Damn you Empire, damn you.

A place to discuss and ask questions about the third part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Dean »

Backfire wrote:For me, it's hard to judge whether or not Ur was evil or just ignorant. The blight that he released on Vvardenfell was, in his eyes, a way to free the Dunmer. All the Ash Gouls, Sleepers, Dreamers, and other Dagoths who speak to you say that blight is a blessing, not a curse, and will open your eyes rather than make you rabid and monstrous.
Yeah but his corrupted minions will say that, after all the whole lot of them are cursed.
I think, as you say, maybe he is more insane then anything else. He has been using the hearts evil powers for the last millennia or longer and has embraced this unlike the ALMSIVI who fight the evil, because Dagoth Ur gave into the corruption it is obvious that he is not in control but the power controls him. So I agree with you completely on that.
He is like a vessel of this divine corruption, that is how I see it anyway.
User avatar
GUM!!!!
Warder
Warder
Posts: 479
Joined: Sat May 22, 2010 12:00 am
ES Games: obivion, morrowind and Skyrim
Status: Still here
Location: Canada

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by GUM!!!! »

Scozzar wrote:Im too lost in this conversation. Im not going to even post :? :mrgreen:
seconded :wink:
"Wally, get off our forums."
- Caz

"I have a hypothesis that the number of Tyrannosaurs dressed as Santa Claus in your lecture notes is inversely proportional to the quality of the lecture."
- Argonanza
Backfire
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 152
Joined: Sun Jul 18, 2010 7:36 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: XBox / XBox 360
Status: yes
Location: look behind you

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Backfire »

He is like a vessel of this divine corruption, that is how I see it anyway.
Bingo. 100%.
"I see," said the blind man.

98% of forumers say fast travel ruins Oblivion. Put this in your signature if you're one of the 2% who realize it's optional.
Nucleon
Associate
Associate
Posts: 22
Joined: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:49 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: PC

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Nucleon »

Mega-interesting thread, BTW. Kudos!
backfire wrote:The Empire isn't controlling the political system. Like I said before, the Temple and Great Houses are the driving forces behind what happens in Morrowind. They originated before the Empire came to the island. (...) Also, as I said before, the Empire isn't enforcing its religious practices to any degree onto the Dunmer people. They can worship whomever they themselves choose.
Who rules in Morrowind? Hard to say. On the whole of Morrowind, it is King Helseth (if your character doesn't end up killing the popinjay, that is), who is embroiled in a war with the Tribunal/House Indoril.

In Vvardenfell it is the council around the Duke in Ebonheart. Look at the people around his table and you will have a good idea about power in Vvardenfell. I can't access UESP right now, but as far as I can remember, there is no Temple representative (althought there is a Imperial Cult one, among many other Imperial seats). In fact. much as the Ashlanders themselves, the Temple (and by it, House Indoril) feels more like the occupied than the allied.
RobotNixon wrote:They have some of the most experienced warriors and mages in all of Tamriel.
Use them.

The only thing standing in their way is the fact that Morrowind is a house divided, into 5 houses.
They will never stand against the Empire as long as they stand against each other.
This.

As soon as the Tribunes defied Azura, as soon as Chimer became Dunmer, they were weakened.

Nerevar's main qualities were that of an unifier; It is with his guidance that the Chimer booted the Nords out, and that the Great Houses - six or seven of them at the time, if House Sotha was genuine - were unified. It was the golden age of the Chimer. No matter how benevolent the Tribunes were, they perverted the Chimer's fundamental deal with the Aedra and the Daedra. The Dunmer were a denatured people.

The cause of Resdaynia's inevitable loss can only be attributed to divisions in the great Houses: House Redoran ended up with the prospect of being the only House that actually put troops in front of the Imperials.

The real winners in the Empire's invasion are Capitalistic ventures like the East Empire Company and some individuals in House Hlaalu: Like it was written in a in-game book, the cost of the occupation, in gold and personal, offset the gain there is to be made. The Empire did not gain a military ally in Morrowind, and the Dunmer didn't get Empire's enlightment, like banning slavery.

For this, I believe atrue Dunmer Neverarine could only be a Resdaynian nationalist; He is an unifier, and a liberator - not a protector nor a lone adventurer, like he was used in TES III: He was a King. A Nerevarine could admire the Empire, long for its refinement, but stick to his people's values when comes the time to chose.
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Dean »

