What is the allure of the forsworn?
-
Witchery
- Master

- Posts: 1081
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2012 1:39 am
- ES Games: IV: GOTY, V: DG, HF, DB
- Platform: PC (IV, V) & PS3 (V)
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
No one has factored in the Western Reach. Yes, there are more Forsworn in High Rock, being oppressed by fellow Bretons in guard gear. The Forsworn could reclaim the Reach, but they are disorganized and scattered, and not to mention both the Empire and the Stormcloaks are keeping their numbers down. You do realize the game Skyrim is scaled down (A LOT) and cities like Markarth are much bigger than they are in the game. If the Forsworn have trouble successfully infiltrating Markarth, even secretly, they're not going to take back the Reach without outside help. (And, once again, the Empire and Stormcloaks are largely anti-Forsworn. I'm not sure about the Aldmeri Dominion.)
Combining both parts of the Reach, in High Rock and Skyrim, I think it would be awesome if the Forsworn could retake their land and perhaps even become an Empire-recognized Province. . .
Combining both parts of the Reach, in High Rock and Skyrim, I think it would be awesome if the Forsworn could retake their land and perhaps even become an Empire-recognized Province. . .
- Rynkar
- Warder

- Posts: 481
- Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 1:39 am
- ES Games: oblivion GOTY, Skyrim
- Platform: Xbox-360
- Status: Ready for some skyrim dlc...
- Location: Nightingale Hall.
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
How would it be awesome? They have nothing to offer to the world, besides goat and deer fur.
Spoiler:
- Kerr
- CotM Winner!

- Posts: 970
- Joined: Thu Aug 12, 2010 8:32 pm
- ES Games: I, II, III, IV, V. Once I caught a fish alive.
- Platform: PC & Playstation
- Status: Shadowrunning
- UESPoints: 20
- Location: Ireland
- Contact:
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
I think the Forsworn should get their own empire recognized province much like the Orcs did.
So we have come to solve every squabble in the village personally?
The last thing you never see
The last thing you never see
- Rynkar
- Warder

- Posts: 481
- Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 1:39 am
- ES Games: oblivion GOTY, Skyrim
- Platform: Xbox-360
- Status: Ready for some skyrim dlc...
- Location: Nightingale Hall.
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
Orcs are good worriers and blacksmiths, they have something to bring to the table, forsworn have barbaric worriers that probably can't be bought, so again they're is nothing good about the forsworn.
Spoiler:
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
If I could have influence over the Empire (in game), I would have made an offer to recognize the Forsworn, and even grant them their own land/province, much like what happened with the Orc's and Orsinium. Why fight, when you can have allies. Especially with the threat of the Thalmor and Stormcloaks.
The tricky part, would be to make this happen, without also making the Nords of the Reach, and Markarth upset, and turn towards the Stormcloaks.
The tricky part, would be to make this happen, without also making the Nords of the Reach, and Markarth upset, and turn towards the Stormcloaks.
-
Witchery
- Master

- Posts: 1081
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2012 1:39 am
- ES Games: IV: GOTY, V: DG, HF, DB
- Platform: PC (IV, V) & PS3 (V)
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
Aaaaaaaaaaaand there's where you're wrong. The Forsworn offer much to the mage/scholar community. Their particular hedge magic is stemmed from a different source than "normal, safe magic" from what I can observe. Hagravens and Forsworn Shamans alike have secret magics and rituals, like to art of bringing a fallen Forsworn back to life . . . as something other than a groaning zombie. An actual living creature (the Briarhearts). If the Hagravens can do that, what else can they do? We've seen their ritual tables (which may seem sinister, but probably have a certain spiritual and magical importance to the Reachmen) and their ability to wield powerful Frost and Flame magics, and I've seen Hagravens heal wounds, create magical wards, and use Alteration spells. . . and the fact that they quote "have lived here from the beginning" may state that the Hagravens, once changed from female Forsworn Shamans/normal witches, become incredibly long-lived? Perhaps even immortal (not unable to die, mind you)? And if so . . think of the knowledge they can provide.Rynkar wrote:How would it be awesome? They have nothing to offer to the world, besides goat and deer fur.
And what about a better use for the silver that is so rich in the Reach? Instead of lining the Silver-Bloods pockets and keeping them in power, what if they used it as a main export? Sure, they are advocates for the "Old Ways", but that doesn't mean they're incapable of civil interaction. I'd be mad too if I was suffering at the hands of the Nords.
Why is the Dwemer's return (which I hope will never happen, and it probably will not -- the Dwarves are gone. They insulted the gods and are hopefully paying.) so exciting, or the Falmer's invasion (that would be admittedly cool, but not as a take-over-Skyrim thing), but an entire people's homeland is nothing? Why are the Nords more entitled to their land, but the Forsworn are not?
- Lotet
- Apprentice

