Oblivion better then Morrowind?

A place to discuss and ask questions about the third part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions
User avatar
Guy No. 2
Warder
Warder
Posts: 536
Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 9:18 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360, PC.
Status: Lurking....duh-dun....duh-dun...duh duh duh dun du
Location: Here.

Post by Guy No. 2 »

The King wrote:If you like fairy tales, then I cordially invite you to the oblivion experience.If you like a world that is realistic, then welcome to Morrowind.

As someone here once quoted someone else:

Oblivion is a great game but Morrowind is a great world.
In fairness the entire Elder Scrolls series are a bunch of fairy tales.
Didnt Arena involve rescuing an Emperor from a realm called Oblivion?
Didnt Daggerfall involve freeing the spiit of a dead King?
Didnt MW involve becoming +revenging a "God"?
Didnt Ob involve stopping an invasion from another realm??
Also I dont understand all this "realistic" features you have been mentioning. Can you honestly say that you live near an active Volcano with daily sandstorms?
Im still here :)
User avatar
The King
Master
Master
Posts: 1006
Joined: Tue May 20, 2008 1:55 am
ES Games: Obliwind.
Platform: Game Cube 360
Location: Texas

Post by The King »

I mean that the world is harsh and barren, not everything is all lush forests and beautiful rivers, life is harder in Morrowind than Oblivion, you have to work hard, strange beasts are in the land, horrid diseases are everywhere. OB is just too nice, plus Morrowind has more lore than Oblivion, and if you argue about that then your are just stubborn or you haven't played/beat the game.
"I have never killed a man, but I have read many obituaries with great pleasure."- Clarence Darrow

"An eye for an eye only ends up making the whole world blind."- Mohandas Ghandi
Deathmist
Warder
Warder
Posts: 518
Joined: Sat Apr 05, 2008 12:34 am
ES Games: Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC, PS3

Post by Deathmist »

The King wrote:I mean that the world is harsh and barren, not everything is all lush forests and beautiful rivers, life is harder in Morrowind than Oblivion, you have to work hard, strange beasts are in the land, horrid diseases are everywhere. OB is just too nice
A beautiful, rich, stunning world is a good thing to some people and a bad thing to others. If you didn't like it, that's your opinion, if you did like it, that's your opinion. Simple as that.

And despite the landscape, is Oblivion really all that goody-goody? From what I've played in Morrowind, necromancy and vampirism seem to be far more abundant and accepted in Cyrodill than they are in Vvardenfell.

Although I guess that assassination and slavery is commonly accepted in Vvardenfell. :? Still, each game has it's good and bad points.
User avatar
The King
Master
Master
Posts: 1006
Joined: Tue May 20, 2008 1:55 am
ES Games: Obliwind.
Platform: Game Cube 360
Location: Texas

Post by The King »

Ummm, necromancy is illegal in Cyrodil, it is legal in Morrowind, just frowned upon, vampirism isn't accepted in Cyrodil, it's illegal(like Morrowind). The Telvanni are the only ones who don't frown upon it, like the DB, I'm not saying Oblivion is bad it's just not my style of perception,make sense,kind of.
"I have never killed a man, but I have read many obituaries with great pleasure."- Clarence Darrow

"An eye for an eye only ends up making the whole world blind."- Mohandas Ghandi
User avatar
gregor
Champion
Champion
Posts: 806
Joined: Mon May 15, 2006 12:26 pm

Post by gregor »

Optional, optional, optional... there are plenty of things optional in Oblivion, yet everyone uses them. There are no such options in Morrowind.

they limit the game play, making it harder. Oblivion was sold in more pcs than Morrowind. that tells you something. it was more popular. it also tells another thing - people who couldn't play Morrowind could play Oblivion. a lot of kids i knpow played it but not Morrowind. for startes you need to understand English to play Morrowind. being able to solve a few riddles or come up with solutiuons. in Oblivion there would be an arrow showing you where to go - and usually kill someone :lol:

on the topic of landscape. morrowind has grasslands on NE, swamps on W ashlands in center, islands on east and north, fields & farms in SW, icy world with blizzards in NW. that's about it. oh and underground. and the "moon" (converted to prison). oblivion has forest, mediteranean climate like area, mountains, swamps. it's missing out only on deserts & lava which of course can be found in Oblivion worlds. but it does have a paradise. and some strange world (i dont' have it installed) it is also missing out on a few mines. oh and the watters are darker - more muddy or what?!?