I'm glad you like it, I wanted something different :P
Nucleon wrote:As soon as the Tribunes defied Azura, as soon as Chimer became Dunmer, they were weakened.
I am not really sure about this, you see Azura like most Daedra still does things solely to benefit herself. She can act benevolent as she likes but the greed is still there, I mean she made a worshipper go into hiding for a couple of hundred years to prove a point to another Daedra Prince.
The Tribunal, in my opinion, strengthened the Dunmer people. They managed to cease an invasion of the Akaviri forces by flooding the province of Morrowind, that is more then Nerevar ever could do for his people. You may think that would of killed the Dunmer people but Vivec taught them all the power of water breathing, pretty wise aye?
Nucleon wrote:The real winners in the Empire's invasion are Capitalistic ventures like the East Empire Company and some individuals in House Hlaalu:
Exactly my point. I agree with you completely on this, the Dunmer people are being raped of there resources and wealth by the Imperial occupants and Imperial allies in the house Hlaalu.
If the Dunmer people had not been invaded, but rather allied with by the Imperials then the outcome would have been much fairer and a bond would of been made which would not of been one of control. Talking to nearly any Dunmer in-game will show you that they do not admire the Imperials one bit.
Nucleon wrote:For this, I believe atrue Dunmer Neverarine could only be a Resdaynian nationalist; He is an unifier, and a liberator - not a protector nor a lone adventurer, like he was used in TES III: He was a King. A Nerevarine could admire the Empire, long for its refinement, but stick to his people's values when comes the time to chose.
I'm sorry I don't actually know what a Resdaynian is, there is no mention in any Lore that I have read or any mention on the wiki that I have found :?
Explain what you mean by this last paragraph, I am a little confused. Interesting no doubt.
Nucleon
Associate
Associate
Posts: 22
Joined: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:49 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: PC

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Nucleon »

Newsound wrote:I'm glad you like it, I wanted something different
Yeah I'm a sucker for these political threads. Politics are IMO one of the most interesting aspect of Morrowind.
I am not really sure about this, you see Azura like most Daedra still does things solely to benefit herself. She can act benevolent as she likes but the greed is still there, I mean she made a worshipper go into hiding for a couple of hundred years to prove a point to another Daedra Prince.
Once again, I can't access UESP but didn't St Veloth guide the Chimer out of the Mer heartlands because of a difference in religion, in which the Chimer made a pact with Aedra and Daedra? That was what defined the Chimer.
The Tribunal, in my opinion, strengthened the Dunmer people. They managed to cease an invasion of the Akaviri forces by flooding the province of Morrowind, that is more then Nerevar ever could do for his people. You may think that would of killed the Dunmer people but Vivec taught them all the power of water breathing, pretty wise aye?
It is undeniable that they were well-intentionned.
Exactly my point. I agree with you completely on this, the Dunmer people are being raped of there resources and wealth by the Imperial occupants and Imperial allies in the house Hlaalu.
If the Dunmer people had not been invaded, but rather allied with by the Imperials then the outcome would have been much fairer and a bond would of been made which would not of been one of control. Talking to nearly any Dunmer in-game will show you that they do not admire the Imperials one bit.
Hlaalu Dunmer are obviously pro-empire. If Morrowind is to gain independance from the Empire, House Hlaalu will be brought down a couple of pegs. They directly benefit from the occupation.
I'm sorry I don't actually know what a Resdaynian is, there is no mention in any Lore that I have read or any mention on the wiki that I have found
Explain what you mean by this last paragraph, I am a little confused. Interesting no doubt.
Resdayn was the name of the Chimer Kingdom in Nerevar's times. I think the country was called like that up until the Imperial Invasion, in which it gained its Province of Morrowind denomination, but it isn't impossible that "Morrowind" became effective as soon as Chimer turned to Dunmer.
Backfire
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 152
Joined: Sun Jul 18, 2010 7:36 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: XBox / XBox 360
Status: yes
Location: look behind you

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Backfire »

In a hurry? Read only the bold and underlined text!
The Tribunal, in my opinion, strengthened the Dunmer people. They managed to cease an invasion of the Akaviri forces by flooding the province of Morrowind, that is more then Nerevar ever could do for his people. You may think that would of killed the Dunmer people but Vivec taught them all the power of water breathing, pretty wise aye?

It is undeniable that they were well-intentionned.
The acts of the Tribunal cannot be called "undeniably" well intentioned. One of the largest controversies of the game is how the Tribunal became what they are now. A widely believed, supported theory is that the Tribunal murdered Nerevar to gain access to the Heart of Lorkhan to turn themselves into immortal gods, using the advancement of their people as an excuse. We can believe one side or the other, that they acted in fear for their own people or in their own lust for power, but neither choice can hardly be dubbed "undeniable".
Azura like most Daedra still does things solely to benefit herself
I myself didn't know whether or not this was true, so I looked at her page on UESP (http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Lore:Azura). There are two semi-conflicting statements about her: 1) "[Azura] is presumably the only Daedra that shows any concern for the well-being of her mortal subjects, as is evidenced in books such as Invocation of Azura." 2) "Though never obviously deceitful, how she always gets what she desires in the end can be portrayed as disturbing." It was Azura who turned the Chimer into the Dunmer, and it was Azura's plan to topple the Tribunal. She may be persuasive and powerful, but I wouldn't say that she does things to solely benefit herself. What did she have to gain by avenging Nerevar's death and deforming the Chimer people when she was not involved in the plights of what is now Morrowind?