- Posts: 162
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 7:43 am
- ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
- Platform: PC, XBox 360
- Location: In my room, probably dead.
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
well, technically it would have been the Dwemers first and they just moved into the Ruins. really, the Falmer probably have a stronger rightful claim. of course the Dwemer and Falmer don't count because of extinction for one side and the other side seems to only interact with humans as targets or slaves.Pilaf The Defiler wrote:While I don't sympathize with all the tactics the Forsworn use to try to get their eastern lands back, it was technically theirs first.
frankly though, they have more land than they lost. Markarth can't be worth that much to them and if that's the case then I don't see how thier bloody revenge is ever going to end without one side being wiped out.
but according to the Forsworn in Sidna Mine, every member has a personal reason to want revenge and knowing how close knit 30 people can be it's easy to understand how if they lost half of thier population due to a war with the Nords that they really would all have a reason, a reason that you couldn't say to thier face is not worth it because the alternative is just giving up.
2 years is not enough time for that to blow over.
TerrorOfTheNorth wrote:He's Bosmer. That's what I think of him.
- Rynkar
- Warder

- Posts: 481
- Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 1:39 am
- ES Games: oblivion GOTY, Skyrim
- Platform: Xbox-360
- Status: Ready for some skyrim dlc...
- Location: Nightingale Hall.
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
They don't deserve land are anything because I don't hear any of them helping out anybody, just killing innocent people doing their jobs, like running a caravan. That magic ability seems to only be focused at killing, and making it possible to kill more efficiently, and besides silver in markarth, wich isn't the only source in the world, they have nothing to offer to the world.Witchery wrote:Aaaaaaaaaaaand there's where you're wrong. The Forsworn offer much to the mage/scholar community. Their particular hedge magic is stemmed from a different source than "normal, safe magic" from what I can observe. Hagravens and Forsworn Shamans alike have secret magics and rituals, like to art of bringing a fallen Forsworn back to life . . . as something other than a groaning zombie. An actual living creature (the Briarhearts). If the Hagravens can do that, what else can they do? We've seen their ritual tables (which may seem sinister, but probably have a certain spiritual and magical importance to the Reachmen) and their ability to wield powerful Frost and Flame magics, and I've seen Hagravens heal wounds, create magical wards, and use Alteration spells. . . and the fact that they quote "have lived here from the beginning" may state that the Hagravens, once changed from female Forsworn Shamans/normal witches, become incredibly long-lived? Perhaps even immortal (not unable to die, mind you)? And if so . . think of the knowledge they can provide.Rynkar wrote:How would it be awesome? They have nothing to offer to the world, besides goat and deer fur.
And what about a better use for the silver that is so rich in the Reach? Instead of lining the Silver-Bloods pockets and keeping them in power, what if they used it as a main export? Sure, they are advocates for the "Old Ways", but that doesn't mean they're incapable of civil interaction. I'd be mad too if I was suffering at the hands of the Nords.
Why is the Dwemer's return (which I hope will never happen, and it probably will not -- the Dwarves are gone. They insulted the gods and are hopefully paying.) so exciting, or the Falmer's invasion (that would be admittedly cool, but not as a take-over-Skyrim thing), but an entire people's homeland is nothing? Why are the Nords more entitled to their land, but the Forsworn are not?
Last edited by Rynkar on Sat Feb 25, 2012 4:47 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Spoiler:
- Pilaf The Defiler
- Imperial Legate