And it is true you can quite fast finish all the quests in Oblivion with same character. which is hard to do in Morrowind. i still haven't finish them all. and i had about the same amount of time available for both. Oblivion i already finished most of them. look at the quests pages here on Wiki and you will see why...

anyway i still like Oblivion. i wish they could improve it with a few things. i liek the fast travel option, but i wouldn't need it if the horses would be more efficiant (as in that you could do combat form them...). also there are plenty of other things that bother me a bit. like lack of weapons. and skill. and spells. and master trainers can be killed, but some idiotic villagers can't. but there are things i like. like the AI for exmple.

morrowind isn't bad. it is just old. it has more lore than Oblivion and a lot more missions. it has a problem with fighting system - which can be huge minus for beginners. it also has a problem with spells. you can learn it but you will fail to cast it (WTF!?). but in the end i think it has more to offer than Oblivion. well if you like interesting stories that is. combat and action - i would go for Oblivion on this one. i just wish they would work more on the AI for the next release (if there will ever be one).
User avatar
Dogmantra
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1518
Joined: Fri Mar 21, 2008 6:19 pm
ES Games: Yes
Platform: 9¾ leaving in 5 minutes.
Status: Listening to They Might Be Giants
Location: With Uncle Crassius and the Companion Cube
Contact:

Post by Dogmantra »

gregor wrote:And it is true you can quite fast finish all the quests in Oblivion with same character. which is hard to do in Morrowind.
I hope you're not planning on trying that... it's impossible, 'cause of great houses.
BANG → !
User avatar
Guy No. 2
Warder
Warder
Posts: 536
Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 9:18 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360, PC.
Status: Lurking....duh-dun....duh-dun...duh duh duh dun du
Location: Here.

Post by Guy No. 2 »

Yeah Necromancy was legal in Cyrodiil but illegal in the Mages Guild. Im not exactly sure about MW, but I think it was illegal because of the Ancetor respect thing as said above.
I mean that the world is harsh and barren, not everything is all lush forests and beautiful rivers, life is harder in Morrowind than Oblivion, you have to work hard, strange beasts are in the land, horrid diseases are everywhere. OB is just too nice, plus Morrowind has more lore than Oblivion, and if you argue about that then your are just stubborn or you haven't played/beat the game.
Well the reason it was harsh and barren in MW was because it was: A)It was the type of land in MW and B)it seemed harsh because the graphics were bad or not up to scratch with todays graphics. This may seem obvious but the reason there are lakes and forests in Cyrodiil is because thats is the type of land there. The reason why it so lush and beautiful was because they wanted to make it the best they could (I would imagine).
Again I dont really think you have an argument with the whole starnge beats thing. Oblivion also has it's own share of "Strange beasts".

Plus not everything is "lush forests and beautiful rivers", try going up to Bruma. A area thats is hardly ever not covered in snow for me.
As also said above swampy land can also be found around the river delta.
You can find a bit of everything really.

I will agree with you that Morrowind had much more lore involved in it but is saying that Oblivion does have a fair amount of lore aswell if you were to go looking for it. But that's the thing, if you were to go looking for it. They made looking through the books and learning the history of TES optional unlike Morrowind where you are kind of forced to learn about it. Oblivion is a much more accessible game than MW, Ill give you that, but that is why I prefer it.
Casual and harcore gamers of TES and RPGs in general can play the game. I believe if you love the lore of TES you could be satisfied with Oblivion but if you hate having to learn the lore of TES you could still play the game.
Im still here :)
User avatar
The Raven
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1762
Joined: Fri May 30, 2008 4:09 pm

Post by The Raven »

I kind of prefer Oblivions gameplay for Morrowinds.
Because, you're not destinied to be something special, you are your own, you can do what you want.
Doin my own, thang, and if you got a problem with that
Then the nina go bang, bang, and I'll be everywhere on the map - but
I rep that West
User avatar
Jeff
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 4680
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 2:35 pm
Status: Gone

Post by Jeff »

Dogmantra wrote:How? Is it a mod?
There are mods, and also the Console, or .ini file, depending on what you want to do. The console command tm toggles the HUD on & off.