Note: Her page also states that the Tribunal did indeed murder Nerevar as to use the Heart for themselves. That, however, may not be more than speculation. It also says that she was the one confirmed Dagoth Ur's original report of the Heart's existence to Nerevar, another act which I don't see directly benefiting her.
Hlaalu Dunmer are obviously pro-empire. If Morrowind is to gain independance from the Empire, House Hlaalu will be brought down a couple of pegs. They directly benefit from the occupation.
Do remember that House Hlaalu is the house of business and trade. I'd guess that some of the shrewdest, trickiest people in Morrowind if not the Empire (at least the shrewdest, trickiest of the Dunmer) are a part of House Hlaalu. If the Empire were to leave, they'd find a way to profit from it. They also (obviously) found a way to profit from them coming in the first place. They sided with the obvious winner and took major advantage in the following turmoil succeeding the entrance of the Empire (taking over House Indoril being an example).
The Tribunal, in my opinion, strengthened the Dunmer people. They managed to cease an invasion of the Akaviri forces by flooding the province of Morrowind, that is more then Nerevar ever could do for his people
First off, before anything, do remember that a direct result from the Tribunal's existence was Azura's cursing the Chimer to becoming the Dunmer. From the get go, the Tribunal already made the Dunmer weak (in that they actually turned them into Dunmer). Secondly, nobody can say that such an act directly proves that the Tribunal was concerned about its people rather than about itself. The theory of the the Tribunal killing Nerevar to take control of the Heart has strong support; aforementioned, fear for their own people's well being could be nothing but a front to hide their selfish intentions. If you're already a god, you might as well use your godly powers to gain support of your people (rather than letting them die out). It could have been nothing more than a politically motivated act. Thirdly, we can't say what Nerevar could have done for his people because he died in his prime! Not to mention that he lead to the destruction of the Dwemer, the then deadliest enemy of the now Dunmer people. To say that Nerevar didn't do anything equal to the Tribunal for the Dunmer people is ridiculous. He did save them just as the Tribunal did, but then he went one step further and didn't kill an innocent hero to set himself up as a god (although we can't objectively say this about the Tribunal, as that's a mere theory, Nerevar's not doing as such isn't helping their case).
"I see," said the blind man.

98% of forumers say fast travel ruins Oblivion. Put this in your signature if you're one of the 2% who realize it's optional.
Nucleon
Associate
Associate
Posts: 22
Joined: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:49 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: PC

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Nucleon »

Backfire wrote:The acts of the Tribunal cannot be called "undeniably" well intentioned. One of the largest controversies of the game is how the Tribunal became what they are now. A widely believed, supported theory is that the Tribunal murdered Nerevar to gain access to the Heart of Lorkhan to turn themselves into immortal gods, using the advancement of their people as an excuse. We can believe one side or the other, that they acted in fear for their own people or in their own lust for power, but neither choice can hardly be dubbed "undeniable".
This is the land of the Dark Elves: Treachery, lies and assassination are all valued tools to obtain power. That's in their ways, they are a people that are revering spirits and demons. I do believe that the Tribunes assassinated Nerevar, but I also believe they did it out of good intentions.
Do remember that House Hlaalu is the house of business and trade. I'd guess that some of the shrewdest, trickiest people in Morrowind if not the Empire (at least the shrewdest, trickiest of the Dunmer) are a part of House Hlaalu. If the Empire were to leave, they'd find a way to profit from it. They also (obviously) found a way to profit from them coming in the first place. They sided with the obvious winner and took major advantage in the following turmoil succeeding the entrance of the Empire (taking over House Indoril being an example).
Hlaalu is the least xenophobic of the Dunmer Houses, but they have thrown all of their weight behind the Empire. Little in House Hlaalu is traditionally Dunmer: they have Nord and Imperial councillors, and their royal families have gained their hold on Morrowind thanks to the protection of the Empire. They favor no nationalism. They are the Dunmer voice of the Empire, nothing less.
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Dean »

You know, the underlining of the text really messes with my thinking process for some reason :?