- Posts: 4359
- Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2011 9:03 pm
- ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim, ESO
- Platform: PC, Xbox, Xbox 360
- Status: Fresh
- UESPoints: 20
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
I have, multiple times in this thread and every other one where the Reach is discussed.Witchery wrote:No one has factored in the Western Reach..
Monsters are bred in labyrinths, labyrinths are bred from walls. There is a reason the Giants choose to remain nomadic rather than follow their shield kin the Nords in building permanent settlements. The Tower is the beginning of all walls.
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
...but having them as Allies when the Aldmeri Dominion does decide to attack again, would be a lot better choice, than having to waste manpower to protect the Reach, so that they do not do like they did in the Great War, and take over the Reach and Markarth.
Learn from your previous mistakes.
Learn from your previous mistakes.
-
Witchery
- Master

- Posts: 1081
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2012 1:39 am
- ES Games: IV: GOTY, V: DG, HF, DB
- Platform: PC (IV, V) & PS3 (V)
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
You want to talk about savages? Look at the Dark Brotherhood, and tell me the Forsworn are only focused on killing.Rynkar wrote:They don't deserve land are anything because I don't hear any of them helping out anybody, just killing innocent people doing their jobs, like running a caravan. That magic ability seems to only be focused at killing, and besides the silver ,they have nothing beyond killing ability.Witchery wrote:Aaaaaaaaaaaand there's where you're wrong. The Forsworn offer much to the mage/scholar community. Their particular hedge magic is stemmed from a different source than "normal, safe magic" from what I can observe. Hagravens and Forsworn Shamans alike have secret magics and rituals, like to art of bringing a fallen Forsworn back to life . . . as something other than a groaning zombie. An actual living creature (the Briarhearts). If the Hagravens can do that, what else can they do? We've seen their ritual tables (which may seem sinister, but probably have a certain spiritual and magical importance to the Reachmen) and their ability to wield powerful Frost and Flame magics, and I've seen Hagravens heal wounds, create magical wards, and use Alteration spells. . . and the fact that they quote "have lived here from the beginning" may state that the Hagravens, once changed from female Forsworn Shamans/normal witches, become incredibly long-lived? Perhaps even immortal (not unable to die, mind you)? And if so . . think of the knowledge they can provide.Rynkar wrote:How would it be awesome? They have nothing to offer to the world, besides goat and deer fur.
And what about a better use for the silver that is so rich in the Reach? Instead of lining the Silver-Bloods pockets and keeping them in power, what if they used it as a main export? Sure, they are advocates for the "Old Ways", but that doesn't mean they're incapable of civil interaction. I'd be mad too if I was suffering at the hands of the Nords.
Why is the Dwemer's return (which I hope will never happen, and it probably will not -- the Dwarves are gone. They insulted the gods and are hopefully paying.) so exciting, or the Falmer's invasion (that would be admittedly cool, but not as a take-over-Skyrim thing), but an entire people's homeland is nothing? Why are the Nords more entitled to their land, but the Forsworn are not?
No, unless you infiltrate their encampments or redoubts, they don't bother you. They go on about their business. If this wasn't a game, I think I could hazard a guess that there are Forsworn children, and mothers, and hunters and gatherers and a society of Reachmen. I have met, many times in the Reach, Forsworn hunting animals but not attacking me. They do warn me to keep my distance, but they leave me be . . and I have even seen a group of Forsworn (four of them -- a Shaman and three warriors) wandering the roads, not bothering with me other than to say "Good morning."
Pardon me, then. Sorry.Pilaf the Defiler wrote: I have, multiple times in this thread and every other one where the Reach is discussed.
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
This could be a good method for the Empire to recognize the Forsworn, giving them a bit of land from Skyrim and Highrock... so as not to have the Nords give up all of the land. Not sure about Hammerfel though, since it is not a part of the Empire.Pilaf The Defiler wrote:I have, multiple times in this thread and every other one where the Reach is discussed.Witchery wrote:No one has factored in the Western Reach..
- Evil-i
- Grand Master

- Posts: 2086
- Joined: Tue Jun 21, 2011 10:51 pm
- ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
- Platform: Xbox, 360
- Status: I have a pulse; it's a good day.
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
Speaking of Foresworn and their Hagraven buddies, I keep finding these little dark brown objects littering their camp locations. They look like they're supposed to be alchemical ingredients, and can be rolled around but not picked up/taken. They kinda resemble an eyeball with a little scraggly tuft sticking out of them. Does anyone have any insight into what these objects are supposed to be?
"Keep your arrows in their archer" *quiver*
- Rynkar
- Warder

