Page 1 of 1

resist magic & spell abosrption/reflection question

Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 6:04 pm
by stk01001
is there any point in having spell absorption/reflection equipment if you have 100% resistance to magic?

My character currently has 100% magic resistance along with around 30% spell reflection and like 15% spell absorption. My question is.. is the spell reflection/absorption even doing anything for me since I have 100% resistance?? Since I'm resisting all the spell damage it seems like there would be nothing left over to reflect/absorb.

What about if I had less than 100% magic resistance.. like say 90%.. would it make a difference then? Do you guys reccomend combining resistance to magic with these other effects??

I'm just trying to come up with the best combination of items and I don't want to be wearing any armor/jewlery that isn't benefitting me.. I'm thinking it would be better to combine the magic resistance with some physical damage reflection effects so that way I'm covered against magic and physical attacks. Thoughts, suggestions??

Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 6:09 pm
by The Edgy Redguard
Spell Absoption adds to your Magicka, Resistance dosen't.

Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 6:32 pm
by Apocalypse
Resist Magic resists the percentage of the spell cast at you (e.g. if you have 50% Resist Magic and a 20-point Frost Damage spell is cast at you, you will only be harmed for 10 points).
On the other hand, Spell Absorption and Reflect Spell use a different method - they have a chance to fully Absorb/Reflect a spell cast at you(e.g. if you have 50% Spell Absorption, approximately every second spell cast at you will refill your Magicka, rather than rejuvenating it for 50% of the spell's original cost).

I hope I cleared things up for you.

Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 6:42 pm
by stk01001
Apocalypse wrote:Resist Magic resists the percentage of the spell cast at you (e.g. if you have 50% Resist Magic and a 20-point Frost Damage spell is cast at you, you will only be harmed for 10 points).
On the other hand, Spell Absorption and Reflect Spell use a different method - they have a chance to fully Absorb/Reflect (e.g. if you have 50% Spell Absorption, approximately every second spell cast at you will refill your Magicka, rather than rejuvenating it for 50% of the spell's original cost).

I hope I cleared things up for you.
I understand how the spells work.. my question was will spell/absorption reflection work in conjunction with resistance to magic. Since I have 100% resistance to magic, spells do zero damage to me so what is being reflected/absorbed? Or are the spell reflection/absorption effects applied BEFORE the 100% resistance to magic kicks in?

sorry if my question is a little confusing. I guess to simplify it.. is there any point in having 100% spell reflection/absorption if you have 100% resistance to magic?

Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 6:43 pm
by stk01001
The Edgy Redguard wrote:Spell Absoption adds to your Magicka, Resistance dosen't.
yes I know that.. thats was not what I was asking.. see above

Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 7:00 pm
by Dogmantra
Having resistance, reflect and absorb is not neccessarily a bad thing.
Reflect is processed before absorb, which is processed before resist, so, say you have 10% reflect, 20% absorb and 100% resist magic effects active. Someone casts a 10 point fire damage spell at you.
To begin with, you have a 10% chance to reflect it, if you don't, then you have a 20% chance to absorb it. If it gets past both of these, then resistance comes into play, and you won't take any damage from it.

Of course, there's no point having 100% absorbtion or resist if you have a 100% reflect, and no point having any resistance if you already have 100% absorb, but if you have a slot or two left over, it can be a pretty good tactic.

Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 8:14 pm
by stk01001
Dogmantra wrote:Having resistance, reflect and absorb is not neccessarily a bad thing.
Reflect is processed before absorb, which is processed before resist, so, say you have 10% reflect, 20% absorb and 100% resist magic effects active. Someone casts a 10 point fire damage spell at you.
To begin with, you have a 10% chance to reflect it, if you don't, then you have a 20% chance to absorb it. If it gets past both of these, then resistance comes into play, and you won't take any damage from it.

Of course, there's no point having 100% absorbtion or resist if you have a 100% reflect, and no point having any resistance if you already have 100% absorb, but if you have a slot or two left over, it can be a pretty good tactic.
thank you... this answers what I was asking..

Posted: Sat Jan 10, 2009 6:50 pm
by Redguard_Master
It really depends on what you're after also. resist is only defensive, reflect can be a counter offense, and absorb can regenerate your magic if you're a spell slinger.

Posted: Sat Jan 10, 2009 6:57 pm
by kjdanext
You CAN reflect/absorb with 100% resistance to magic, I know because my character has it.

Nuff Said 8)

Posted: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:45 am
by Redguard_Master
you sure that's not coming from another source? Resist reduces damage or duration, it shouldn't be doing either of those.

Posted: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:04 am
by Dogmantra
Redguard_Master wrote:you sure that's not coming from another source? Resist reduces damage or duration, it shouldn't be doing either of those.
No, he means that you can reflect or absorb if you also have resistance, since his character has 100% resist and some other reflect/absorb effect.

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 2:17 am
by BFG
The only thing I'll add is that, defensively speaking, Spell Resist is probably superior to Spell Reflect and Spell Absorb.

This is because magic Reflected back at you will ALWAYS bypass both Reflect and Absorb. (It's the only thing my 100% Spell Absorption character has to be careful about...)

Spell Reflect/Absorb can also cause problems, as they can also absorb POSITIVE effects such as Altar magic. Spell Resist won't do that.