Anyway:
Backfire wrote:We can believe one side or the other, that they acted in fear for their own people or in their own lust for power, but neither choice can hardly be dubbed "undeniable".
This is what I love, the fact that Morrowinds history is based on many stories with unique differences in all of them. It is so similar to real life it is nearly uncanny, which leaves a lot to player discussion.
Backfire wrote:It was Azura who turned the Chimer into the Dunmer, and it was Azura's plan to topple the Tribunal. She may be persuasive and powerful, but I wouldn't say that she does things to solely benefit herself. What did she have to gain by avenging Nerevar's death and deforming the Chimer people when she was not involved in the plights of what is now Morrowind?
Azura cursed the Chimer because a few of them decided to go against her will. Don't you think that is a tiny bit petty? and did she really have to go and turn the entire race into another race because of a select few?
She got involved, in my opinion, to try and get back the power she lost over the Dunmer people. What better way to get the peoples attention then to be the power behind Dagoth Ur's defeat? She did it for her self.
Backfire wrote:she was the one confirmed Dagoth Ur's original report of the Heart's existence to Nerevar, another act which I don't see directly benefiting her.
What is the one thing that would really annoy a God? normal people turning into divine beings(the Dwemer in this case). Because Nerevar was such a devote follower to Azura she trusted him with the information so he could guard the heart and stop anything like this from being attempted again. To bad for her that her own followers got lured in by the power.
Backfire wrote:If the Empire were to leave, they'd find a way to profit from it. They also (obviously) found a way to profit from them coming in the first place. They sided with the obvious winner and took major advantage in the following turmoil succeeding the entrance of the Empire
House Hlaalu annoy me. I mean they have no doubt got a lot of sense when it comes to business but they have no care for the Dunmer traditions and Independence. Valuing money over all else, in my opinion, is a sign of weak character and a lack of devotion to your own race. I could only hope that when the Empire falls, House Hlaalu falls with it. In my eyes they deserve nothing less.
Backfire wrote:From the get go, the Tribunal already made the Dunmer weak (in that they actually turned them into Dunmer).
I'm not sure you can really say they where weakened by there changing, all that we know happened to them for sure was a change in physical appearance.
Backfire wrote:Thirdly, we can't say what Nerevar could have done for his people because he died in his prime! Not to mention that he lead to the destruction of the Dwemer, the then deadliest enemy of the now Dunmer people.
You forget that Nerevar was just a mortal Mer, yes he was a great general for the Chimer people but he was nothing compared to the might of the ALMSIVI. The fact that the Tribunal never die because of the heart meant that they could look after there province till the end of time. They would do more for there people then Nerevar or the Empire ever could.

Okay, now I will discuss Nucleon's post:

Nucleon wrote:Once again, I can't access UESP but didn't St Veloth guide the Chimer out of the Mer heartlands because of a difference in religion, in which the Chimer made a pact with Aedra and Daedra? That was what defined the Chimer.
St.Veloth was the leader of a section of Mer that left the Elven heartlands yes. However, they did not worship the Aedra, but rather the Daedra with whom they made a pact and where given guidance to leave.
I believe it is the other Mer at the time who worshipped the Aedra, the Chimer did not want to worship them because they have barely any involvement with the mortal realm.
Nucleon wrote:Hlaalu Dunmer are obviously pro-empire. If Morrowind is to gain independance from the Empire, House Hlaalu will be brought down a couple of pegs. They directly benefit from the occupation.
I honestly couldn't agree more with this. So I can't comment.
Nucleon wrote: Resdayn was the name of the Chimer Kingdom in Nerevar's times. I think the country was called like that up until the Imperial Invasion, in which it gained its Province of Morrowind denomination, but it isn't impossible that "Morrowind" became effective as soon as Chimer turned to Dunmer.
Ah yes I managed to search in Resdayn and it came up. It tells that it was named that until Imperial Invasion, after that it was changed to Morrowind.
Backfire
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 152
Joined: Sun Jul 18, 2010 7:36 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: XBox / XBox 360
Status: yes
Location: look behind you

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Backfire »