- Posts: 481
- Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 1:39 am
- ES Games: oblivion GOTY, Skyrim
- Platform: Xbox-360
- Status: Ready for some skyrim dlc...
- Location: Nightingale Hall.
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
They are eyeballs...from animals...Evil-i wrote:Speaking of Foresworn and their Hagraven buddies, I keep finding these little dark brown objects littering their camp locations. They look like they're supposed to be alchemical ingredients, and can be rolled around but not picked up/taken. They kinda resemble an eyeball with a little scraggly tuft sticking out of them. Does anyone have any insight into what these objects are supposed to be?
Spoiler:
- Hissien
- Archmage

- Posts: 1902
- Joined: Sun Jan 22, 2012 5:10 pm
- ES Games: Morrowind Oblivion and Skyrim
- Platform: Xbox 360, PC
- Status: Something pretentious.
- Other Profiles: Xbox: AbroadHarpy22 Steam: Hissien
- UESPoints: 1
- Location: The astral plane
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
Specifically goats. I thought they were smooth stones when I saw them.
\[T]/ Praise the Sun Y'all
- Elani
- Initiate

- Posts: 26
- Joined: Sat Jan 07, 2012 10:13 am
- ES Games: Skyrim
- Platform: Xbox
- Location: UK
- Contact:
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
Exactly!Jeff wrote:It is one reason why I find it harder each time, to play the game. If I make the appropriate moral choices, it does not leave me much to do in the game. I have to forget and ignore the moral values I have spent 4 decades building up.
- JVElEven
- Master

