Page 1 of 5

Sigh...you warriors are wasting your time...

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 11:50 am
by Symmachus
I will never understand how anyone can be satisfied:

Having to walk around in heavy and unsightly armour all day...

Having to pay to repair your swords and shields...

Having to buy new arrows or pray you find them...

Having to depend on luck to find the potions you want, or having to buy them...

Having a useless guild full of orcs and redguards...

Being all brawn and no brain...

Being the 'rabble', the ubiquitous 'soldier' while more intelligent people command and plan...

Being so rough and uncultured...

Having to sleep in common rooms in your guild halls...

Being nearly run out of business by steroid-sodden lizards and cats...

and being subject to the commands of a redguard, orc, dunmer and old woman.

Do explain...

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 11:58 am
by Arzock
We repair our own weapons. Anyway, it's fun.

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 12:11 pm
by Coulsonji
Would you still be saying that after we smashed your face with a sledgehammer?

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 12:38 pm
by Dogmantra
[pedant]Well, we certainly have a better command of the English language. It should be "are wasting your time."[/pedant]

I don't know, I kind of like warrior types. They have a certain charm to them, that can only be gained by whacking someone repeatedly with a hammer.

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 1:22 pm
by Dark Spark
At least warriors are real. Only mages you see 'round here wear sequins and get off by levitating white tigers around a stage.

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 1:26 pm
by Symmachus
Aaaah exactly the response I had hoped for...

I'm being really sarcastic lol but these are the main reasons I don't like being a close-up melee fighter. It puts you in danger, to be in range of your enemy's weapons... I prefer killing people before they reach me.

Also its scary having to rely on the potions you find to keep you going in a dungeon. Much better to make ur own.

And I don't like paying someone to repair my stuff everytime I come out of a dungeon.

The result was even a character I intended to play as a paladin eventually became a pure mage after level 25. Eventually all his magic skills exceeded his combat ones.

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 2:33 pm
by gregor
It's been known to hapen.

Anyway with new type of casting in Oblivion mages really are quite dominating. After having a Crusader, who also used a lot of magic later on i started up a pure mage and damn they are strong.

And if they face a tough melee fighter were they can just conjure up the whole daedric armour and still be very fast on their feet.

I also chosen not to use any shield and only short swords.

in Morrowind fighters were thougher, because spells failed too often...

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 3:03 pm
by The Edgy Redguard
When started on these forums, i loved The Warrior, ever since, i've slowly changed my interest over to Pure Mages. While i still enjoy warriors, Mages are pretty sweet.

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 3:25 pm
by Kinzer
I repair my own armor. I heal myself and make my own potions. And I'm not really involved in any of the Guilds. I'm what you call a self-sufficient warrior. Then again I'm more of a Battlemage than a real warrior. Point is, us fighters have our advantages.

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 4:37 pm
by J'Ghasta
The feeling when you have smashed a skeleton and killd the other one before the first has reached the ground is .......AMAZING :wink:

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 4:40 pm
by kjdanext
Crusaders,knights,battlemages and spellswords are all warrior-mages.

Crusader and knight are more combat based , spellsword and battlemage are more magic.

Crusaders and knights are very similar.They have have most of their skill based on heavy armored melee combat

Spellswords are mages who are backed up by blades, the ability to block attacks and have skill with heavy armor

The most magic based out of the 4 is battlemage.These are basically mages who protect and offend using combiation of blades and blunts over restoration and illusion, because rather than healing after combat they use the melee to keep their enemies at bay.

My personal favourite is Crusader for a character who is based primarily on melee and backs up my fighting capabilities with destruction and I use this for ranged attacks also.After a fight I use restoration to heal my character.

I like mage classes too, and I find that mages are more poweful at comanding and using magic to overcome their enemies, but, they are weak and easily breakable at heart.