Well, I just haven't seen you (or myself) saying something good about the game we don't like as much... although, after playing oblivion quite a lot, it did give me the feeling that Morrowind is sort of empty...
Most pro's & con's about MW & OB are Opinions. Which I tend to stay away from on most forums. Unfortunately, the few times I do make comments, it is in reply to others, and it is not my opinion, but to make a point how poorly others are acting. This is actualy the first time I made a comment pointing out the bad points of Morrowind. Previous comments were pointing out the bad points of the people complaining about Oblivion. As stated in the last Oblivion Forum topic, it bothered me that people found it helpful to post in the Oblivion Forum, how they "thought" MW was better than OB.

I am not saying people can not have opinions. However, it is how they voice those opinions. You don't have to insult the Game, or the People who play that game.

This is the Unofficial Elder Scrolls Forum, not the Morrowind is better than Oblivion Forums, or the other way around.

The last three topics I replied to in this forum was to point out the Wiki Articles, for people switching from OB to MW, so that it can help them enjoy MW.
"à tout le monde, à tous mes amis, je vous aime, je dois partir"
User avatar
gregor
Champion
Champion
Posts: 806
Joined: Mon May 15, 2006 12:26 pm

Post by gregor »

Dogmantra wrote:
gregor wrote:And it is true you can quite fast finish all the quests in Oblivion with same character. which is hard to do in Morrowind.
I hope you're not planning on trying that... it's impossible, 'cause of great houses.
not only that, but also you can't progress in mage guild unless you are skilled in magic. so it's difficult to do it with same character. that's why i have different ones.


@ The Raven - you are not destined to do anything in Morrowind. in fact you can drop the imperial papers in the nearest basket.

in the end of the game i was sure my character is not Nerevar or his reincarnation. but he did kill the vampire to stop the ash storms. i have plenty of characters that tollerate dagoth ur. wish i could join him. IMO he is doing the right thing, but in a wrong way.

then again i have character that joined the legion and temple and dislikes the ashland tribes. never got to play the main quest with him. but i added him in all major fighting faction and imperial ones. even built a colony to annoy the "native" Nords.

i expected Oblivion to expand the factions. but i guess developemnt was somewhat limited by time. still like i said before game seems OK to me. in some things it is even better, some things i hate (like leveling enemies).

But Morrowind still has more things to do. at least for me.
User avatar
The Raven
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1762
Joined: Fri May 30, 2008 4:09 pm

Post by The Raven »

I know that you're not destinied, but you're still the Nerevarine no matter what.
The main quest, just proofs it to you, that you're infact the Nerevarine, reincarnation of Nerevar.
I also better like Morrowinds Guild system, that you have to be good in Magic/Stealth/Combat to get a promotion, so a pure stealth character dont just suddently become the leader of the fighters/mages guild.
Or a pure mage become the leader of the Imperial Legion/Morag Tong/Theives guild.
In my opinion, the devplovers were a little slacky in the creation of Oblivion.
Doin my own, thang, and if you got a problem with that
Then the nina go bang, bang, and I'll be everywhere on the map - but
I rep that West
User avatar
Jeff
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 4680
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 2:35 pm
Status: Gone

Post by Jeff »

KJR1012 wrote:Go ahead and play. Then you can answer the topic's title question for yourself. It's a subjective issue, not an objective one.

We can't really do that for you; some folks think MW is better, some think OB is better. Others like them both the same.
This is actually my stance on OB v.s. MW. I don't comment that much in the MW forum, since I have not played it in two years. Plus, with Rohugh the All Knowing around, whats the real point... :P

I actually made my comment for two reasons:

1.) The topic started out fine, then a certain comment lead to an (in my opinion) inapproprate comment, and with the pack mentality, would have lead to even more. People tend to like to jump on the bandwagon, once it shows up.