- Posts: 1234
- Joined: Sun Apr 17, 2011 9:26 pm
- ES Games: Oblivion, Shivering Isles, Knights of the Nine, Skyrim (DUH!)
- Platform: PC
- Status: The last damn purist around here!
- Other Profiles: I'm always JVElEven. Look me up on Steam
- Location: Jylland
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
What I find strange is that Rynkar and Hessien keep making the same argument against the Forsworn, e.g. "They are mindless savages" without expanding on them while simultaneously ignoring any argument made by the other side of the pitch.
I find them alluring mostly because they are actually a whole new race, thinking and capable of being civil, unlike the falmer, who have long since degenerated, as we can all vouch for. They are a true eleventh race, and they are ancient. The way they are presented, they seem like perhaps runaway slaves from the Ayleid or whatever, who set up in the ruins and caves north of Cyrodiil. The way they talk, they appear to have been there for longer than the Nords. Even though the Nords came first from Atmora, most were wiped out, and I believe that the Reachmen, like the Bretons, are from a strand of elven slaves, who split off from the breton race long time ago. They are an eleventh race which we were almost completely unprepared for. No one saw it coming, even though there were vague references to the race in earlier games (these were never discussed much, though).
And it is not definitely proven what these "Old Gods" are. It's the Nords who call them "Old Gods". But the Nordic old gods are Kyne, Shor etc, which IIRC is Kynareth and Lorkhan, and thus Aedra, not Daedra (Lorkan is a Daedra, yes, but acknowledged even by the Temple of the Nine).
Of course, them being in cahoots with Hagravens is less than outright amiable, but they are effectively fighting a guerilla war, and they had to improvise on their weaponry, much like, say, the Taleban has (Sorry for invoking the Afghanistan War on this, btw). The Hagraven alliance might simply be for protection, or an act of desperation from the leadership of the past.
The way I see it, the Forsworn were forcibly held down and evicted from land that were rightfully their own, just like the Orsimer. They are viewed with scorn, much like the orsimer once were. And likely, they are just as noble as the orcs if they got the chance to be. They chose to stay and fight for their land, instead of, as most orcs did, leave and settle down other places until they almost got a carte blanche from Wayrest and the Empire that they wouldn't invade what was left of Orsinium. Only recently, Orsinium is beginning to sprout again, one should notice. The orsimer are slightly barbaric as well, but in the warrior sense. They are fierce warriors, 'berserkers', one might say.
The Reachmen, on the contrary, works with the shamanistic aspect of barbarism. The magic, as opposed to the orsimers' brute force. And natural magic is bound to be a bit more bloody than most other magic. But let me remind you that there are alchemist's ingredients named Sabre Cat's Eye, Human Flesh, Bonemeal, Vampire Dust and so on. Magic uses morbid and savage tools, it's just a bit more obvious with the Forsworn. I mean, how can you chastise them for having goats' eyes laying around when you pluck out those of a sabre cat yourself?
And before you say you don't do that, let me just remind you that it's possible.
I find them alluring mostly because they are actually a whole new race, thinking and capable of being civil, unlike the falmer, who have long since degenerated, as we can all vouch for. They are a true eleventh race, and they are ancient. The way they are presented, they seem like perhaps runaway slaves from the Ayleid or whatever, who set up in the ruins and caves north of Cyrodiil. The way they talk, they appear to have been there for longer than the Nords. Even though the Nords came first from Atmora, most were wiped out, and I believe that the Reachmen, like the Bretons, are from a strand of elven slaves, who split off from the breton race long time ago. They are an eleventh race which we were almost completely unprepared for. No one saw it coming, even though there were vague references to the race in earlier games (these were never discussed much, though).
And it is not definitely proven what these "Old Gods" are. It's the Nords who call them "Old Gods". But the Nordic old gods are Kyne, Shor etc, which IIRC is Kynareth and Lorkhan, and thus Aedra, not Daedra (Lorkan is a Daedra, yes, but acknowledged even by the Temple of the Nine).
Of course, them being in cahoots with Hagravens is less than outright amiable, but they are effectively fighting a guerilla war, and they had to improvise on their weaponry, much like, say, the Taleban has (Sorry for invoking the Afghanistan War on this, btw). The Hagraven alliance might simply be for protection, or an act of desperation from the leadership of the past.
The way I see it, the Forsworn were forcibly held down and evicted from land that were rightfully their own, just like the Orsimer. They are viewed with scorn, much like the orsimer once were. And likely, they are just as noble as the orcs if they got the chance to be. They chose to stay and fight for their land, instead of, as most orcs did, leave and settle down other places until they almost got a carte blanche from Wayrest and the Empire that they wouldn't invade what was left of Orsinium. Only recently, Orsinium is beginning to sprout again, one should notice. The orsimer are slightly barbaric as well, but in the warrior sense. They are fierce warriors, 'berserkers', one might say.
The Reachmen, on the contrary, works with the shamanistic aspect of barbarism. The magic, as opposed to the orsimers' brute force. And natural magic is bound to be a bit more bloody than most other magic. But let me remind you that there are alchemist's ingredients named Sabre Cat's Eye, Human Flesh, Bonemeal, Vampire Dust and so on. Magic uses morbid and savage tools, it's just a bit more obvious with the Forsworn. I mean, how can you chastise them for having goats' eyes laying around when you pluck out those of a sabre cat yourself?
And before you say you don't do that, let me just remind you that it's possible.
Because there's no fun to be found in being normal.
- JVElEven
- Master

