Page 1 of 5
Any History Buffs Here?
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 2:14 am
by Kinzer
Today in my American History class, I got to thinking about what certain times or events in history that interests people the most. I personally enjoy anything history related, but for some reason I'm the most interested in anything having to do with War. I guess because I'm a guy or something. The Civil War to me is the most interesting. There are entire books just about major battles. And it's interesting to think about how events could have changed the outcome. What if Britain and France had come to the aid of the South? Would I be living in the Confederacy right now?
Anyways, I'd like to here what specific events are eras in History interest you the most and if you want why you think it interests you so much. I'd like to get a good discussion going here and get peoples opinions on the things that shaped today's society. And of course don't limit your responses to events in American History.

Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 2:17 am
by Kestral
Meh. :/
The US history is alright I guess, not that I care all that much.
Sure I'm in the US, but what's the point of knowing every single nagging detail.
The US was built upon freedom, justice, blah, blah, blah. We had several wars but most people only know the big ones, The Revolutionary, Civil, and the World Wars.
And I myself wouldn't consider the war in Iraq an actual "war."
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 2:23 am
by The Most Unholy
My favorite periods in history are probably the Hellenic Period, the Middle Ages, (Deus Vult, anyone?) the period from 1914-1945 in Europe, and finally the time When England was a mixed and matched tapestry of independent states, like Saxony and Wales.
I also have many different views on both history and current military tactics than almost every person alive who cares. For example, I loathe the centering of a navy upon the aircraft carrier in the Modern Age. Also, Operation Barbarossa, was the smartest military move ever made by any civilization in history, that was not executed well enough. I am willing to discuss more opinions if asked, of course.
And Kestral, I agree on Iraq.
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 2:29 am
by Kestral
Woops, I missed the part about it not being a part of American history.
Well, I do like... well right now I'm reading a book on the Spanish Civil War, interesting I'd say.
But I like how the Age of Empire's showed me history. Put their periods on there.
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 2:44 am
by Dark Spark
The First World War, the death of civilization as they knew it (but not like as how we know it, of course, because we live in what was reshaped out of that insanity).
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 3:36 am
by Kinzer
The Most Unholy wrote:My favorite periods in history are probably the Hellenic Period, the Middle Ages, (Deus Vult, anyone?) the period from 1914-1945 in Europe, and finally the time When England was a mixed and matched tapestry of independent states, like Saxony and Wales.
I also have many different views on both history and current military tactics than almost every person alive who cares. For example, I loathe the centering of a navy upon the aircraft carrier in the Modern Age. Also, Operation Barbarossa, was the smartest military move ever made by any civilization in history, that was not executed well enough. I am willing to discuss more opinions if asked, of course.
And Kestral, I agree on Iraq.
Well it of course depends on your own definition of war. Dictionary.com defines it as a conflict carried on by force of arms, as between nations or between parties within a nation.
It started as a conflict between nations, the Allied forces and Iraq, but over time the enemy became any group deemed a "terrorist group." Now we do not have a clear enemy, like we would have if we were fighting an actual nation's military, but we do have an enemy none the less. So I personally do think it is a War, however I will say it's far from conventional.
Moving on to the history topic, Dark Spark I'm not sure how this compares to others, but World War I is the conflict I've learned the least about, at least of those that involve America. I mean it may just be me, but we as Americans know a lot more about World War II. D-Day, Pearl Harbor and the genocide of the Jews are all things many people are aware. I don't think the average person could mention one or two things about World War I. Why do you think this is?
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 3:42 am
by The Most Unholy
It was shrouded over by WWII, but IMO, the most influential event in world history was the assassination of Franz and Sophie Ferdinand. Also, a lot of people recognize von Richthofen, whether they know anything about who that name is related to or not. (Hint: Manfred von Richthofen was the Red Baron.)
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 3:47 am
by Kinzer
The Most Unholy wrote:It was shrouded over by WWII, but IMO, the most influential event in world history was the assassination of Franz and Sophie Ferdinand. Also, a lot of people recognize von Richthofen, whether they know anything about who that name is related to or not. (Hint: Manfred von Richthofen was the Red Baron.)
Yes, the Red Baron. Did they ever settle who actually killed him?
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 3:51 am
by The Most Unholy
Not as far as I know, I think it's still up to debate.
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 3:52 am
by Dark Spark
Kinzer wrote: ... Dark Spark I'm not sure how this compares to others, but World War I is the conflict I've learned the least about, at least of those that involve America. I mean it may just be me, but we as Americans know a lot more about World War II. D-Day, Pearl Harbor and the genocide of the Jews are all things many people are aware. I don't think the average person could mention one or two things about World War I. Why do you think this is?
I could point out that the fighting began in August 1914 and ended in November 1918, and that the U.S. really got into the fight in June 1917 (34 months after the start and 17 months to the end).
But, honestly?
Movies. Not much of a market for WWI-themed movies in the American viewing public after the war, but by the time WWII rolled around, an entire generation had grown up watching these cinematic spectacles on the silver screen— and WWII was much easier for Hollywood to film.
Do not get me started on
Flyboys. Telling us that 'Skinner' (the black pilot) ended up becoming a U.S. airmail pilot after the war is like telling us that the bones of Erwin Rommel were tucked inside the Volkswagen Beetle used in the Love Bug films. Never happened, and a patent example of how we'd tread roughshod over that segment of history— all because it is so far removed from our consciousness that such a falsehood carries that much veracity.
Eugene Bullard, the Black Swallow of Death, never had a postwar future as rosy as what that film showed. A great tragedy that such a celebrated hero of France would die in his home country as a destitute unknown.
Kinzer wrote:The Most Unholy wrote:... Also, a lot of people recognize von Richthofen, whether they know anything about who that name is related to or not. (Hint: Manfred von Richthofen was the Red Baron.)
Yes, the Red Baron. Did they ever settle who actually killed him?
Snoopy.
Oddly enough, the Red Baron looked nothing like the fellow on the pizza box.
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 4:39 am
by leroybrown
If you like civil war you should take a look at mathew bradys photos
http://www.archives.gov/education/lessons/brady-photos/
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 4:48 am
by ThePatster
I loooooove ancient history, anything about ancient greece, rome, egypt, norse you name

Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 5:05 am
by Crusader
being Australian, Australian history is just boring.
European history is the best (modern and ancient) i was pretty anoyed in my ancient civs class at school when we only did Egypt...
American history seems to contradict itself to me...
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 5:45 am
by Dark Spark
Crusader wrote:...American history seems to contradict itself to me...
What, the history itself being an odd assortment of attitudes and events, or is this the Canterbury Ghost's
"...why, you have your manners and your Navy!"
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 7:57 am
by Oathbreaker
American history starts out interesting but loses my interest after the Civil War. (I do wish we could've seen how it'd have turned out if the Natives didn't nearly get wiped out of existence by disease, though... speculation ftw)
In terms of history my favorites are ancient Greece and Japan. I'm not sure exactly why I like Japanese history so much... but Greece. Wow. They even had an extremely interesting religious pantheon which, in my opinion, beats out everything else in terms of intrigue (Rome's pantheon was just a lame copy... blech... although the ancient Chinese deities were pretty interesting too).
And for shame... why has nobody mentioned TES history? That's some VERY interesting and well-designed stuff, right there.
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 10:15 am
by ThePatster
It would be a waste of time learning about the history of the TES, unless you are completely utterly obsessed with Elder Scrolls and wanted to know absolutely EVERYTHING!
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 10:46 am
by Caz
well, i'm studying archaeology and history so i guess this is my topic
what i'm mostly interested in: prehistoric stuff. celts and all those other barbarians

and romans and greeks of course...
middle ages? not so much. same goes for more modern times. there are some very interesting subjects, i'm currently in a seminar about witches. but mostly, esp. when it comes to WW 1/2, then i guess i've just been forced through it too often in school. not really my thing. but who knows, maybe i'll have a good professor next year who will make it more interesting...
but learning it all from the german point of view is different, i guess, so i'm grateful for that.
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 11:59 am
by Oathbreaker
ThePatster wrote:It would be a waste of time learning about the history of the TES, unless you are completely utterly obsessed with Elder Scrolls and wanted to know absolutely EVERYTHING!
You obviously do not value the vast amounts of insight into the game that you can gain by reading its books. Besides, when you've got a TES game popped in and you don't have anything better to do anyway, then why not? It's only a waste of time if you call it so, and it's not.
Blech @ the Medieval era. So... lacking.

And ever since my sister started learning about the whole witch thing about 3 years ago, she still hasn't gotten over it. It's pretty much her favorite subject that I can think of, historically.
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 1:00 pm
by ThePatster
Why read history about a virtual world?
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 7:03 pm
by leroybrown
Crusader wrote:
American history seems to contradict itself to me...
I was proud of everyone on this forum for not pointing out the irony of thanksgiving. You guys rock.
"ruuuun to the hiiiiills"
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 10:19 pm
by WolfGang IceEye
I love history!! My favorite time period of history is the over throwing of the czar's in Russia it was a bloody time period but so very interesting.
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 11:38 pm
by Kestral
leroybrown wrote:Crusader wrote:
American history seems to contradict itself to me...
I was proud of everyone on this forum for not pointing out the irony of thanksgiving. You guys rock.
"ruuuun to the hiiiiills"
"Run for your lief!" - Iron Maiden
Interesting though, but I believe under US law the Native Americans did break laws.
Unfair yes, against the Constitution? No.
Once America gained the lands instead of saying "GTFO," they said, "THESE LANDS R OURS. WE HAZ PERMITS. G-T-F-O."
@ Wolfgang
And along came Communism!
Posted: Thu Dec 11, 2008 2:25 am
by Necrolysis
Kestral wrote:And along came Communism!
Them dang dirty rotten commies.
I'm actually a pretty big history buff mehself. I love Viking and Nordic history in general. Their religon is one of the more interesting ones.
Posted: Thu Dec 11, 2008 2:30 am
by The Most Unholy
I second that, although I'm biased, I agree about the religion. I find it offensive when people use the term 'pagan' for it. I prefer either using Asatru or less so mythology.
Posted: Thu Dec 11, 2008 2:32 am
by Kinzer
Kestral wrote:leroybrown wrote:Crusader wrote:
American history seems to contradict itself to me...
I was proud of everyone on this forum for not pointing out the irony of thanksgiving. You guys rock.
"ruuuun to the hiiiiills"
"Run for your lief!" - Iron Maiden
Interesting though, but I believe under US law the Native Americans did break laws.
Unfair yes, against the Constitution? No.
Once America gained the lands instead of saying "GTFO," they said, "THESE LANDS R OURS. WE HAZ PERMITS. G-T-F-O."
@ Wolfgang
And along came Communism!
To be completely honest, I really didn't feel much sympathy for the Indians while we learned about them. I mean sure, we took the land, but it was never officially theirs. We had superior technology and numbers and we won. And they always seemed to side with the wrong country in Wars.