and did she really have to go and turn the entire race into another race because of a select few?
The Heart destroyed a whole race, like, in an instant. The Heart is incomprehensibly dangerous, and for the Tribunal to use it so carelessly and selfishly as they did (in the eyes of Azura, at least) is simply indescribably ignorant and arrogant. I can see Azura being so p**sed off that she felt like she had to do something. Messing with the Heart like they did earns something so rash as what Azura did.
Azura cursed the Chimer because a few of them decided to go against her will. Don't you think that is a tiny bit petty? . . .
She got involved, in my opinion, to try and get back the power she lost over the Dunmer people. What better way to get the peoples attention then to be the power behind Dagoth Ur's defeat? She did it for her self.
What power are you talking about? If it's how the Tribunal became the leading religion in Morrowind, taking Azura out of the picture, then I'd doubt that it's selfish greed rather than avenging a personal and inhumane insult. Azura is smart, for sure, but I can't see her coming up with such an elaborate plan as you propose simply in the name of greed. Find me a wiki page and I'll believe what you're saying, but until we can get some written proof, our reasoning behind her actions are only speculation.
What is the one thing that would really annoy a God? normal people turning into divine beings(the Dwemer in this case).
Again, it's a good argument, but I haven't seen any evidence as to this being true.
House Hlaalu annoy me. I mean they have no doubt got a lot of sense when it comes to business but they have no care for the Dunmer traditions and Independence. Valuing money over all else, in my opinion, is a sign of weak character and a lack of devotion to your own race. I could only hope that when the Empire falls, House Hlaalu falls with it. In my eyes they deserve nothing less.
House Hlaalu knows how to win / not lose. I won't put the blame on them, nor find any fault in them, if they act based on what's best for themselves, not what's best for principle. It might not be the most honorable thing to do, but it's a dog-eat-dog world.
You forget that Nerevar was just a mortal Mer, yes he was a great general for the Chimer people but he was nothing compared to the might of the ALMSIVI. The fact that the Tribunal never die because of the heart meant that they could look after there province till the end of time. They would do more for there people then Nerevar or the Empire ever could.
This argument contradicts itself, because if the Tribunal cared so much about its people and acted in nothing but fear, why would they off Nerevar (the person who literally just saved the Dunmer) and insult one of their gods to do so? Heck, turn Nerevar immortal if you're so scared for the Dunmer. Nerevar was a mortal mer because he was murdered, murdered because he knew how bad of an idea it was to set oneself up as a god. The Tribunal did it anyway and got their own people charred forever. Vivic, Sotha Sil, and Almalaxia took the power of the Heart for themselves in cold blood and doused their race into an era of drama and controversy. The Heart's power is great, but comes with a greater price. They paid that price with the welfare of their people. Morrowind got a hefty sum in return for an even heftier cost.
"I see," said the blind man.

98% of forumers say fast travel ruins Oblivion. Put this in your signature if you're one of the 2% who realize it's optional.
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Dean »

Backfire wrote: The Heart destroyed a whole race, like, in an instant. The Heart is incomprehensibly dangerous, and for the Tribunal to use it so carelessly and selfishly as they did (in the eyes of Azura, at least) is simply indescribably ignorant and arrogant. I can see Azura being so p**sed off that she felt like she had to do something. Messing with the Heart like they did earns something so rash as what Azura did.
It didn't necessary cause the Dwemer to be destroyed, I for one think they reached a sort of godly level and where teleported to some realm on another distant plane. Of course everyone who knows about the Dwemer has different views on there 'disappearance'.
I honestly don't think Azura should have cursed the entire race, if she had such a bone to pick with these three, she should of dealt with them and them alone.
Backfire wrote:What power are you talking about? If it's how the Tribunal became the leading religion in Morrowind, taking Azura out of the picture, then I'd doubt that it's selfish greed rather than avenging a personal and inhumane insult. Azura is smart, for sure, but I can't see her coming up with such an elaborate plan as you propose simply in the name of greed. Find me a wiki page and I'll believe what you're saying, but until we can get some written proof, our reasoning behind her actions are only speculation.
The power through worship, what is a god without worshippers exactly? Gods are generally there to be worshipped in some form or manor. Azura had temples built for her so she is not excluded.
You should realise that the wiki doesn't contain theories and the sort. No one knows the facts for sure and each one of our guesses are exactly that, 'Guesses'. It would be impossible for me to give you one page when there are like 300 books of lore containing tiny snipets of information, it is up to us to piece them together and believe what we will and to make our own assumptions.
Newsound wrote:What is the one thing that would really annoy a God? normal people turning into divine beings(the Dwemer in this case).
Backfire wrote:Again, it's a good argument, but I haven't seen any evidence as to this being true.
What about Sheogorath? he was turned from Jyggalag into his state now because the other Daedra got jealous of the power he had. Daedra are as petty as humans, and just as greedy.
Backfire wrote:House Hlaalu knows how to win / not lose. I won't put the blame on them, nor find any fault in them, if they act based on what's best for themselves, not what's best for principle. It might not be the most honorable thing to do, but it's a dog-eat-dog world.
Exactly, that is why I have no love for them. I would choose a more respectable path then one of greed and shame, I don't care if the rest of the world does something. I will never go against my beliefs or try to profit of something like people invading my country, just isn't right in my eyes.
Backfire wrote:This argument contradicts itself, because if the Tribunal cared so much about its people and acted in nothing but fear, why would they off Nerevar (the person who literally just saved the Dunmer) and insult one of their gods to do so? Heck, turn Nerevar immortal if you're so scared for the Dunmer. Nerevar was a mortal mer because he was murdered, murdered because he knew how bad of an idea it was to set oneself up as a god.
There was not a single contradiction in my post, I don't believe that the Tribunal murdered Nerevar at all. I think he just died from being mortally wounded after the big fight with Dumac Dwarf-king and Dagoth Ur. Azura didn't know what was happening until she was summoned after the battle by the Tribunal so she saw the body of Nerevar and went ape-[&@%!], in my opinion.
Backfire wrote:The Heart's power is great, but comes with a greater price. They paid that price with the welfare of their people. Morrowind got a hefty sum in return for an even heftier cost.
Would you choose the power of three divine-kings to protect your country or one Chimeri hero? The welfare of there people was lifted with the creation of the Tribunal, I don't think Nerevar could of defended his country from Invasions by the Nords after the 'loss' of the Dwemer. It was only when they teamed together that they where able to destroy them. You have to realise that the Chimeri where very few in number at this time.