- Posts: 1234
- Joined: Sun Apr 17, 2011 9:26 pm
- ES Games: Oblivion, Shivering Isles, Knights of the Nine, Skyrim (DUH!)
- Platform: PC
- Status: The last damn purist around here!
- Other Profiles: I'm always JVElEven. Look me up on Steam
- Location: Jylland
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
(Terribly sorry for double post, but I was running out of space)
I saw someone (I think it was Rynkar) saying on the first page, that if you weren't strong enough to hold your land, then perhaps you didn't deserve it:
Does that mean you believe that Israel should never have existed? Ireland didn't deserve independence? Norway? Bosnia (Both present and pre-WW1), Chechnya, Tibet, Taiwan and many other Caucasus republics?
It's the same as saying that Hungary should've been annexed by the USSR in 1956, because they weren't strong enough.
Yes, the strongest may well be the one who win and take the spoils, but that doesn't jutify it. If you look at it like that, you'd in the same way say that becuase my country couldn't defend ourselves during WW2, we should be part of Germany.
In fact, that's a pretty nice analogy: Denmark were occupied by Germany under WW2. If the stronger one has the right, as you said, shouldn't we be annexed, as clearly we weren't fit to rule ourselves and have our own land, despite thousands of years of distinct separate culture and history. That is the equivalent in real life of what you argue.
I personally don't find them barbaric and savage. I see them as freedom fighters fighting off occupiers, forgotten by all of the world, and needing to resort to savage ways to stay alive. It's a good marker to the resistance of WW2, who also did despicable things to stay alive and to keep the battle going. Are you going to claim that they were barbaric savages who should just give up, don a swatika and heil to the fuhrer? No.
I respect your opinion that the Reachmen are barbarian savages who don't deserve to have their own land. But I will say that I find your argumentation flawed and unconvincing, and I don't really see any depth put into it. It just appears to me that you only took a very superficial view into it, and then stopped with what you could see (Their clothing and their clutter). I'm sorry, but I find your argumentation flawed, and I don't understand the reasoning behind it, as it is very preposterous when compared to the real world. But I respect your opinion, and hope for an educated debate.
Lastly, I noticed that Hessien isn't arguing for that point of view straight out, so sorry for mentioning you immediately.
And sorry for the Godwin's Law incident, but really, it was inevitable.
I saw someone (I think it was Rynkar) saying on the first page, that if you weren't strong enough to hold your land, then perhaps you didn't deserve it:
Does that mean you believe that Israel should never have existed? Ireland didn't deserve independence? Norway? Bosnia (Both present and pre-WW1), Chechnya, Tibet, Taiwan and many other Caucasus republics?
It's the same as saying that Hungary should've been annexed by the USSR in 1956, because they weren't strong enough.
Yes, the strongest may well be the one who win and take the spoils, but that doesn't jutify it. If you look at it like that, you'd in the same way say that becuase my country couldn't defend ourselves during WW2, we should be part of Germany.
In fact, that's a pretty nice analogy: Denmark were occupied by Germany under WW2. If the stronger one has the right, as you said, shouldn't we be annexed, as clearly we weren't fit to rule ourselves and have our own land, despite thousands of years of distinct separate culture and history. That is the equivalent in real life of what you argue.
I personally don't find them barbaric and savage. I see them as freedom fighters fighting off occupiers, forgotten by all of the world, and needing to resort to savage ways to stay alive. It's a good marker to the resistance of WW2, who also did despicable things to stay alive and to keep the battle going. Are you going to claim that they were barbaric savages who should just give up, don a swatika and heil to the fuhrer? No.
I respect your opinion that the Reachmen are barbarian savages who don't deserve to have their own land. But I will say that I find your argumentation flawed and unconvincing, and I don't really see any depth put into it. It just appears to me that you only took a very superficial view into it, and then stopped with what you could see (Their clothing and their clutter). I'm sorry, but I find your argumentation flawed, and I don't understand the reasoning behind it, as it is very preposterous when compared to the real world. But I respect your opinion, and hope for an educated debate.
Lastly, I noticed that Hessien isn't arguing for that point of view straight out, so sorry for mentioning you immediately.
And sorry for the Godwin's Law incident, but really, it was inevitable.
Because there's no fun to be found in being normal.
- Pilaf The Defiler
- Imperial Legate

