Romance & frendships comfirmed?

Pre-Release Archive

Moderator: Tea Party Mods

User avatar
Sloady
Warder
Warder
Posts: 589
Joined: Sat Apr 23, 2011 8:50 pm
ES Games: Daggerfall, Oblivion, Shivering Isles, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Status: AFK since 2011

Re: Romance & frendships comfirmed?

Post by Sloady »

"Honey! Where'd I leave my sword!" "It's on the side!" "For [&@%!]" *blows away half the house by shouting* "...sake?"
Could prove problematic.
I'm on a rollercoaster that only goes up
Chaos the N'wah wrote:TRAMPY!
Founding member of the Weasel Forums Universe
User avatar
Stendarr
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 27
Joined: Wed May 26, 2010 2:55 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: Xbox 360
Status: Monster of the Earth
Location: Heavy Metal Mountain

Re: Romance & frendships comfirmed?

Post by Stendarr »

TheNightFather wrote:
Stendarr wrote:I mean, sure I can appreciate well written characters, but on a level which I want my character to romance another one? Impossible for me. Anyway, I don't play games to do something I can easily do in real life. Plus, Elder Scrolls characters are never as fleshed out as say in Mass Effect (games which the romances were handled very poorly, particularly 2), as we already know some of them will barely say anything. Anyway, I will steer clear of this, it's pretty much only a weak gimmick to me; it's unimportant and doesn't add anything significant or worthwhile except exchanging pretty words with a character made out of pixel from the imagination of a designer, and then seeing or not my character get some awkward - which is an appropriate word for everything involving video game romances - hot action... I see romances as only distracting me from the real deal.
You haven't even played the game (it hasn't even come out) and you're already saying you're going to avoid parts? That's just silly. For all I or you know, marriages could be handled brilliantly - or awful. But we haven't played yet. Nothing is set in stone.
Dude, did you read what I wrote? It is an aspect of RPGs I just don't like, regardless of them being well made or not, which I also talked about them being badly made most of the time. I just can't see the appeal of dating a character made of pixel and pre-determined dialogue, I find it extremely silly to engage in video game romances. That not only I feel it is very awkward, but since it's something I can do in real life - unlike other, more important aspects of the game - I'd rather just do it for real. So no matter if it will actually end up relatively well design, I could care less of such waste of dev time, I'd rather use my gaming time to do something that I can actually find enjoyment from rather than playing a silly gimmicks, this has nothing to do with me having played the game in the first place or not.

Jingles wrote:In game romances that aren't part of an actual main plotline?

WAY too nerdy for my tastes. Sorry. I get enough relationship bother irl, thanks.
This.
Image
User avatar
Haravikk
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 150
Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2011 1:59 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: XBox 360, PC (WINE)

Re: Romance & frendships comfirmed?

Post by Haravikk »

Stendarr wrote:I just can't see the appeal of dating a character made of pixel and pre-determined dialogue, I find it extremely silly to engage in video game romances.
By the same logic; why read a book? It's just words on a page and pre-determined dialogue.
It's all part of making the story seem more real, and allow the player to see the NPC's as something more immersive than a bucket full of quests to do or a store vendor, so that events in the game can actually engage the player to a greater degree.

If you want to play an emotionless loner that sees everyone in the environment as disposable bundles of resources for your whims, then I'm sure you can still play the game that way. But friendships and romances may be useful, or just characterful, or provide more options for those that like to role-play completely, so their character can make friends with people that make sense to, and so-on.

Since Bethesda's games are all about playing your way, then more realistic relationships between the character and the NPC's can go a long way to doing that, by also making the story more their story.

For example; if Whiterun is attacked, then that's going to be a very different experience for a player who hates everyone in Whiterun, to one that's bothered to befriend or romance NPC's there. If those NPC's are in imminent danger than that's not a quest that the player is going to put off, they're going to drop everything to go save those NPC's, whether it's because the dialogue actually endeared them to the characters, or the friendships are beneficial ones, doesn't matter so much, the effect it has on the player does.

Ultimately it's all part of good story-telling, and strong immersion; and calling that nerdy is just insulting.
User avatar
Jingles
Novice
Novice
Posts: 94
Joined: Fri Apr 08, 2011 9:34 pm
ES Games: Skyrim, Morrowind, Daggerfall, Oblivion, Redguard, Arena
Platform: PC

Re: Romance & frendships comfirmed?

