Damn you Empire, damn you.

A place to discuss and ask questions about the third part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions
User avatar
Veck
Champion
Champion
Posts: 931
Joined: Wed Apr 28, 2010 9:05 pm
Status: Nutrientibus mea nuce
Location: Scatland

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Veck »

Correct, the Imperials are heavily exploiting the Dunmer. In fact, quite shockingly the Imperials often use the slaves (though not directly) to get the dirty work done, then steal all the resources of Morrowind for themselves. The only reason they were allowed to even take over Morrowind in the first place was because Vivec realised that if Talos wasn't invited in, he'd set his golem on them.

And as for the Tribunal, people who dislike them seem to be forgetting that prior to the destruction of the heart, they were actually benevolent and helpful. In my opinion, the Tribunal Temple is far better for the Dunmer than the Nine Divines that the Inperials are trying to enstate. If a Dunmer wants to worship the Imperial Cult, that's fine, he can do that. But it doesn't take a foreign occupation to make that happen.
Backfire
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 152
Joined: Sun Jul 18, 2010 7:36 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: XBox / XBox 360
Status: yes
Location: look behind you

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Backfire »

The Empire isn't controlling the political system. Like I said before, the Temple and Great Houses are the driving forces behind what happens in Morrowind. They originated before the Empire came to the island. The mines and the like weren't taken from the Dunmer, either. Sure, the Imperials have hefty investments in Morrowind, but they didn't take them by force. Also, as I said before, the Empire isn't enforcing its religious practices to any degree onto the Dunmer people. They can worship whomever they themselves choose.
"I see," said the blind man.

98% of forumers say fast travel ruins Oblivion. Put this in your signature if you're one of the 2% who realize it's optional.
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Dean »

Backfire wrote:The Empire isn't controlling the political system. Like I said before, the Temple and Great Houses are the driving forces behind what happens in Morrowind. They originated before the Empire came to the island. The mines and the like weren't taken from the Dunmer, either. Sure, the Imperials have hefty investments in Morrowind, but they didn't take them by force. Also, as I said before, the Empire isn't enforcing its religious practices to any degree onto the Dunmer people. They can worship whomever they themselves choose.
So what if they originated before? things can still be taken over. The Empire is not going to let that much freedom happen in there provinces, they seek to control the political system. Control that and you control the whole province.

And yes the mines where taken over by the Imperials, it is referred to in the game about a million times. Another reason why the Dunmer are so [&@%!] at them. The Dunmer can't fight back and claim the mines because lets face it, the Imperial army would destroy them.

I do agree with you on the religion thing though, they where not forced to take up a certain religion.
User avatar
kertaw48
Warder
Warder
Posts: 503
Joined: Wed Aug 12, 2009 6:18 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Redguard
Platform: PC
Location: Above the sky and below your feet.

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by kertaw48 »

Ha! Imperialist pig-dog lies!
Talos was scared of the Tribunal more than they were scared of him! He knew that if the Morowind's goverment fell, so too would the Ghostgate and that would be just more hard work for him in the long run. Of course the Tribunal too were eager to sign the Armistice, because let's face it Morrowind would surely fall. They didn't want another Four-Score War on their hands.

The certain amount of freedom Morrowind has, was not given, but was earned. For without the Tribunal Tamriel would become Dagoth's playground.

But now that Dagoth Ur is defeated we no longer need the crumbling Empire or the protection of it's weakly legions...

Oh and btw. it was the Tribunal that gave Talos "the golem"...
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Dean »

What I find funny is that in Morrowind Lore, It tells that the Tribunal would have won had Sotha Sil not been out of the province sorting stuff out(the usual daedra stuff, you know how it is). Almalexia had the ability to see the future in her dreams and this is how she found out that Sotha was needed. Talos had not the power or the force to take on all three of the ALMSIVI but he got them at a weak point. I would love to see Talos take on Dagoth Ur, after all he was the strongest of all four of the Chimer Divines because he embraced the dark power of the heart.
Backfire
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 152
Joined: Sun Jul 18, 2010 7:36 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: XBox / XBox 360
Status: yes
Location: look behind you

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Backfire »

I highly doubt that Dagoth Ur would have been able to take the Empire. Dagoth Ur's reign was a regional dispute. Had he tried to defeat the Empire, Dagoth Ur would have been pushed all the way back to the Heart Chamber and defeated. The forces of Vvardenfell are a simple militia in comparison to the Empire's army, but they were able to hold Ur back. It's similar to Kim Jung-Il, Hugo Chavez, or Castro: they're terrors in their own countries, but if they (individually,) tried to take the world, they would have been crushed.
"I see," said the blind man.