- Posts: 4359
- Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2011 9:03 pm
- ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim, ESO
- Platform: PC, Xbox, Xbox 360
- Status: Fresh
- UESPoints: 20
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
I'd like to point out that the Forsworn are just a faction of Reachmen, which were mentioned as far back as 1997 in Redguard's Pocket Guide. So they're not a new race or a new lore concept at all. They've just not appeared in any games yet until now.
Skyrim has fleshed out their lore and background a lot in interesting ways, of course, but they're not new. I imagine to the casual fans, if something like a Sload or Imga appeared in an expansion or future game they'd seem like new races too, but they've also been there all along. That's the cool thing about Tamriel. Many levels of background ideas to explore.
Skyrim has fleshed out their lore and background a lot in interesting ways, of course, but they're not new. I imagine to the casual fans, if something like a Sload or Imga appeared in an expansion or future game they'd seem like new races too, but they've also been there all along. That's the cool thing about Tamriel. Many levels of background ideas to explore.
Monsters are bred in labyrinths, labyrinths are bred from walls. There is a reason the Giants choose to remain nomadic rather than follow their shield kin the Nords in building permanent settlements. The Tower is the beginning of all walls.
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
As per above, the Forsworn aren't an ancient or entirely new race: they're simply the remnants of skirmishes between Bretons and Nords, as is explained even in the game's loading screens. They're not a part of some ancient or lost culture: they're simply war refugees who became tribal.
That said, I'd also like to point out again that the logic that the "Forsworn had their lands taken from them" is flawed in and of itself. Mostly because, as per lore, Skyrim was originally Elven: that said, by that logic, all Humans do not belong, and the land should be owned by the Altmer and Falmer.
That said, I'd also like to point out again that the logic that the "Forsworn had their lands taken from them" is flawed in and of itself. Mostly because, as per lore, Skyrim was originally Elven: that said, by that logic, all Humans do not belong, and the land should be owned by the Altmer and Falmer.
First to fight for the right, and to build the nation's might, the Army goes rolling along.
- JVElEven
- Master

- Posts: 1234
- Joined: Sun Apr 17, 2011 9:26 pm
- ES Games: Oblivion, Shivering Isles, Knights of the Nine, Skyrim (DUH!)
- Platform: PC
- Status: The last damn purist around here!
- Other Profiles: I'm always JVElEven. Look me up on Steam
- Location: Jylland
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
Yes, I know they were mentioned before, I believe I did say that.
I just meant in the way that they are new to the game universe. And the Forsworn may just be a fraction of the Reachmen, but how many Reachmen have you seen that wasn't living in the wilderness. There's those keeping watch on Thonar and Nepos' henchmen, but that was on Madanach's orders.
Like my earlier WW2 analogy, most of the population in Denmark, for example, but also France and others, didn't do anything, but didn't like the Germans being there. And a small number fought back.
If it's like that, then the Forsworn might have a large support among a (perhaps hidden) populace of Reachmen.
I just meant in the way that they are new to the game universe. And the Forsworn may just be a fraction of the Reachmen, but how many Reachmen have you seen that wasn't living in the wilderness. There's those keeping watch on Thonar and Nepos' henchmen, but that was on Madanach's orders.
Like my earlier WW2 analogy, most of the population in Denmark, for example, but also France and others, didn't do anything, but didn't like the Germans being there. And a small number fought back.
If it's like that, then the Forsworn might have a large support among a (perhaps hidden) populace of Reachmen.
Because there's no fun to be found in being normal.
- Pilaf The Defiler
- Imperial Legate

- Posts: 4359
- Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2011 9:03 pm
- ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim, ESO
- Platform: PC, Xbox, Xbox 360
- Status: Fresh
- UESPoints: 20
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
JVElEven wrote:Yes, I know they were mentioned before, I believe I did say that.
I just meant in the way that they are new to the game universe. And the Forsworn may just be a fraction of the Reachmen, but how many Reachmen have you seen that wasn't living in the wilderness. There's those keeping watch on Thonar and Nepos' henchmen, but that was on Madanach's orders.
Like my earlier WW2 analogy, most of the population in Denmark, for example, but also France and others, didn't do anything, but didn't like the Germans being there. And a small number fought back.
If it's like that, then the Forsworn might have a large support among a (perhaps hidden) populace of Reachmen.
Yes, that's likely, but they're not "on the front lines" as it were, so they might only have a lukewarm support for the Forsworn. They could be inspired to rise up if the situation got very bad though.
Monsters are bred in labyrinths, labyrinths are bred from walls. There is a reason the Giants choose to remain nomadic rather than follow their shield kin the Nords in building permanent settlements. The Tower is the beginning of all walls.
- JVElEven
- Master