Post by Jingles »

Haravikk wrote:By the same logic; why read a book? It's just words on a page and pre-determined dialogue.
Books have plot. Betsy McPixel doesn't. Dating NPCs in video games is self-esteem rock bottom.
Haravikk wrote: and allow the player to see the NPC's as something more immersive than a bucket full of quests to
Yep, they're now bucket fulls of sex cutscenes and meat shields for throwing at dragons. Come on this is Bethesda, the princes of cardboard NPCs. These "friendships" and "romances" are going to be about as meaningful as Fable's. And therin lies the pointlessness of it. Why allow you date pixellated women when you can't even feel attached to their characters in some way. Bioware spend hours and hours of unique dialogue on trying to get players to care about their NPCs, and in the romantic sector it still generally fails to the max. In a sandbox game where you can do this with pretty much every NPC under the sun (I'm assuming) it's going to take a miracle to make it seem believable.
Haravikk wrote:befriend or romance
Man I hate it when people use romance as a verb.
Haravikk wrote:calling that nerdy is just insulting.
I'm sorry, what's NOT nerdy about dating and marrying women that consist of pixels and ones and zeros? Especially when it's not even plot driven.
User avatar
Sloady
Warder
Warder
Posts: 589
Joined: Sat Apr 23, 2011 8:50 pm
ES Games: Daggerfall, Oblivion, Shivering Isles, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Status: AFK since 2011

Re: Romance & frendships comfirmed?

Post by Sloady »

Jingles wrote:
Haravikk wrote:By the same logic; why read a book? It's just words on a page and pre-determined dialogue.
Books have plot. Betsy McPixel doesn't. Dating NPCs in video games is self-esteem rock bottom.
Haravikk wrote: and allow the player to see the NPC's as something more immersive than a bucket full of quests to
Yep, they're now bucket fulls of sex cutscenes and meat shields for throwing at dragons. Come on this is Bethesda, the princes of cardboard NPCs. These "friendships" and "romances" are going to be about as meaningful as Fable's. And therin lies the pointlessness of it. Why allow you date pixellated women when you can't even feel attached to their characters in some way. Bioware spend hours and hours of unique dialogue on trying to get players to care about their NPCs, and in the romantic sector it still generally fails to the max. In a sandbox game where you can do this with pretty much every NPC under the sun (I'm assuming) it's going to take a miracle to make it seem believable.
Haravikk wrote:befriend or romance
Man I hate it when people use romance as a verb.
Haravikk wrote:calling that nerdy is just insulting.
I'm sorry, what's NOT nerdy about dating and marrying women that consist of pixels and ones and zeros? Especially when it's not even plot driven.
*cough* Ahem *cough*

ROLEPLAYING GAME
I'm on a rollercoaster that only goes up
Chaos the N'wah wrote:TRAMPY!
Founding member of the Weasel Forums Universe
User avatar
Samaelthedestroyer
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 177
Joined: Mon Apr 25, 2011 4:00 am
ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC, PS3
Status: Riding space unicorns

Re: Romance & frendships comfirmed?

Post by Samaelthedestroyer »

If you want to because you would like your character to then it's fine, or if you really like the character (like morrigan in dragon age) but i will say that if the line between game and reality get's blurred then you have a problem.
The sad truth is, kids today will never know why pikachu is never inside a pokeball.
User avatar
Haravikk
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 150
Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2011 1:59 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: XBox 360, PC (WINE)

Re: Romance & frendships comfirmed?

Post by Haravikk »

Jingles wrote:Books have plot. Betsy McPixel doesn't.
Games have a plot, and in a game like Skyrim that plot's open-ended to some degree in that no two players are the same, and neither are two play-throughs of the game as a result. Which NPC's you befriend is a good way to make the world feel more like your own. I mean, a common complaint with Oblivion homes is that they're basically just storage receptacles, there's no real other purpose without the ability to have NPC's over to make them feel more like a home.
Jingles wrote:Dating NPCs in video games is self-esteem rock bottom.
Is your default setting to insult anyone that thinks differently from you? Seriously, I'm not sure I've read a single one of your posts that doesn't come across as trolling. If you want to put insults in your posts then here's a tip; don't.
Jingles wrote:Yep, they're now bucket fulls of sex cutscenes. Come on this is Bethesda, the princes of cardboard NPCs.
Anything more suggestive than a shared bed would be unnecessary; the point is to try to build up semi-realistic relationships with the NPC's around your character so that they don't feel like cardboard, and neither does your character. If you don't believe that Bethesda can make better NPC's, then why are you here exactly? It seems like all you want is levitate around Morrowind so why follow Skyrim at all?
Considering how much Bethesda is mentioning Radiant Story, and how much effort I'm sure they've put into it, and the improvements they've already made in the past, I'm inclined to believe that they can come up with a good system. I doubt romancing arbitrary characters is on the cards though, as I'm sure there'll always be characters that just don't get on with the player.
Jingles wrote:Man I hate it when people use romance as a verb.
Was this even worth saying? Dictionaries clearly doesn't share your opinion.
Jingles wrote:I'm sorry, what's NOT nerdy about dating and marrying women that consist of pixels and ones and zeros? Especially when it's not even plot driven.
I'm sorry, what's NOT story driven about NPC interaction in an open-world where you're supposed to be able to be whoever you want to be? Immersion is crucial to a good RPG, and more, varied character interaction is exactly what helps to build it, as there's nothing worse than feeling like you're playing a character that's about as emotionally attached to their surroundings as a plank of wood with a face painted on.
User avatar
Jingles
Novice
Novice
Posts: 94
Joined: Fri Apr 08, 2011 9:34 pm
ES Games: Skyrim, Morrowind, Daggerfall, Oblivion, Redguard, Arena
Platform: PC