98% of forumers say fast travel ruins Oblivion. Put this in your signature if you're one of the 2% who realize it's optional.
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Dean »

Dagoth Ur had the power to create monstrous foes and even more monstrous diseases. He would of simply infected the Empires ranks with corprus and turned there people own against them. One of Dagoth Ur's aims was to get rid of Imperial occupation in his province. Seriously the only reason he was weakened was due to the Ghostfence and that he was sharing the connection with the heart with three other Chimer.

And there is no way you can compare a Divine being like Dagoth Ur to Kim Jung-Il. Dagoth Ur has the power to incinerate stuff with his hands, his power was vast and no normal men can stand against him and his mutant forces.
User avatar
Veck
Champion
Champion
Posts: 931
Joined: Wed Apr 28, 2010 9:05 pm
Status: Nutrientibus mea nuce
Location: Scatland

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Veck »

Bear in mind that any force defending their home has an enormous advantage, both from their familiarity with the area, and the fact that they have nowhere else to run. It's why the so-called great British army lost a war to a handful of Dutch farmers in the Boer War. I personally think that if a war started and Talos tried anything, he would probably have been crushed. The Dunmer may not have had the strong military he had, but they had the home ground, excellent experience at skirmishing, the Great Houses and Morag Tong, and two gods to fall back on. What if Sotha Sil returned from Oblivion mid-war, and brought an army of daedra with him? Although I admit I'm concerned this is going to turn into another "Men vs Elves" thread, I just wanted to put my bit in.
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Dean »

Yeah this thread is getting a bit off topic, it was suppose to continue the trend of 'why the Empire was wrong/right to invade Morrowind', let's keep it on track. I was one of the main haters of the 'war threads' and I don't need this turning into one.
Milder Despues
Warder
Warder
Posts: 470
Joined: Sun Mar 16, 2008 8:56 am

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Milder Despues »

The Empire isn't controlling the political system. Like I said before, the Temple and Great Houses are the driving forces behind what happens in Morrowind. They originated before the Empire came to the island. The mines and the like weren't taken from the Dunmer, either. Sure, the Imperials have hefty investments in Morrowind, but they didn't take them by force. Also, as I said before, the Empire isn't enforcing its religious practices to any degree onto the Dunmer people. They can worship whomever they themselves choose.
+1
And as for the Tribunal, people who dislike them seem to be forgetting that prior to the destruction of the heart, they were actually benevolent and helpful.
Well, their good deeds were in contradiction to the powers of the heart, which means that they got less and less helpful as Dagoth grew stronger and stronger. Wouldn't have worked in the long run.
User avatar
kertaw48
Warder
Warder
Posts: 503
Joined: Wed Aug 12, 2009 6:18 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Redguard
Platform: PC
Location: Above the sky and below your feet.

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by kertaw48 »

Milder Despues wrote:
And as for the Tribunal, people who dislike them seem to be forgetting that prior to the destruction of the heart, they were actually benevolent and helpful.
Well, their good deeds were in contradiction to the powers of the heart, which means that they got less and less helpful as Dagoth grew stronger and stronger. Wouldn't have worked in the long run.
This is one of the most common things people know about the Tribunal's connection to the Heart. It is false.

"The Tribunes continue to grow weaker without access to the Heart, and because of resources required to support the Ghostfence." - Dagoth Ur's Plans, A Recent Timescale of Dagoth Ur's Activities

They became weaker because the last they had access to the Heart was 2E 882...
Milder Despues
Warder
Warder
Posts: 470
Joined: Sun Mar 16, 2008 8:56 am

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Milder Despues »

This is one of the most common things people know about the Tribunal's connection to the Heart. It is false.

"The Tribunes continue to grow weaker without access to the Heart, and because of resources required to support the Ghostfence." - Dagoth Ur's Plans, A Recent Timescale of Dagoth Ur's Activities

They became weaker because the last they had access to the Heart was 2E 882...
Well, nothing is "commonly" known about the Tribunals and Dagoth connection to the heart, it is in the apographa, after all. And I don't see any reason to label it as false.

And they managed fine without the heart until they lost Sunder and Keening, so it's debateable which loss, that of the heart or tools, was the hardest blow.
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Dean »

Milder Despues wrote:Well, their good deeds were in contradiction to the powers of the heart, which means that they got less and less helpful as Dagoth grew stronger and stronger. Wouldn't have worked in the long run.
This may be true as it is referred to in the game, but they where still willing to help there people by fighting the darkness which came from the heart. As Kertaw said, they where only becoming weaker faster because they had no access to there divine source. Yeah they would eventually lose all power but that would take Millennium's to happen.

