You know, the underlining of the text really messes with my thinking process for some reason
Anyway:
Backfire wrote:We can believe one side or the other, that they acted in fear for their own people or in their own lust for power, but neither choice can hardly be dubbed "undeniable".
This is what I love, the fact that Morrowinds history is based on many stories with unique differences in all of them. It is so similar to real life it is nearly uncanny, which leaves a lot to player discussion.
Backfire wrote:It was Azura who turned the Chimer into the Dunmer, and it was Azura's plan to topple the Tribunal. She may be persuasive and powerful, but I wouldn't say that she does things to solely benefit herself. What did she have to gain by avenging Nerevar's death and deforming the Chimer people when she was not involved in the plights of what is now Morrowind?
Azura cursed the Chimer because a few of them decided to go against
her will. Don't you think that is a tiny bit petty? and did she really have to go and turn the entire race into another race because of a select few?
She got involved, in my opinion, to try and get back the power she lost over the Dunmer people. What better way to get the peoples attention then to be the power behind Dagoth Ur's defeat? She did it for her self.
Backfire wrote:she was the one confirmed Dagoth Ur's original report of the Heart's existence to Nerevar, another act which I don't see directly benefiting her.
What is the one thing that would really annoy a God? normal people turning into divine beings(the Dwemer in this case). Because Nerevar was such a devote follower to Azura she trusted him with the information so he could guard the heart and stop anything like this from being attempted again. To bad for her that her own followers got lured in by the power.
Backfire wrote:If the Empire were to leave, they'd find a way to profit from it. They also (obviously) found a way to profit from them coming in the first place. They sided with the obvious winner and took major advantage in the following turmoil succeeding the entrance of the Empire
House Hlaalu annoy me. I mean they have no doubt got a lot of sense when it comes to business but they have no care for the Dunmer traditions and Independence. Valuing money over all else, in my opinion, is a sign of weak character and a lack of devotion to your own race. I could only hope that when the Empire falls, House Hlaalu falls with it. In my eyes they deserve nothing less.
Backfire wrote:From the get go, the Tribunal already made the Dunmer weak (in that they actually turned them into Dunmer).
I'm not sure you can really say they where weakened by there changing, all that we know happened to them for sure was a change in physical appearance.
Backfire wrote:Thirdly, we can't say what Nerevar could have done for his people because he died in his prime! Not to mention that he lead to the destruction of the Dwemer, the then deadliest enemy of the now Dunmer people.
You forget that Nerevar was just a mortal Mer, yes he was a great general for the Chimer people but he was nothing compared to the might of the ALMSIVI. The fact that the Tribunal never die because of the heart meant that they could look after there province till the end of time. They would do more for there people then Nerevar or the Empire ever could.
Okay, now I will discuss Nucleon's post:
Nucleon wrote:Once again, I can't access UESP but didn't St Veloth guide the Chimer out of the Mer heartlands because of a difference in religion, in which the Chimer made a pact with Aedra and Daedra? That was what defined the Chimer.
St.Veloth was the leader of a section of Mer that left the Elven heartlands yes. However, they did not worship the Aedra, but rather the Daedra with whom they made a pact and where given guidance to leave.
I believe it is the other Mer at the time who worshipped the Aedra, the Chimer did not want to worship them because they have barely any involvement with the mortal realm.
Nucleon wrote:Hlaalu Dunmer are obviously pro-empire. If Morrowind is to gain independance from the Empire, House Hlaalu will be brought down a couple of pegs. They directly benefit from the occupation.
I honestly couldn't agree more with this. So I can't comment.
Nucleon wrote:
Resdayn was the name of the Chimer Kingdom in Nerevar's times. I think the country was called like that up until the Imperial Invasion, in which it gained its Province of Morrowind denomination, but it isn't impossible that "Morrowind" became effective as soon as Chimer turned to Dunmer.
Ah yes I managed to search in Resdayn and it came up. It tells that it was named that until Imperial Invasion, after that it was changed to Morrowind.