Page 1 of 1
Solthilde - SPOILERS
Posted: Wed Nov 26, 2008 6:05 pm
by Ladyblack
I have read the walkthrough about Solthilde (hope that's the right spelling), and I guess I must be doing something wrong.
I am a Warrior (a Breton...Yes, I know I might have been better off as a Magic User

).
I am a member of the Fighters' guild and the Mage's guild.
My Speechcraft is not high enough to Taunt her (not unreasonable, I'm only level 2, or should I be high enough by now?).
I have no Sneak skill and have not been interested in gaining this (want to be a tank, possibly with magic).
I can't kill her
She will not give me the darn book.
Am I missing something here? PLEASE can someone help?
Thanks
Posted: Wed Nov 26, 2008 6:28 pm
by urthdigger
Well, if you don't have enough speechcraft, and your combat skills aren't good enough to kill her... well, I guess you're going to have to pick one of those to raise now aren't you
There's also a way to skip that quest, which is key if you want to be a member of both the thieves guild and the fighters guild... but if you're not interested in the thieves guild you can disregard this (It involves doing some of the higher thieves guild quests)
Posted: Wed Nov 26, 2008 6:30 pm
by Rohugh
OK, there can also be some conflicts with the Thieves guild if you intend to join them - you will not be able to if you get the book off her at this stage.
Simple exploit: Join Fighters Guild first, don't join Thieves Guild yet, do Eydis Fire-Eye's quests until you get the Codebook quest. This way, you can persuade Sottilde to hand over the codebook. Before you leave the South Wall, talk to Sugar-Lips Habasi and join the Thieves Guild. Only then, go back to Eydis and deliver the codebook.
Strategic: Join both guilds anytime, but when you get the Codebook quest, don't do it. Do quests for other Fighters Guild stewards (Percius Mercius and Hrundi are honorable; the Vivec guild is corrupt) and do all the Thieves Guild quests. A late Thieves Guild quest will turn Eydis and make her forget about the codebook.
Brute force: If you're already in Thieves Guild or don't favor either of the above, you'll have to pick Sottilde's pocket (hard) or kill her (messy). If you get expelled from Thieves Guild, you can weasel your way back in just this once.
If you do not intend to join Thieves you can use a Frenzy spell on her to get her to attack you. You can also drink a number of Telvanni Bug Musk to improve your disposition with her, and then talk to her
Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 8:53 am
by Ladyblack
Aha! OK, I have nothing against the Thieves Guild, it's just that one of my other characters joined basically everything, I have about 24 unfinished quests to do and I keep getting lost. I don't suppose I can erase old quests which I have completed from my Journal? I decided that I was going to be more linear with this one, and complete one 'section' before doing anything else. But I specifically wanted the Mages' quests because they led me to places where I could gain lots of experience and pick up some nice pieces of loot.
"Simple exploit: Join Fighters Guild first, don't join Thieves Guild yet, do Eydis Fire-Eye's quests until you get the Codebook quest."
Well, that's bascially where I am. She still won't give me the book. I am quite 'happy' to kill her, but I don't want to kill the other chappie who's going to see me, or spend time in jail. I will try and get my Speechcraft up or get the Bug Musk.
Many thanks, looking forward to the weekend to do some.....erhum...'exploring' of the Dwarf mines. Got some scrolls of Intervention. (Wanders off, whistling nonchantly).
Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 10:32 pm
by urthdigger
Check the quests that you've "completed" on the wiki. Chances are you missed the final person you have to talk to to actually "complete" the quest. In particular, take note of the journal entries at the bottom of the page. Once you get one of the journal entries that has a checkmark next to it, the quest is taken off your quest list.
Posted: Fri Nov 28, 2008 8:58 am
by Ladyblack
Ah. Now that's strange and worrying. For example, I still have the 'Quest' for the Healing ring listed.....but then again, I understand that that one comes back to haunt you. And I know I mucked up the quest for the mushrooms somehow, because I got them, but didn't get the next quest. Might be one of my stats isn't up enough yet. I'll have to go back and check my journal, but I'm pretty sure I still have the Fake Sould Gem Quest and the Flowers quest, both completed successfully enough to ensure that I got the next quest.
Perhaps I should have cleared Old Whatshername's desk before planting the Soul Gem

!
Posted: Fri Nov 28, 2008 10:20 am
by Rohugh
Ladyblack wrote:
Perhaps I should have cleared Old Whatshername's desk before planting the Soul Gem

!
As a note, the fake soul gem goes
in the desk, not on it and you do not have to take anything from it.
Posted: Fri Nov 28, 2008 7:12 pm
by The King
Though the limeware platters and soulgems are worth tons.
Posted: Sat Dec 13, 2008 11:56 am
by Sanctuary
might hafta dissagree with you there Rohugh
Whilst She's downstairs gabbing .... put the Fake Gem in the desk and take everything else- the Creeper loves soulgems

just do not sell ANY soulgems to ANY Mage Guild NPC ever after that, lest you be expelled.
And a hint on ol' fire-eye and the book ...slip on over to the fighters guild in Vivec, Ald Rune, Ginsis, and Sadrith Mora and complete those Guildmaster quests..Along with the Mages Guild quests .. by then your lvl will have Increased as well as your Speachcraft...at that point you can tackle lil old Solthide and get the book.
another tip: its wise to persuede with coin then taunt then repeat until the fight commences.. yes it can get spendy but it works
GL
Posted: Sat Dec 13, 2008 1:09 pm
by Rohugh
I said you do not have to take anything - in other words it is not required by the quest.
The gems that are there are assigned to Galbedir, not to the guild, therefore it is safe to sell them to anyone else except Galbedir.