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 6:45 pm
by Boulderheart
Dogmantra wrote: Well, we certainly have a better command of the English language. It should be "are wasting your time."
i lol'd

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 7:05 pm
by belemnoid
Hmmm....I own every house, repair my own armor and enchanted weapons, lead every guild (including the mages guild) and can kill anything in 3 or less swings of my uber-sword. My armor not only looks good, but it's totally maxed out and I could go thru 3 dungeons and not have to repair it. Oh yeah, I made some sweet poisons too. Not that I need to make potions - I get plenty from killing mages and taking them off their lifeless bodies.
In fact, I've started wearing less armor and beating mages with my fists just to give them a chance. :Twisted Evil:

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 7:56 pm
by Kestral
I play as an Argonian archer and I'm in in no guild. :/

At lvl 25.

Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 8:15 pm
by kjdanext
Kestral wrote:I play as an Argonian archer and I'm in in no guild. :/

At lvl 25.
are you lvl 25 now?

Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 12:29 am
by branlord
daggers against heavy armor is funny :p.

Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 1:13 am
by Kestral
kjdanext wrote:
Kestral wrote:I play as an Argonian archer and I'm in in no guild. :/

At lvl 25.
are you lvl 25 now?
Now I'm level 30.

@ branlord

And daggers work like any other weapon.

It's better than an iron longsword, which is used against heavy armor.

So that kinda made no sense...

Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 2:03 am
by Dark Spark
branlord wrote:daggers against heavy armor is funny :p.
Actually, a dagger was a very effective weapon against heavy armor. The short, strong stabbing blade could be worked into joints or gaps in the harness better than a longer sword blade could. The trouble is that you had to grapple your enemy in the process.

Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 2:57 am
by Kestral
Dark Spark wrote:
branlord wrote:daggers against heavy armor is funny :p.
Actually, a dagger was a very effective weapon against heavy armor. The short, strong stabbing blade could be worked into joints or gaps in the harness better than a longer sword blade could. The trouble is that you had to grapple your enemy in the process.
In the real world, armor was actually useless.
It only defended against slashes from a longsword, but not against blunt weapons, or lances, or arrows, which most of the people were using.

The Romans used a long sword as a secondary weapon.
The Greeks primarily used their spears.
The British used a lot of their archer power.

So, armor is useless against almost everything.

Just a fun fact.

Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 5:51 am
by Nikulas the Nord
if you think we're wasting our time, you've never played as a NORD. :P :P :P :D :D :)

Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 5:52 am
by Dark Spark
Kestral wrote:
Dark Spark wrote:
branlord wrote:daggers against heavy armor is funny :p.
Actually, a dagger was a very effective weapon against heavy armor. The short, strong stabbing blade could be worked into joints or gaps in the harness better than a longer sword blade could. The trouble is that you had to grapple your enemy in the process.
In the real world, armor was actually useless.
It only defended against slashes from a longsword, but not against blunt weapons, or lances, or arrows, which most of the people were using.

The Romans used a long sword as a secondary weapon.
The Greeks primarily used their spears.
The British used a lot of their archer power.

So, armor is useless against almost everything.

Just a fun fact.
I disagree. In the real world, armor was very useful in keeping one's most favorite body parts attached. But, like the weapons employed against it, there was a constant struggle between creating armor sufficient to protect against weapons of the day; and envisioning weapons that would defeat the armor of the day.

Your citations ignore the vast temporal gulfs between their comparisons and exactly what challenges they had to defeat. Ancient Greeks used the spear as a primary weapon, but they still had a sword to back them up. Same deal with the Romans. Whatever the materials or design of those weapons, however, they were designed to defeat their opponent's defenses. The neccessity of their innovations point to the effectivness of those defenses, be it shield, maille, jack, or harness.

Remember: your armor only had to protect well enough for you to get your weapon past the protection of his armor. That is, by no means, a simple trade-off. It's the messy dance known as combat.

Pole-arms needed room, lances needed horses, and archers needed a shield wall. Nothing's perfect: not armor, not weapons. Maille could stop the shortsword being used when you close inside of a ole-arm's range, a shield wall could stop a lancer's charge if discipline held the wall together, and plate armor did protect knights from arrows (it just didn't prtect knights' horses from them as effectively).

Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 6:13 am
by Kestral
I never mentioned the Romans having to fight the Greeks, and the British longbows fighting them. What I was talking about was that armor did not serve as much of a purpose. Simply put, I was not making a comparison.

When the French Knights fought the British longbows, the longbows decimated the French Knights. The French armor was the best of the day, and the arrows pierced through the metal and killing the knight.

The Roman Legionnaire's armor suffered challenges against the Germanic tribes. The Greek armor only served protection from slashing. Their shield served a better purpose (protection from arrows). The Greek armor could not protect against thrusting.

Pole-arms (spears) did serve to keep the enemy at bay, but also protect from cavalry charges.

I'm pretty sure the halberd was for chopping.

The flail, mace, and hammer were meant to deliver powerful blows. Ones that no armor could withstand.

@ Nikulas
A lot of us has played as a Nord and preferred a mage more.

Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 6:19 am
by The Most Unholy
Kestral wrote:
Dark Spark wrote:
branlord wrote:daggers against heavy armor is funny :p.
Actually, a dagger was a very effective weapon against heavy armor. The short, strong stabbing blade could be worked into joints or gaps in the harness better than a longer sword blade could. The trouble is that you had to grapple your enemy in the process.
In the real world, armor was actually useless.
It only defended against slashes from a longsword, but not against blunt weapons, or lances, or arrows, which most of the people were using.

The Romans used a long sword as a secondary weapon.
The Greeks primarily used their spears.
The British used a lot of their archer power.

So, armor is useless against almost everything.

Just a fun fact.

I'll add to Dark Spark, Plate Armor stops blunt weapons dead in their tracks, try hitting a fully armored knight with a mace, you won't do much but get that armor vibrating slightly (Note the fact that no man ever wore his plate armor up against his body, there was padding and possibly a mail vest in between). Next, one word, shield. The shield, when used effectively and assuming it is large enough, stops any and all weapons dead in their tracks, so long as they are well-made (Not including any weapons made after the dawn of gunpowder on the battlefield). The Greeks used the spear primarily for two reasons 1. Reach 2. The ability for three or four lines of men all to be able to kill, with two or three lines protected from the enemy, armor penetration was a minor factor. The Romans didn't use long swords, period. They used either a Gladius or a Spatha, neither of which are long swords, both of which could penetrate the armor of any enemies the Romans would have to face. Long swords didn't come around until after the Viking Age.

Yes, the British did use a lot of archer power, here are the problems, a warrior can last longer on a battlefield than an archer, British archers are prone to their arms being dislocated from their bows, pulling a longbow is like pulling the weight of an adult male. Catch your arm bad, well, your military career is effectively over. Next, the medieval arrow was a sad excuse for an armor penetrating arrow, it would bounce off any fairly significant and well-made armor, not to mention if they had a chainmail vest underneath, once again it comes back to this, as Dark spark pointed out, they were aiming for the horse.


Kestral, do you know who won, the French or the British? Flails, maces, 1. Were in very rare use 2. Did nothing of the sort, armor shook it off very easily, it's chain mail that has a problem. Now, I have a lot on this, Greek armor was near impenetrable during the time of the Trojan wars, heavy yes, worth it, definitely. Medieval 'armor-piercing' arrows bounce off of it, and we can't even smith metal as well as the Greeks could. The reasons the Germanic tribes (Hun empire) owned the Romans, was not because of superiority, but sheer force, the Hun empire was absolutely massive, they overwhelmed the Romans until they assembled an army large enough to defeat them. They needed help to do that.

Note: Not being mean, I just hate when history is skewed.

Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 6:20 am
by leroybrown
Surely, you guys have played a lot of age of empires.

Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 6:26 am
by The Most Unholy
I've never tried Age of Empires actually.


AND, There is not a thing more satisfying than grabbing an ebony longsword, walk into a goblin dungeon, and stabbing one in the face. 'tis priceless.