2.) The topic got hijacked with a joke. The joke was fine, but it lead to the hijack of the topic. ...so it was also an attempt to get it back on topic.
"à tout le monde, à tous mes amis, je vous aime, je dois partir"
User avatar
Dogmantra
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1518
Joined: Fri Mar 21, 2008 6:19 pm
ES Games: Yes
Platform: 9¾ leaving in 5 minutes.
Status: Listening to They Might Be Giants
Location: With Uncle Crassius and the Companion Cube
Contact:

Post by Dogmantra »

The Raven wrote:I know that you're not destinied, but you're still the Nerevarine no matter what.
Hmm... I never once with all one of my characters that's actually done the main quest believed I was the nerevarine... I just sort of thought it was something that must be done
BANG → !
Lord Voldemort
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 162
Joined: Sun Apr 08, 2007 9:30 pm
ES Games: Morrowind
Platform: PC
Location: Hogwarts, playing Morrowind

Post by Lord Voldemort »

I think some of us are getting a bit touchy over their favorite games...
Personally I prefer Morrowind, but I have no trouble in playing Oblivion.
Last edited by Lord Voldemort on Mon Jul 21, 2008 1:58 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Cactus
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1629
Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 12:48 pm

Post by Cactus »

Yknow, I'm currently hooked on Morrowind. I pretty much play constantly, all the time, every day for hours. I'm finally getting to the point where I can stop for a while (hence my currently posting). I've been playing for weeks and weeks, and I have Metal Gear Solid IV sitting unused next to my PS3 where it has been since I got it because Morrowind is so awesome.

When I first bought Oblivion I was hooked. I pretty much played constantly, all the time, every day for hours. I finally got to the point where I could stop for a while (hence my being able to join these forums in the first place). I played for months and months, new game after new game while several newer "better" games often sat unused because Oblivion is so awesome.

That's my comparison of the two games. Should be obvious of my opinion of the the games individually and compared to each other. I'm sure once I get sick of Morrowind, play MGS IV, eventually buy and play through a few other games coming out in September I really want, I'll pop in Oblivion and spend a few weeks playing some random skill mix character, then I'll try a new character-type in Morrowind and play through Telvanni, the only house I haven't joined (I lost my save games with my Redoran character when I went from vanilla Morrowind to GOTY edition, so now I'm playing Hlaalu) and try going through the Imperial Cult, Thieves Guild, and other factions I haven't played in these first two games. My biggest complaint about Oblivion is actually that I know it inside and out. The only reason it's so easy is because I've played every quest in the game a half-dozen times (well, except a couple I don't like which I've mostly done once each).

In conclusion, I know I seemed to join the complainers when I first started playing, but that was just because it was fresh in my mind and I was excited to have a new awesome game with lots to explore and being able to do missions I didn't have every possible ending memorized. It's nice having quests where I have no idea what my next choice is going to have. Eventually it's going to be just like Oblivion and I'll have the game and its quests memorized. Until then I'll be leaning towards Morrowind as my "favorite." Once I learn this game two, I imagine I'll have a nice tie as favorite. Of course, none of this matters: my favorite game series is actually Destroy All Humans. :Twisted Evil:
New sequel (Destroy All Humans! Path of the Furon) hits stores September 15th (19th in Europe)!! I'll be on vacation.

[/two cents]
User avatar
The Tourist
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 325
Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2008 4:44 am

Post by The Tourist »

Don't jump ship Cactus! Stay with the chosen few! Don't question your belief just yet! :D

On a serious-ish note: maybe if you played the game less frequently, you'd sustain your enjoyment. I've had Morrowind since it came out, and I've still never finished the Telvanni, Mages, Thieves Guild, or the Temple (and only last year did I complete Mournhold). Though I never strictly 100% RP'd characters in MW, I stuck to what I enjoyed - sword-swinging warrior archetypes of various forms.

