mother is said to be Mephala; in 2920, Sun's Height (v7), the Night Mother is said to be the leader of the Morag Tong; in Sacred Witness, the Night Mother is identified as a former Thieves Guild member who prefered to kill her victim before robbing him; in Morrowind, the Night Mother is identified as Severa Magia; in Oblivion, the Night Mother is a spirit who is the wife of Sithis.

Posted: Fri Jan 16, 2009 5:56 am
by Symmachus
but what about the theory that talos, tiber, underking are parts of a whole, like the christian holy trinity?
maybe the night mother can be all of those people. they might also have faked a few of them lol. i think sacred witness is the most credible because he was killed for writing it.

Posted: Fri Jan 16, 2009 6:30 am
by Aendra
I do wonder if she does have any connection to Sithis though...Sometimes I wonder XD Because doesn't she say Sithis has forseen it when you finish the DB questline? And what about the Crimson scars? enemies of the DB yet, The CS serve sithis and the DB supposedly do, Due to The night mothers marriage

Posted: Fri Jan 16, 2009 11:45 am
by Sarendei
A little off topic but... just out of curiosity, where's the key for the well into the sanctuary?