And also, to say that Dunmer where weakened would be a personal decision. The Chimeri where 'exactly' the same as the Altmer at that time (Altmer weren't as gold but time changes things) and they where simply transformed to a darker skinned version.
lonely_wolf
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 26
Joined: Sat Jul 17, 2010 7:15 pm

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by lonely_wolf »

I lead all you, already killed EACH AND EVERYONE in morrowind in a boring weekend (of course with console codes) IM THE KING OF THE WORLD!!! (well really just king of Vvanderfell and Mournhold) LOL

Then loaded pre-saved game
THE HIGHLIGHT OF MY LIFE: Moooooooooom! I just killed 6 Cliff Racers without cheats!!
Backfire
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 152
Joined: Sun Jul 18, 2010 7:36 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: XBox / XBox 360
Status: yes
Location: look behind you

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Backfire »

It didn't necessary cause the Dwemer to be destroyed, I for one think they reached a sort of godly level and where teleported to some realm on another distant plane.
It did, at least, take a complete race off the face of the map (actually using that literally here) in a matter of seconds. Even if it did nothing but transport them, that power's too much for anyone one to handle without tremendous risk.
The power through worship, what is a god without worshippers exactly?
They're still a "god", that doesn't change. They may not be happy, but it's not like they melt and die if there's nobody worshiping them.
What about Sheogorath? he was turned from Jyggalag into his state now because the other Daedra got jealous of the power he had. Daedra are as petty as humans, and just as greedy.
I'm talking specifically about Azura, whether or not it was the Dwemer's pseudo-devine status or if it's just her concern for humanity that cause her to rat the Dwemer out.
Exactly, that is why I have no love for them. I would choose a more respectable path then one of greed and shame, I don't care if the rest of the world does something. I will never go against my beliefs or try to profit of something like people invading my country, just isn't right in my eyes.
If the "more respectable path" got you and your family killed, threatened, or harmed; then I can understand why some choose to side with the Empire. You can stand for whatever principle that you'd like, but if in the end your worse off, that principle doesn't seem to be doing its job. Pragmatism is that on which the Hlaalu are based, and the pragmatic solution was to ally themselves with the winning side. I won't necessarily say "good for them" for selling their homeland out, but I'm not going to blame them for not effectively committing suicide by standing against such an army either.
Azura didn't know what was happening until she was summoned after the battle by the Tribunal so she saw the body of Nerevar and went ape-[&@%!], in my opinion.
I highly doubt that god so powerful that she can change an entire race at her whim and lead the Nerevarine to complete the prophecies couldn't witness such a historical moment happen. Her eyes were glued to Red Mountain that day.
Would you choose the power of three divine-kings to protect your country or one Chimeri hero?
No matter how you look at it, the Tribunal used the Heart of Lorkhan. Period. Look at the Dwemer and Dagoth Ur. If they have the potential to do the things that those two did, they're more dangerous than anything. I don't know how they haven't been corrupted yet, and they have done some miraculous things during their reign, but using the Heart like they did is unacceptable. They made themselves gods but also risked the contamination of their mind, and that s**t could have gone bad. Remember that nobody should have been a god-king in the first place, that the bouts that the Dunmer had to face should have been met by mortal generals, not blaspheming elves who though it suitable to take over the job for the Daedra. We also can't really say how good Nerevar would have been in comparison to the Tribunal; he died early and would never have used the Heart. Remember that Nerevar was b.a. and witty. He'd have figured something out (not to mention that he had Azura's support, something that we can't say about the Tribunal).
And also, to say that Dunmer where weakened would be a personal decision. The Chimeri where 'exactly' the same as the Altmer at that time (Altmer weren't as gold but time changes things) and they where simply transformed to a darker skinned version.
Azura cursing them to begin with sure isn't helping the Tribunal's case, and I can't see the creation of the Dunmer helping their race. Again, either way that you dissect it, they got off on the wrong foot.
"I see," said the blind man.