Also if you all really want to talk about the ALMSIVI in depth then I will direct you here:

The reason we have a Lore forum :P

Lets get back on track, why do you guys and gals think that the Empire should of invaded Morrowind? Wouldn't you be [&@%!] at someone doing that to you?

I have heard people say that this stuff happens all the time, and it does I won't dispute the fact. The thing is though, does that make it right just because it happens a lot?
Milder Despues
Warder
Warder
Posts: 470
Joined: Sun Mar 16, 2008 8:56 am

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Milder Despues »

This may be true as it is referred to in the game,
Which is what one should go by, and not guesswork. But fine, let's change tack. :)
Lets get back on track, why do you guys and gals think that the Empire should of invaded Morrowind? Wouldn't you be [&@%!] at someone doing that to you?
Morrowind was peacefully integrated into the Empire, or, the Empire flexed, and the Dunmer caved. There was no invasion.

My thinking is, who is to say that it's not okay to do what the Empire did? I would be [&@%!] if someone invaded my land, but if it was in the same manner like this Empire/Resdaynia situation, then I would be more [&@%!] at my fellow dumner who couldn't agree on anything than at the Empire for expanding. Can't whine about the imperials taking what they can by force, things like that is human and the only way to quell it is apparently to pick up yer pitchfork and smack 'em back to where they came from.

And another thought, if we (the people behind the screens) lived in a different time I don't think this would have raised any eyebrows since territory were often swapped or conquered.
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Dean »

Milder Despues wrote: Which is what one should go by, and not guesswork. But fine, let's change tack. :)
True, but then again most of the stuff in-game leaves things open for discussion. I like that there are many different theories in-game of what is happening, it's very realistic. :P
Milder Despues wrote:Morrowind was peacefully integrated into the Empire, or, the Empire flexed, and the Dunmer caved. There was no invasion.
The Dunmer caved because Almalexia saw a vision of the future in her dreams (divine beings get handy stuff like that). They decided it was better in the long run then just getting wiped out completely. It may have not been an invasion exactly but the intention to do so was there all along, if the Dunmer hadn't complied they would of invaded in a heartbeat.
Milder Despues wrote:Can't whine about the imperials taking what they can by force, things like that is human and the only way to quell it is apparently to pick up yer pitchfork and smack 'em back to where they came from.

And another thought, if we (the people behind the screens) lived in a different time I don't think this would have raised any eyebrows since territory were often swapped or conquered.
It may be Human, but the thought is actually one of greed. Does that make it acceptable to you? If we lived in another time yes this would of been the norm, but what I am talking about is with our understanding on Human rights today would you agree with it? This is more to do with your views then the views of people at the time.
User avatar
Veck
Champion
Champion
Posts: 931
Joined: Wed Apr 28, 2010 9:05 pm
Status: Nutrientibus mea nuce
Location: Scatland

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Veck »

Of course, we'll probably be arguing about a similar thing when the next ES comes out about why the province in the game shouldn't have been invaded. And of course, as I am now a revolutionary, I will say that all the lies about the empire improving Morrowind and allowing free worship is filthy Imperialist propaganda. Were it not for the Mages Guild, the empire would immediately ban daedra worship across Tamriel, and they would probably tear down the Tribunal Temple, taking Houses Indoril and Redoran with it.

Note that as I am a zealous revolutionary in this post, my views to not reflect the views of Bethesda, UESP or its affiliates, if it has any.
User avatar
RobotNixon
Warder
Warder
Posts: 507
Joined: Sat Oct 03, 2009 6:16 am
ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Battlespire, Morrowind, Tribunal, Bloodmoon, Oblivion, Knights of The Nine, Shivering Isles, Skyrim, Dawnguard, Dragonborn, Elder Scrolls Online
Platform: PC
Status: Just came back, from outer space.
Other Profiles: AdultPuppetShow
Location: Space Texas

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by RobotNixon »

Newsound wrote: It may be Human, but the thought is actually one of greed. Does that make it acceptable to you? If we lived in another time yes this would of been the norm, but what I am talking about is with our understanding on Human rights today would you agree with it? This is more to do with your views then the views of people at the time.
The weak often complain after they are conquered.

C'est la vie.
Count to four. Inhale. Count to four. Exhale.
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Dean »

RobotNixon wrote:
Newsound wrote: It may be Human, but the thought is actually one of greed. Does that make it acceptable to you? If we lived in another time yes this would of been the norm, but what I am talking about is with our understanding on Human rights today would you agree with it? This is more to do with your views then the views of people at the time.
The weak often complain after they are conquered.