- Posts: 1234
- Joined: Sun Apr 17, 2011 9:26 pm
- ES Games: Oblivion, Shivering Isles, Knights of the Nine, Skyrim (DUH!)
- Platform: PC
- Status: The last damn purist around here!
- Other Profiles: I'm always JVElEven. Look me up on Steam
- Location: Jylland
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
That's smething we could argue about till the end of the world, since there's no evidence of either theory.
You believe it's a lukewarm support that will occur if the situation gets dire, while I believe it's a populace that supports them wholeheartedly, but for whatever reasons have been scared into acting neutral.
You believe it's a lukewarm support that will occur if the situation gets dire, while I believe it's a populace that supports them wholeheartedly, but for whatever reasons have been scared into acting neutral.
Because there's no fun to be found in being normal.
- Pilaf The Defiler
- Imperial Legate

- Posts: 4359
- Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2011 9:03 pm
- ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim, ESO
- Platform: PC, Xbox, Xbox 360
- Status: Fresh
- UESPoints: 20
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
I think maybe they're tired of war. I suspect the Oblivion crisis affected them, too, and the siege of Orsinium happened in or near their lands, etc. Also there was the War of Ben'dr'mark or however the crap you spell it that happened while Jagar was posing as Uriel Septim, when the Nords tried to take back their lands from the Redguards and Bretons, and felt the Reach was part of those lands. I'm sure the Reachmen have had their share of bloodshed in the past centuries. I think the Forsworn continue to fight the hardest because they perceive their lands as still being occupied by Nords, whereas the Nord forces withdrew from the middle and Western Reach 2 centuries ago.
Monsters are bred in labyrinths, labyrinths are bred from walls. There is a reason the Giants choose to remain nomadic rather than follow their shield kin the Nords in building permanent settlements. The Tower is the beginning of all walls.
-
Witchery
- Master

- Posts: 1081
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2012 1:39 am
- ES Games: IV: GOTY, V: DG, HF, DB
- Platform: PC (IV, V) & PS3 (V)
Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?
And here is where the Hagraven-lubber comes in! I take issue with your assumption that all Hagravens are evil and cohorting with them is evil. Just because we don't understand something doesn't mean it's wrong. Sure, the Hagravens are vile . . and cruel . . and train witches . . and slaughter goats . . and literally kill nature. . and are ugly. . but that doesn't mean they're all evil. Let's say. . A Necromancer, for example. The College of Winterhold allows this "evil" art. So, does that make someone that practices necromancy evil? The College is obviously evil for allowing it, right? Just because most Necromancers are evil, doesn't mean they all are.JVElEven wrote: ... Of course, them being in cahoots with Hagravens is less than outright amiable, but they are effectively fighting a guerilla war, and they had to improvise on their weaponry, much like, say, the Taleban has (Sorry for invoking the Afghanistan War on this, btw). The Hagraven alliance might simply be for protection, or an act of desperation from the leadership of the past. ...
A much more likely reason for the Forsworn teaming up with the witches would be that they are spiritual vessels for the Forsworn's gods, and act as a much more devoted and powerful Shaman to the Forsworn. (which might be the reason all Forsworn Shamans are female. They could be training to become Hags, much like witches do with the unaffiliated Hagravens.) Women are twisted into Hags in pursuit of ancient magics, not necessarily evil. They're as much an important part of Reachmen lore as a Briarheart is. (Which wouldn't exist without the Hags!)
Why would they work with the Hags, live with them even, if they are just for protection? Evidence backing up my spiritual guidance claim is the fact that a Hagraven Matriarch is the LEADER of a Forsworn redoubt. They call the shots. They're not just hired muscle . . er, magic. ( Evidence, More Evidence, Worth a read too ,lol more ) They are revered and protected by the Forsworn. The "hags were here first, and they are on our side" explains that the Hagravens are helping the Forsworn.
Now, I understand not all witches that become Hagravens are allies to the Forsworn, or even are Bretons/Reachmen. But most Hags take residence in the Reach. How I view it, is . .
Witch becoming Hagraven = Unaffiliated with the Forsworn, mostly in it for just powerful magic/much longer lifespan/power/knowledge/etc.
Forsworn Shaman becoming Hagraven = closer to Forsworn's gods spiritually, possible candidate for Matriarchy of a Forsworn encampment, along with powers
Are Spriggans evil because they attack you? I think not, they're beings of Meridia and Kynareth. A "good" Daedra and an Aedra. The Hagravens may use magic in a more archaic form and they may use nature rather than scholarship to practice their craft, but we cannot claim they are evil anymore than we can say the Forsworn are.