98% of forumers say fast travel ruins Oblivion. Put this in your signature if you're one of the 2% who realize it's optional.
XPviper
Layman
Layman
Posts: 6
Joined: Tue Jul 20, 2010 4:40 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
Status: Creeping
Location: Lithuania

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by XPviper »

There was not a single contradiction in my post, I don't believe that the Tribunal murdered Nerevar at all. I think he just died from being mortally wounded after the big fight with Dumac Dwarf-king and Dagoth Ur. Azura didn't know what was happening until she was summoned after the battle by the Tribunal so she saw the body of Nerevar and went ape-[&@%!], in my opinion.
Well, this is just a game! And because of that, if there is mentioning of something more interesting, compromising sb and not "official" in that world, 99% that it is true. And don't say that it is Tribunal opponents propaganda, because it's not. Tribunal killed Lord Nerevar. Also, I don't think, that god, who can make entire race look different than they were, could not know what is going and curse entire race because of that.
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Dean »

XPviper wrote:Well, this is just a game! And because of that, if there is mentioning of something more interesting, compromising sb and not "official" in that world, 99% that it is true. And don't say that it is Tribunal opponents propaganda, because it's not. Tribunal killed Lord Nerevar. Also, I don't think, that god, who can make entire race look different than they were, could not know what is going and curse entire race because of that.
Mate this is more to do with you opinion, so what if it is just a game I like to discuss things on an Elder Scrolls site about...well Elder Scrolls funnily.

What are your reasons why it can't be Tribunal opponent propaganda? Morrowind's lore happens to be very involved and dark, just like the real world. Besides there are like four different versions of the story.

I'm not saying it is impossible she couldn't see everything, but I would think a Daedra god like herself would have other thing's to do aswell then pay 100% attention to every single thing that is going on, if the Daedra where so powerful in the mortal realm she would be able to do the quests herself and also Daedra like Hircine would be pretty much invincible.

Azura only bothered to respond AFTER the battle when she was summoned using a ritual. Yet she managed to appear after you defeat Dagoth Ur on her own, funny that no? looks like she wasn't paying much attention after all. :P
User avatar
Goblin voice
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 268
Joined: Mon Jul 26, 2010 1:21 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Morrowind GOTY, Skyrim
Platform: PC, Xbox
Status: sort of transparent...
Location: Sweden
Contact:

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Goblin voice »

Backfire wrote:
The power through worship, what is a god without worshippers exactly?
They're still a "god", that doesn't change. They may not be happy, but it's not like they melt and die if there's nobody worshiping them.
Well... if they have no one worshiping them, they just as well might... (melt and die) I mean... it could get kind of... dull... you know... as a god not being able to bully anyone around since no one care about your existance...
För kriget det kan, Förgöra en man
Jag ger mitt liv för mitt fosterland
Men vem saknar mig?
Så se mig som den, En make en vän
Fader och son som aldrig kommer hem
Men vem sörjer mig?

~Make Peace Not War.
User avatar
Bladecutter
Novice
Novice
Posts: 55
Joined: Wed Jul 28, 2010 4:13 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Bloodmoon, Tribunal, Oblivion, Knights of the Nine, Shivering Isles, Arena, Daggerfall
Platform: PC, Xbox 360
Location: Orlando, FL

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Bladecutter »

Goblin voice wrote:
Backfire wrote:
The power through worship, what is a god without worshippers exactly?
They're still a "god", that doesn't change. They may not be happy, but it's not like they melt and die if there's nobody worshiping them.
Well... if they have no one worshiping them, they just as well might... (melt and die) I mean... it could get kind of... dull... you know... as a god not being able to bully anyone around since no one care about your existance...
It's actually pretty plausible that a God loses their powers if nobody has faith in them. That's how it worked in D&D, Gods die and fade away if people no longer worship them. It may or may not work that way in Morrowind since Almsivi gained their divinity through The Heart of Lorkhan (Sp?) and I have no idea about the Nine or Daedra Lords.
Image
Backfire
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 152
Joined: Sun Jul 18, 2010 7:36 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: XBox / XBox 360
Status: yes
Location: look behind you

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Backfire »

I doubt that Azura would have "better" things to do than watch the battle of Red Mountain. That'd be like Eisenhouer having "better things to do" than give the speech prior to Operation Overlord, it wasn't a battle, it was the battle.

Also, I don't ever remember reading anything that said that Azura was "summoned" as opposed to "appeared out of her own will".
"I see," said the blind man.

98% of forumers say fast travel ruins Oblivion. Put this in your signature if you're one of the 2% who realize it's optional.
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Dean »

Backfire wrote:I doubt that Azura would have "better" things to do than watch the battle of Red Mountain. That'd be like Eisenhouer having "better things to do" than give the speech prior to Operation Overlord, it wasn't a battle, it was the battle.

Also, I don't ever remember reading anything that said that Azura was "summoned" as opposed to "appeared out of her own will".
Alright, maybe better wasn't the right word to use but she is a rather busy gal after all. The Dunmer aren't technically the only people that worship and summon Azura, lot's of the other races see her as a major god. All I'm saying is that she has more to do then one battle.