I didn't play through MW just because it was a game and I wanted to see all angles of it; MW is infinitely superior to Ob in that it gives you a far broader palette of choices to work with. Ob is vapidly dualistic - right and wrong, and the superficalities of non-existant good and evil - Morrowind caters for the 'greys', the inbetweens, the moral complexity of human nature.

I picked and chose in MW because I could - In Ob, there is hardly any choice, so limited are the guilds and the empty headed main quest. And as the land and people have almost no variety, I couldn't care less about their chocolate-box, eastern European cod-medieval 'culture', with its abject lack of polity, strife, or tension. Vvardenfell feels like a land in turmoil, and the metaphor is presented via the actual geography and topography. Oblivion can't even cobble together a narrative, let alone mythic metaphors that stretch deep into the actual environ of the gameworld.

[ I'll either post again later this evening, or edit this one, but there's a couple of things that have been said, which I want to respond to directly (i'll try my very hardest to keep things brief... ) ]
[ data pending ]
Cactus
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1629
Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 12:48 pm

Post by Cactus »

The Tourist wrote:Don't jump ship Cactus! Stay with the chosen few! Don't question your belief just yet! :D
...
Shh... it's all a cover.

I would love to play less, but I can't. It's like a narcotic. I mean, I'm not RPing, but I'm staying vaguely in-character. I'm playing a warrior type, so I'm sticking with stuff that fits. I'm avoiding Thieves Guild, Cult, etc. I was actually going to avoid Mages Guild to begin with; I only joined for some brief disposition points and to maybe do a random quest here and there, but then I got caught up doing dwemer quests because I personally find that whole thing interesting, and I ended up becoming Arch-Mage. I'm not "done" yet, I've still got a couple quests in the Wolverine Hall and I haven't done more than gotten a journal entry for the Khajiit (can't remember her name) in Balmora. As for the main quest, I've been playing all these weeks and today just before I shut the 360 off I cured my corpus. I mean, I play a lot, but I'm taking my time. I usually only end up doing two or three quests a day (depending on length, sometimes one or less) because I tend to get easily side tracked by random dungeons and getting curious where different roads go and whatnot. Today I spent over an hour doing a simple delivery quest because I heard a rumor about a guy in Hla Oad and dwemer artifacts, so I searched his place before finding an entire cavern of Camonna Tong hidden beneath through a trap door. That was interesting, to be sure.
User avatar
The Raven
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1762
Joined: Fri May 30, 2008 4:09 pm

Post by The Raven »

I wish i had it like you, i mean the adventure lust.
Im like, finish my quests, get a reward, find a new quest etc. etc.
I really cant be bothered to go dungeon diving, because why go in a cave, for really no reason?
But im thinking of starting a Khajiit Rogue/Theif(Just deleted my lvl 15 Nord Warrior)and completing the whole MQ +Theives and Morag Tong, maybe some dungeon diving too.
Doin my own, thang, and if you got a problem with that
Then the nina go bang, bang, and I'll be everywhere on the map - but
I rep that West
Cactus
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1629
Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 12:48 pm

Post by Cactus »

It's actually weird, that. In Oblivion that's how I was. I think I went through about five random dungeons that I didn't have a specific quest-related goal for. The only reason I went into the Ayleid ruin across from the sewers exit is because I found out it had the Ayleid statue in it. Before that I never went in there, then afterwards I started doing it first thing, every game because I always imagined I'd do that huge quest a second time. In ever did. :?
User avatar
The Most Unholy
Warder
Warder
Posts: 437
Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 3:19 am
Status: Spreading the Thermodynamics

Post by The Most Unholy »

I have also had this game for quite some time and have yet to do the thieves, fighters, and mages guilds, redoran, temple, and many miscellaneous quests. The game itself is, indeed, much better than oblivion in many ways. This game is not, like tourist said, about good and evil. Its what you will do, and what you want to do, rather than what you will and what you won't do. This game has very many choices, the people are extremely diverse, and the land itself is amazing, simply stunning, not in looks but in the way everything is. It all works, the land is not some large grassy field with some mountains and trees, as in oblivion, but a land with actual depth. This place seems like it, at any instant could simply fall apart. And the lore is not just a bunch of books but an actual history of Vvardenfell as though written by real people, with conflicting accounts and missing pieces.