C'est la vie.
I wouldn't say you can call an entire species weak because they got conquered by a an Empire which is much bigger in size. The Dunmer complain about being conquered because they didn't actually want to war with anyone, it was not there thought to go and kick up fuss in Cyrodil. They have a right to moan if you look at the facts.
User avatar
RobotNixon
Warder
Warder
Posts: 507
Joined: Sat Oct 03, 2009 6:16 am
ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Battlespire, Morrowind, Tribunal, Bloodmoon, Oblivion, Knights of The Nine, Shivering Isles, Skyrim, Dawnguard, Dragonborn, Elder Scrolls Online
Platform: PC
Status: Just came back, from outer space.
Other Profiles: AdultPuppetShow
Location: Space Texas

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by RobotNixon »

Well maybe they should have "kicked up a fuss".

If they had fought back and lost I would be able to understand their plight, but they didn't do anything.
Count to four. Inhale. Count to four. Exhale.
User avatar
Veck
Champion
Champion
Posts: 931
Joined: Wed Apr 28, 2010 9:05 pm
Status: Nutrientibus mea nuce
Location: Scatland

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Veck »

RobotNixon wrote: The weak often complain after they are conquered.

C'est la vie.
Maybe it's just me, but I feel that it takes some serious cajones to stand up to your conquerors.
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Dean »

RobotNixon wrote:Well maybe they should have "kicked up a fuss".

If they had fought back and lost I would be able to understand their plight, but they didn't do anything.
So your simply saying, kill others because they might end up killing you? that is a depressing way to look at everything. :|

A I explained earlier the Lore of Morrowind states that Almalexia saw an inevitable defeat at the hands of the Empire. Yes sometimes lore can be made up and the like, but she was a demi-god I wouldn't say that is the most ridiculous power she would have. They where clever in the fact that they signed the treaty over with a bit more rights then most provinces, and without the need of bloodshed.
User avatar
RobotNixon
Warder
Warder
Posts: 507
Joined: Sat Oct 03, 2009 6:16 am
ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Battlespire, Morrowind, Tribunal, Bloodmoon, Oblivion, Knights of The Nine, Shivering Isles, Skyrim, Dawnguard, Dragonborn, Elder Scrolls Online
Platform: PC
Status: Just came back, from outer space.
Other Profiles: AdultPuppetShow
Location: Space Texas

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by RobotNixon »

Veck wrote:
RobotNixon wrote: The weak often complain after they are conquered.

C'est la vie.
Maybe it's just me, but I feel that it takes some serious cajones to stand up to your conquerors.
If they stand up against their conquerors they cease to be weak.

The Dunmer haven't even tried.
Newsound wrote:
RobotNixon wrote:Well maybe they should have "kicked up a fuss".
If they had fought back and lost I would be able to understand their plight, but they didn't do anything.
So your simply saying, kill others because they might end up killing you? that is a depressing way to look at everything. :|
If you want to live in freedom you have to be willing to pay for it with blood.

Call me backwards and overly conservative if you must, but it's a belief that is paramount to my very being.
Count to four. Inhale. Count to four. Exhale.
User avatar
Veck
Champion
Champion
Posts: 931
Joined: Wed Apr 28, 2010 9:05 pm
Status: Nutrientibus mea nuce
Location: Scatland

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Veck »

The idea that war is in the human nature is simply not true. We are sapient, so our decisions are not written in our DNA. It is our choice whether war is necessary.
User avatar
RobotNixon
Warder
Warder
Posts: 507
Joined: Sat Oct 03, 2009 6:16 am
ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Battlespire, Morrowind, Tribunal, Bloodmoon, Oblivion, Knights of The Nine, Shivering Isles, Skyrim, Dawnguard, Dragonborn, Elder Scrolls Online
Platform: PC
Status: Just came back, from outer space.
Other Profiles: AdultPuppetShow
Location: Space Texas

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by RobotNixon »

Veck wrote:The idea that war is in the human nature is simply not true. We are sapient, so our decisions are not written in our DNA. It is our choice whether war is necessary.
When thousands of other people decide that it is their choice to invade or war with your nation,
your decision to not fight just makes it easier for them.

It doesn't matter what you think, weapons aren't sentient, and most of the people that wield them aren't philosophers.
Count to four. Inhale. Count to four. Exhale.
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: Damn you Empire, damn you.

Post by Dean »

Newsound wrote:A I explained earlier the Lore of Morrowind states that Almalexia saw an inevitable defeat at the hands of the Empire. Yes sometimes lore can be made up and the like, but she was a demi-god I wouldn't say that is the most ridiculous power she would have. They where clever in the fact that they signed the treaty over with a bit more rights then most provinces, and without the need of bloodshed.
@RobotNixon- if you had bothered to read this you would understand why they didn't fight. War is not the right way if you can save your people from a slaughter that is inevitable.
Locked