And the last bit about the 'summoned' or 'appeared out of her own will' happen to both be mentioned in Lore, I don't quite remember which books/documents they are on but they are two of the many ideas mentioned.
User avatar
MurtaghSpector563
Novice
Novice
Posts: 82
Joined: Sat Jul 31, 2010 3:48 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, (briefly) Oblivion
Platform: (Morrowind)PC, (Oblivion)PS3

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by MurtaghSpector563 »

Everyone here has violated the law. Pay 20000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 septims each.

Pay Gold
Go to Jail
Resist Arrest
User avatar
RobotNixon
Warder
Warder
Posts: 507
Joined: Sat Oct 03, 2009 6:16 am
ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Battlespire, Morrowind, Tribunal, Bloodmoon, Oblivion, Knights of The Nine, Shivering Isles, Skyrim, Dawnguard, Dragonborn, Elder Scrolls Online
Platform: PC
Status: Just came back, from outer space.
Other Profiles: AdultPuppetShow
Location: Space Texas

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by RobotNixon »

MurtaghSpector563 wrote:Everyone here has violated the law. Pay 20000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 septims each.

Pay Gold
Go to Jail
Resist Arrest
Stifle it you criminal scum.

I'll have your head for impersonating an officer of Imperial Law.
Count to four. Inhale. Count to four. Exhale.
User avatar
MurtaghSpector563
Novice
Novice
Posts: 82
Joined: Sat Jul 31, 2010 3:48 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, (briefly) Oblivion
Platform: (Morrowind)PC, (Oblivion)PS3

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by MurtaghSpector563 »

THEN PAY WITH YOUR BLOOD!
(ten identical versions of me appear out of nowhere and start poking you with spears)
Leilah
Master
Master
Posts: 1116
Joined: Sun Mar 08, 2009 12:25 pm

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Leilah »

People, please stay on-topic. One more off-topic response and I may have to lock this, which I don't want to do since this thread was started precisely to encourage intelligent conversation in the Morrowind forum. So please. If there's nothing to be said that's on this topic, don't say anything here at all, since we have a thread for that in General Banter.
User avatar
Goblin voice
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 268
Joined: Mon Jul 26, 2010 1:21 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Morrowind GOTY, Skyrim
Platform: PC, Xbox
Status: sort of transparent...
Location: Sweden
Contact:

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Goblin voice »

Bladecutter wrote: It may or may not work that way in Morrowind since Almsivi gained their divinity through The Heart of Lorkhan (Sp?) and I have no idea about the Nine or Daedra Lords.
Still... it's the faith of the people of Vivec that gives Vivec the power to hold the ministry of truth floating over the city.
And I think that both the Aedra and Daedra are the descendants of earlier gods...
För kriget det kan, Förgöra en man
Jag ger mitt liv för mitt fosterland
Men vem saknar mig?
Så se mig som den, En make en vän
Fader och son som aldrig kommer hem
Men vem sörjer mig?

~Make Peace Not War.
User avatar
Chibimala
Novice
Novice
Posts: 68
Joined: Wed Jul 14, 2010 12:17 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Lost, as usual...
Location: WI

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Chibimala »

Bladecutter wrote:It's actually pretty plausible that a God loses their powers if nobody has faith in them. That's how it worked in D&D, Gods die and fade away if people no longer worship them.
Offtopic: Haven't you ever read Small Gods by Terry Pratchett?? That's exactly how it happens on Discworld too *lol*

Ontopic: Azura, like any Daedra according to most of the lore that I've come across, can appear at will but can be summoned on their holy days by a rite of invocation. And through quests & lore, it's apparant that the strength/belief of their followers is a key factor in their powers. Boethiah asks you to rebuild a shrine, and to get Azura's Star you have to help her settle a bet against Sheogorath. So it seems to me that even though they could do things themselves it is more beneficial to them to get mortals to do it for them. Their strength can be equalled to the devotion and strength of their followers, and when they can get mortals to do their bidding, it's a show of their power.

And as far as taking on Hircine, it's kind of along the same lines as taking out the Almsivi. Although where the Almsivi began as mortal and can obviously be killed, Daedra can only be banished. For them to appear and actively interact with mortals, they would have to assume a mortal form and that form can be destroyed. Of course, you are only destroying the flesh they inhabited, their essence merely returns to their respective plane in Oblivion. An idea on this is that the Daedra can really only appear at will when their strength is boosted by their followers. Hircine doesn't come back (in the Morrowind story that is) after his defeat because the belief structure is broken when he is defeated.

Just my two cents :) Although like Newsound pointed out there's four sides to every story *lol*
God grant me the serenity to not kill anyone today, but if it comes to that grant me the patience to wait until the opportune moment, the strength to transport the body, and the wisdom to hide it where no one will find it...
Locked