The game is amazing, the choices you make can affect later on things unlike in oblivion you're choices are few to none. The complexity of the game makes it what it is in my opinion. Oblivion, is just do this and that, nothing more.
Lieutenant of DHC. UESP Rock Star.
User avatar
The Raven
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1762
Joined: Fri May 30, 2008 4:09 pm

Post by The Raven »

I feel that Oblivion is easier to roleplay than Morrowind is because.

In Oblivion, you're not destinied to be someone(Morrowind, Nerevarine) or something, as i have said in various other posts: You are your own.

In Morrowind, you can still Roleplay, but however, you are destinied to be the Nerevarine. You can still choose not to do anything about it, however, you're still the Nerevarine, the main quest just prooves it.

Not that i roleplay that much, but still.

I also better like Morrowinds Mercantile System, but i still better like Oblivion's speechcraft system.

All in all, i like both games, but for good gameplay, lore/history then Morrowind wins.
But for also ok gameplay, easier roleplay, better graphics, then Oblivion wins.
So i dont like one game better than the other, but i still like some things in Morrowind better than Oblivion, or the other way around.

As King said, i hope i dont become like you Tourist :D. No offense though :)
Doin my own, thang, and if you got a problem with that
Then the nina go bang, bang, and I'll be everywhere on the map - but
I rep that West
User avatar
Dogmantra
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1518
Joined: Fri Mar 21, 2008 6:19 pm
ES Games: Yes
Platform: 9¾ leaving in 5 minutes.
Status: Listening to They Might Be Giants
Location: With Uncle Crassius and the Companion Cube
Contact:

Post by Dogmantra »

The Raven wrote:however, you are destinied to be the Nerevarine. You can still choose not to do anything about it, however, you're still the Nerevarine, the main quest just prooves it.
Now that's a little like saying: "I'm destined to be run over by a car, because it might happen to someone." well, completely ignore the main quest and you're not the Nerevarine, sure, you're a super-powerful demi-god, but not the Nerevarine just because some of your characters are the Nerevarine (one in my case, my other MQ char doesn't believe in that) doesn't mean all of them are. In any case, you can decide what you want to be in both games.
BANG → !
User avatar
gregor
Champion
Champion
Posts: 806
Joined: Mon May 15, 2006 12:26 pm

Post by gregor »

Dogmantra wrote:
The Raven wrote:I know that you're not destinied, but you're still the Nerevarine no matter what.
Hmm... I never once with all one of my characters that's actually done the main quest believed I was the nerevarine... I just sort of thought it was something that must be done
well that's juts it. you are proclaimed to be reincarnation of lord Nerevar. You certainly seem strong, wise etc. enough to be him. but, are you really him? Or just a guy/girl who has powers.

if you were the nerevar, then why would all the quests be necessary? like joining the houses etc.?!? i mean you could join them just as well if you were just a dude.
Cactus
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1629
Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 12:48 pm

Post by Cactus »

gregor wrote:i mean you could join them just as well if you were just a dude.
Not to mention you pretty much bribe/cheat/kill your way into all of them.

The only divine point is that Azura is pretty much "You're totally like, the Nerevarine and stuff. Totally." That's an exact quote by the way. Of course, she's a Daedric Prince, so it's difficult to determine how much that's affected by truth or simply her personal vendetta.

The whole problem with prophecies, especially old ones, is that they're vague (just read them all from Morrowind) and chances are eventually SOMETHING is going to happen that appears to meet it, and everyone's going to jump all over it proclaiming it as truth. Furthermore, is it really prophetic if you're only doing these things because the prophecy told you to? That's a bit paradoxical, if you ask me. It's not a prediction if you're just reading a script. That's like calling screenwriters psychic because everything they write later happens to one degree or another. I mean, hell, part of the prophecy is skippable if you've high enough level and reputation. Kinda goes against the grain of a prophecy if you can skip parts legitimately.