Re: Romance & frendships comfirmed?

Post by Jingles »

I mean, a common complaint with Oblivion homes is that they're basically just storage receptacles
Well, that's essentially the only good reason to have a house in a sandbox RPG.
Haravikk wrote:Is your default setting to insult anyone that thinks differently from you? Seriously, I'm not sure I've read a single one of your posts that doesn't come across as trolling. If you want to put insults in your posts then here's a tip; don't.
Fine, don't address the point then. Or perhaps you're avoiding it on purpose...
Haravikk wrote:If you don't believe that Bethesda can make better NPC's, then why are you here exactly?
Because I don't need them to make better NPCs. Duh.
Haravikk wrote: It seems like all you want is levitate around Morrowind so why follow Skyrim at all?
Played all the others to death. Need more elder scrolls fodder.
Haravikk wrote:Was this even worth saying?
Yep.
Haravikk wrote:Dictionaries clearly doesn't share your opinion.
lol so I did make you google it. Nice.
Haravikk wrote:I'm sorry, what's NOT story driven about NPC interaction in an open-world where you're supposed to be able to be whoever you want to be?
I'm sorry, what's NOT nerdy about dating and marrying women that consist of pixels and ones and zeros? You still haven't answered.
Haravikk wrote:there's nothing worse than feeling like you're playing a character that's about as emotionally attached to their surroundings as a plank of wood with a face painted on.
Dude the phone's ringing. Call of Duty wants a word with you. Something about their multi-million dollar success.
User avatar
Arch-Mage Matt
Master
Master
Posts: 1498
Joined: Wed Mar 03, 2010 1:37 am
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Daggerfall
Platform: PC, Xbox
Status: having someone read my status
Location: The Tops Casino
Contact:

Re: Romance & frendships comfirmed?

Post by Arch-Mage Matt »

Hey now gentlemen, stick to the topic here. Only talk about romances and friendships.

Follow an example...
I'm sorry, what's NOT nerdy about dating and marrying women that consist of pixels and ones and zeros? You still haven't answered.
It's all part of the game; part of playing a game. I see it as no different than killing or questing. Take Mass Effect for example, a romance is a large part of the plot. Bioware makes awesome characters. Sure, it could be seen as nerdy... but then again, I could be described as a nerd (Well, loosely of course 8) ). As long as Ms. Pixel isn't the only thing in your life, hey, why not?
Image
Ring-a-ding, baby.
Hi! I am a UESPF Moderator and you can PM me with any concerns you have, no matter how trivial. You can also use the report button - a feature that draws attention to a certain post and allows us to offer our own input.
User avatar
Jake-uh
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 114
Joined: Mon Feb 28, 2011 4:29 am
ES Games: Skyrim, Oblivion, Morrowind, Daggerfall, Arena
Platform: Xbox, Xbox 360, PS3, PC
Status: I'm back on here as a frequent, yay!
Other Profiles: Officerkhajiit(Steam, Xbox live.)
Location: Elma, Washington

Re: Romance & frendships comfirmed?

Post by Jake-uh »

It seems like all you want is levitate around Morrowind so why follow Skyrim at all?
This.
Haravikk, you made my day.
Regards.
User avatar
Haravikk
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 150
Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2011 1:59 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: XBox 360, PC (WINE)

Re: Romance & frendships comfirmed?