Is the playable character the reincarnation of the Nerevar? That's up to you decide, which is the beauty of the game. Maybe you're not and you're just playing along for fortune and fame. Maybe you're not, and you're just doing what you feel is necessary to save the land. Or maybe you are, and it's all destiny and you ARE just acting out a script written long ago by those far older and more powerful than anyone else.
User avatar
The Tourist
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 325
Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2008 4:44 am

Post by The Tourist »

Jeff; yes, Oblivion and Morrowind are two different games. Here's another [abstract] case study of two 'different' things: a ride in a topless Lambo Murcielago, with Scarlett Johansson as a passenger - and someone throwing a brick into the back of your head as you walk down the street...

Two different things. One good, one bad. 'Different' isn't always relative/subjective.

Why do people care so much about Morrowind? All I can do is speak for myself, so: I didn't buy Oblivion hoping Vivec would turn up, or that Cyrodiil would secretly give passage to Vvardenfell in hi-def, in a reprise in which I was allowed to either join with Dagoth Ur, or use nothing but Speechcraft and a 300,000g bribe to convince the mighty Sharmat to forgoe the Heart, and thus find redemption for the fallen Sixth House. Nor did I expect Jiub to show up as a secret playable character, in which we find out how he came to be on that prison ship beside the Nerevarine. Nor did I believe I'd get to continue my gamesave, and save Cyrodiil by leading my band of fellow Nords from Solstheim into Mankar's Paradise.

However, nor did I expect less guilds, a less involved main quest, a lack of lore, an absence of narrative, a levelling system that didn't reward you (a FUNDAMENTAL failing of an RPG), or a one-note landscape in which a patronisingly delineated map/town/compass combo took away any and all sense of exploration - something I had become accustomed to across close to a thousand hours of merrily wandering the diverse landscape of Vvardenfell, Solstheim, and the catacombs of Mournhold, and still not getting close to 'completing' the game.

Betrayed by NoOBZz!!!!
I came to Oblivion with a completely open mind, ready and eager to dive into a rich world as I had done in Morrowind. I didn't have expectations, I just had an immensely rewarding memory bank of experience in Morrowind. But I found nothing to connect to, no effort required, no thought, no choices, no character; neither could I escape the constant handholding, telling me where to go and how to get there, and never once allowing me, the gamer, to use my own nous and knowledge of the land to reach my goal.

In Morrowind's place was a brash, colourful world with less things to do, less skills, less everything.

Tell me, how could I feel anything but utterly let down and disappointed? Where once I mulled over the mysteries of Red Mountain and the nature of self-identity in the context of fate and history - seeing humanities failings and weaknesses writ large for the first time in an epic fantasy game - now I was a no-mark, or an empty headed puppet dancing to everybody elses tune, and a final 'victory' was taken by Sean-bloody-Bean and a character called MARTIN.

My First TES
People coming to TES via Oblivion know nothing else, they haven't seen the potential depth of a first-person RPG. People coming to Oblivion via Morrowind, saw something they care deeply for dismantled and repackaged for the benefit of an easy sell. This could explain the reaction, and the differences, in how their respective players view the two games, and specifically how some 'Morrowinners' could react with such potential hostility. To me that makes perfect sense.

It's not good to berate the Oblivionites on the Ob board, and I no longer do so in any way, but Jeff, I believe those who came to Oblivion from Morrowind - and saw a game with undeniably less content and depth - have cause to get a little peeved.

Coda - 'don't get me wrong....'
....it's still a hugely enjoyable game. It is the current TES, after all, which means it's the premier open world first-person RPG - no game does it better. However, the only motivation I have to return to the patronisingly pristine, indentikit world of Cyrodiil is to finish off a few Achievement's on the game.

Morrowind is a living breathing world of history, myth, culture, choice and a game of fond memories that I'll cherish until I give up gaming.
Oblivion is just 150 more gamerscore points.
[ data pending ]
Locked