Post by Haravikk »

Jingles wrote:Well, that's essentially the only good reason to have a house in a sandbox RPG.
Doesn't mean they need to be, just because you lack the imagination to see other possible uses for a home doesn't mean there aren't any. And NPC's provide quite a lot of opportunity for making them something more by creating shared spaces as opposed to having a whole house to yourself, becoming a base of operations as you build up your own little merry band of allies, and so-on. There are plenty of uses for these spaces, if you bother to look.
Jingles wrote:Fine, don't address the point then.
What point? All you did was accuse people interested in more NPC interaction of being pathetic =/
Jingles wrote:Because I don't need them to make better NPCs. Duh.
You accuse the NPC's of being like cardboard, which implies that they break immersion (a critical element of a good RPG) and yet you don't want them to be improved? If you don't want new games to contain improvements then fine, but the majority of players aren't going to agree with you. These days the good games are the ones that craft really great experiences, and NPC's are a big part of that in a good RPG.
Jingles wrote:lol so I did make you google it. Nice.
Hardly, since I know what the word actually means.
Jingles wrote:I'm sorry, what's NOT nerdy about dating and marrying women that consist of pixels and ones and zeros? You still haven't answered.
If you bothered to read, then I did answer your point, but just to really spell it out for you; you implied that it being nerdy is contingent on it being unnecessary to the plot, and I pointed out that in such a free-form "be what you want to be" environment that NPC interaction of any kind are part of the plot. As I've said several times as well; the more important NPC's are to the player, the more important game events become, by creating a real sense of threat or immediacy.
Otherwise your definition of nerdy is some confusion of the finer points of NPC's being a more important part of the character's personal story, and someone with terminal loneliness using the events of a game as a substitute for real life, which just ends up making insulting implications to everyone.
Jingles wrote:Dude the phone's ringing. Call of Duty wants a word with you. Something about their multi-million dollar success.
Call of Duty is barely a single-player game, way to take a completely unrelated example to respond to a point out of context!
User avatar
Hadrianus
Warder
Warder
Posts: 516
Joined: Sun Apr 04, 2010 11:58 pm
Status: Hearing damage.

Re: Romance & frendships comfirmed?

Post by Hadrianus »

Companionship can play a part in your roleplay story. It doesn't generally have anything to do with self-esteem, and for the people it does, that is their solace.

If you don't like the romance system, then don't use it. :roll: It's really quite simple.
Johnny Guitar
Layman
Layman
Posts: 0
Joined: Tue Jun 21, 2011 5:19 am
ES Games: morrowind, oblivion.
Platform: PC

Re: Romance & frendships comfirmed?

Post by Johnny Guitar »

LtGt72 wrote:Well, there it is. A confirmation... I'll be damned.

well,........okay.........just remember, you asked for it.......(summons divine power) I DAMN THEE!!!! (thou art damned.)
TheNightFather wrote:
"Honey! Where'd I leave my sword!" "It's on the side!" "For [&@%!] *blows away half the house by shouting* "...sake?"
Could prove problematic.

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

I literally fell out of my damned chair I was laughing so damned hard!!!!!
TheNightFather wrote:
Jingles wrote:
Haravikk wrote:By the same logic; why read a book? It's just words on a page and pre-determined dialogue.
Books have plot. Betsy McPixel doesn't. Dating NPCs in video games is self-esteem rock bottom.
Haravikk wrote: and allow the player to see the NPC's as something more immersive than a bucket full of quests to
Yep, they're now bucket fulls of sex cutscenes and meat shields for throwing at dragons. Come on this is Bethesda, the princes of cardboard NPCs. These "friendships" and "romances" are going to be about as meaningful as Fable's. And therin lies the pointlessness of it. Why allow you date pixellated women when you can't even feel attached to their characters in some way. Bioware spend hours and hours of unique dialogue on trying to get players to care about their NPCs, and in the romantic sector it still generally fails to the max. In a sandbox game where you can do this with pretty much every NPC under the sun (I'm assuming) it's going to take a miracle to make it seem believable.
Haravikk wrote:befriend or romance
Man I hate it when people use romance as a verb.
Haravikk wrote:calling that nerdy is just insulting.
I'm sorry, what's NOT nerdy about dating and marrying women that consist of pixels and ones and zeros? Especially when it's not even plot driven.
*cough* Ahem *cough*

ROLEPLAYING GAME

:shock: ladies and gentlemen, the bomb has been dropped! :?
Last edited by Arch-Mage Matt on Wed Jul 20, 2011 1:13 am, edited 2 times in total.
Reason: You've already been told that double/triple posting is not acceptable, please stop.
Post Reply